Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.

adamjackson

macrumors 68020
Jul 9, 2008
2,340
4,741
@adamjackson If you did a Cmd + Opt + O + F, that will put you into Open Firmware, which is a CLI. Unless you entered multi-boot, how did you boot from a drive with a penguin logo? Seeing that should have required the boot picker, which is accessed with just Opt (not Opt + Cmd + O + F).

You can burn them to disc if you wish, but if you followed the Wiki's USB boot instructions, installing via USB is usually faster and pretty straightforward.

Also, the Ubuntu 16.04 download offered in Distributions is supposed to be of 16.04.6, not 16.04.5.

The issue I'm having is specifically this - https://askubuntu.com/questions/671159/bootable-usb-needs-cd-rom

ubuntu's installer is asking for a CD-ROM and I was in the OF Picker as you described. It definitely recognizes the USB drive has ubuntu on it and goes through the installer loader.
 

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
The issue I'm having is specifically this - https://askubuntu.com/questions/671159/bootable-usb-needs-cd-rom

ubuntu's installer is asking for a CD-ROM and I was in the OF Picker as you described. It definitely recognizes the USB drive has ubuntu on it and goes through the installer loader.

What happened when you tried:

Once I get the "Your installation CD-ROM couldn't be mounted..." message and I'm back at the main Ubuntu Server install screen, I simply plugged the USB thumbdrive out, then plugged it in again, and then after pressing the "detect CD" option, I got "The CD-ROM autodetection was successful... The installation will now continue." ... and so the installation continued.

or likewise,

  1. Start up live CD.
  2. Without touching anything open a terminal and type:
    sudo umount -l -r -f /cdrom

  3. Install Ubuntu without any issue.

as mentioned in the thread?

Otherwise, I believe we've encountered this problem before (somewhere in the bowels of this thread, probably around last April). I think you're supposed to use a different USB drive, and if that fails, try a different port.
 
  • Like
Reactions: adamjackson

Frank Ciampa Champ

macrumors newbie
Jan 28, 2020
11
0
Maine
did a fresh install of Ubuntu 14.04 and it refuses to see my audio chip. I have an 2005 G5 dual 2.0. I listed installed devices and sure enough it states that audio was not found. Is there a way to make it see the audio??
 

adamjackson

macrumors 68020
Jul 9, 2008
2,340
4,741
What happened when you tried:



or likewise,



as mentioned in the thread?

Otherwise, I believe we've encountered this problem before (somewhere in the bowels of this thread, probably around last April). I think you're supposed to use a different USB drive, and if that fails, try a different port.

I wanted to follow up. Burning a DVD of the ISO fixed my issue. Now I'm having problems installing "Yaboot" which is required in the install. I'm going to keep tinkering with it.
 

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
I wanted to follow up. Burning a DVD of the ISO fixed my issue. Now I'm having problems installing "Yaboot" which is required in the install. I'm going to keep tinkering with it.

What errors are appearing?
 

sheich0608

macrumors newbie
Mar 15, 2019
25
12
Hey all, looking to test drive Linux of some sort on my PB G4 once I can figure out the USB/flashing issues in Catalina. I frequently use Zotero, which you may be familiar with (citation manager with browser integration). It's open source, and I can compile it from source here: https://github.com/zotero/zotero

There's a Linux binary already but of course it's for x86_64. Does it look like this could be compiled from source for PPC? The browser extension should work with Firefox.
 

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
There's a Linux binary already but of course it's for x86_64. Does it look like this could be compiled from source for PPC? The browser extension should work with Firefox.

No harm in trying with whatever distro you pick.
 

repairedCheese

macrumors 6502a
Jan 13, 2020
632
835
Hey all, looking to test drive Linux of some sort on my PB G4 once I can figure out the USB/flashing issues in Catalina. I frequently use Zotero, which you may be familiar with (citation manager with browser integration). It's open source, and I can compile it from source here: https://github.com/zotero/zotero

There's a Linux binary already but of course it's for x86_64. Does it look like this could be compiled from source for PPC? The browser extension should work with Firefox.
Since this is for a G4, you're going to have a bit of a challenge with the browser integration. See, we don't really have a full 32-bit ppc version of Firefox, we have Firefox forks. It has something to do with not being able to build FF on 32-bit ppc, I'm not really sure of the specifics. But it does mean you're going to be stuck using older browser extensions, and assuming that software can build, it might not like a version of the extension from around 2018.

If you can test out your current setup with something like Palemoon or Basilisk, which I believe are the origins of some of our Firefox ports, you'll have a better idea what you're up against.
 
Last edited:

sheich0608

macrumors newbie
Mar 15, 2019
25
12
Since this is for a G4, you're going to have a bit of a challenge with the browser integration. See, we don't really have a full 32-bit ppc version of Firefox, we have Firefox forks. It has something to do with not being able to build FF on 32-bit ppc, I'm not really sure of the specifics. But it does mean you're going to be stuck using older browser extensions, and assuming that software can build, it might not like a version of the extension from around 2018.

If you can test out your current setup with something like Palemoon or Basilisk, which I believe are the origins of some of our Firefox ports, you'll have a better idea what you're up against.
Thank you for this explainer. Question: the current Zotero browser extension for Firefox requires version 52 and up, which I think it covered by some of the Linux FF-based browsers, right? Maybe InterWeb?

EDIT: Ah, I see now it's the web extension issue. I assume no PPC browser supports those, right?
 
Last edited:

wicknix

macrumors 68030
Jun 4, 2017
2,621
5,306
Wisconsin, USA
InterWeb has *some* early webext support, but it's not fully implemented. With that said, it's probably the best choice you'll have of it possibly working with any of the ppc32 browsers. It's the closest to 'true' firefox, while the other forks are more locked down and stripped of webrtc, eme, webext, etc for added security.

Cheers
 

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
Finally overhauled the Software section, adding InterWeb, and updating Arctic Fox + SpiderWeb / SpiderMail. Also adjusted several other things for a better flow, like integrating [trusted=yes] instead of archive keyrings from USB sticks... among other tweaks.

Void adoption is definitely in the pipeline. Just not today, or next week.

Also, I would really appreciate if anyone else helped update this mammoth resource, whenever time allows. Thank you very much.
 

wnlewis

macrumors regular
Jan 20, 2017
180
45
Newton, Kansas
Finally overhauled the Software section, adding InterWeb, and updating Arctic Fox + SpiderWeb / SpiderMail. Also adjusted several other things for a better flow, like integrating [trusted=yes] instead of archive keyrings from USB sticks... among other tweaks.

Void adoption is definitely in the pipeline. Just not today, or next week.

Also, I would really appreciate if anyone else helped update this mammoth resource, whenever time allows. Thank you very much.
I'm not quite sure what I might be able to do, but I'm willing to help.
 
  • Like
Reactions: z970

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
I'm not quite sure what I might be able to do, but I'm willing to help.

Just update the software titles and their links as needed when new versions are released, amend applicable sections that could be improved, especially when new info surfaces, and make any change you think would make things easier to do, instead of the previous way, or the predetermined way.

This goes for everyone; test and verify every piece of information added, and keep all formatting uniform, following the same basic goal. Otherwise, it's open season. The entire project is after all, in every sense of the word, a community effort. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: dextructor

Demontager

macrumors newbie
Sep 24, 2017
15
5
I got G4 with MacOSX 10.4.11 installed and i want to change original spinable 80 GB HDD to 256 GB SSD (already got IDE-SATA adapter).
I dont have original MacOS installation CD disk, so how would be the easiest way to install MacOS on SSD drive? My intention is to install 10.5.8 since it is the latest supported.
 

wnlewis

macrumors regular
Jan 20, 2017
180
45
Newton, Kansas
I got G4 with MacOSX 10.4.11 installed and i want to change original spinable 80 GB HDD to 256 GB SSD (already got IDE-SATA adapter).
I dont have original MacOS installation CD disk, so how would be the easiest way to install MacOS on SSD drive? My intention is to install 10.5.8 since it is the latest supported.
What type of G4 do you have? I have a Sawtooth (AGP) G4. G4's are 32 bit machines. That means that more advanced software may not run on them, such as the drive health software for an SSD. In terms of an SSD one of the best for the G4 series is the Samsung EVO 840. They are no longer made, but you should be able to pick up one in good condition used. Note: The condition of the drive will have to be checked using an newer, Intel based Mac, or a PC. As to installing an SSD, they install (physically) pretty much the same way as a regular HD (spinning type). They will need an adapter in order to go into the regular "sled" that a standard HD normally takes. There are a couple of ways to make the data connection to an SSD. You can get an SATA to IDE adapter from places such as Operator Headgap and OWC. That allows you to go from an SATA style information exchange to an IDE information exchange. That is an easy, not expensive way to do things. You will notice a good "kick" in the speed when you go to an SSD. There are a couple of downsides to going that way. You will be restricted to the smaller drives that the G4 IDE bus can handle due to logical block addressing (LBA) limitations, and you will be restricted to slightly slower speeds due to the speed of that bus. The alternative - which I have used successfully - is to get an SATA adapter card that goes into a PCI slot and accesses the PCI bus. Sonnet made some cards with one, two and four internal SATA ports. Some times you can find them, some times you can't - The OS 9 Lives forum is a good place to look -. Firmtek/Seritek does - did(?) I have not checked recently - make an excellent card with four internal ports. You will also want to get the power adapter cables for the SSD drive, from standard Molex to SSD style. If you want to continue to use your HD drive, you may want to try one of Firmtek's IDE to SATA adapter cards. On an ultra drive HD you will get faster throughput. Also, PLEASE NOTE, the PCI bus and the Firmtek SATA card, treat IDE drives as though they were SCSI drives. What that means is that the size limitation of the IDE bus does not apply. And that the only size limitation you have for either an IDE or SATA drive is the limitations imposed by a 32 bit system. The LBA limitations of the IDE bus, DO NOT APPLY. You can have a 1 Tb drive in a G4 (SATA or IDE on the PCI bus) and it will read all of it perfectly well. However, I have found that, with IDE drives, it is still wiser to partition the drive into segments of 127.8 Gb or slightly less. If the head stops at the wrong place, you can run into serious drive partition map problems. It can be solved, but it's not fun. Installing your operating system is no problem either. For 10.5.8, on a G4 the biggest difficulty is the speed of the processor. If your processor is up around 877 MHz you will probably have pretty good performance - comparable to Tiger, 10.4.11. If it is less than that, you will need a little program called Leopard assist. It makes the 10.5.8 software think it is running on a 1 GHz machine. If you have a 1 GHz or faster processor upgrade in your G4, do the following. Download the image for 10.5.6 from the Macintosh Garden. Go to the Internet, and get Coriollis Systems iPartion for 10.4.11 (oh yes, send the fellow who designed the software some money as a thank you). Use that to split your current drive into three partitions, one large enough for Leopard and data, one large enough for the current system and data, and one large enough for the disk image of Leopard (I think it will work in 80 Gb as three partitions). The reason I recommend iPartition is that it will let you partition and resize your existing drive without wiping out your data. Once that is done - and it may take quite a bit of time - use disk utility to "restore" the disk image to the smallest partition you have made. Also, if you have a slower processor, put Leopard assist on that partition. If the processor is slow, Go to Leopard assist and start the process to install 10.5.6. It should fool the Leopard install into thinking your machine is fast enough. Choose to install Leopard on the new largest partition you have made and wait until it finishes. If you have a fast enough processor 1 GHz or faster, go to Preferences, startup disk, and choose the disk image. When that comes up, then choose the new partition you have made - for Leopard and data - and install Leopard. Use the software update and update until you have completed the process of getting to 10.5.8. Now, why didn't I say to use a DVD or a USB? G4's, especially the Sawtooth G4's are twitchy beasts. Some will, most won't boot from a USB. They will boot from firewire, if you have a firewire drive. USB boot normally has to be done from the firmware command line and you have to provide the exact path to the exact USB port and hope that the computer likes what you have done. Sometimes it works, most of the time, it doesn't. The G4's are designed to boot off a DVD. If you want to do a complete system, you have to have a super drive capable of dual layer DVD's - and dual layer DVD's - and in good condition, and first you have to make the DVD and make sure it is good (unless you buy a 10.5.8 install). Sometimes they are, sometimes they aren't. The drive itself must be in very good condition. And the installation process can be very slow. You can use the single, reduced DVD option from Macintosh Garden, but I was never able to get it to work correctly. Then you will have to bring the minimized system up to what the complete system is supposed to be. Not a project for the faint of heart. The disk image on one partition and installing to another partition, is very nearly foolproof. If you want to upgrade your processor to a 1 GHz or better, you have a couple of options, you can go with a single processor, such as the one I purchased, or you can go with a dual processor. If you go with a dual processor, you must have a Uni North = 7 or better motherboard for your particular G4. You can find those from time to time. If your machine is already a dual processor machine, then you just need to decide if you want to spend in the neighborhood of $250 to $450 for one of the very nice dual processor upgrades. I've not yet had the deep pockets to do that, but I am still looking for a Newer Technologies MaxPower 7448 dual processor upgrade - supposedly the creme de la creme of processor upgrades. I have been well pleased with the results so far. Once you have done these things, you will want to get and install TenFourFox, and the updates for TenFourFox (FireFox for G4/G5 PowerPC) you will find on these boards, and TenFourBird (Email). Best wishes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CooperBox

Demontager

macrumors newbie
Sep 24, 2017
15
5
@wnlewis
Thank you man for so detailed explanation! I got imac g4 1.25Ghz and 20 inch display version. Today i have successfully installed 10.5.1 and updated to 10.5.8 MacOSX. I just found dmg image file and burned it with SimpleBurns to 8gb DVD-R.
Installation was made to 256GB Samsung 850 Pro SSD which connected to IDE bus via SATA - IDE adapter. Speed boost is notable but not so high, because it anyways limited to low CPU power. For me was important to get rid spin noise from original hdd as i plan to keep G4 in my bedroom. My usage scenario is listen to a music via harmon karbon speakers and i might try to play some old school games like Age of Empires, Stronghold etc. Also tried TenFourFox and its quite fine for text browsing, and not heavily flash overloaded websites, so might will use it for this too. BTW i got 3 modern Macs at home besides Linux and Windows PCs, but I like G4 for its notable great look and retro feelings.
 

wnlewis

macrumors regular
Jan 20, 2017
180
45
Newton, Kansas
@wnlewis
Thank you man for so detailed explanation! I got imac g4 1.25Ghz and 20 inch display version. Today i have successfully installed 10.5.1 and updated to 10.5.8 MacOSX. I just found dmg image file and burned it with SimpleBurns to 8gb DVD-R.
Installation was made to 256GB Samsung 850 Pro SSD which connected to IDE bus via SATA - IDE adapter. Speed boost is notable but not so high, because it anyways limited to low CPU power. For me was important to get rid spin noise from original hdd as i plan to keep G4 in my bedroom. My usage scenario is listen to a music via harmon karbon speakers and i might try to play some old school games like Age of Empires, Stronghold etc. Also tried TenFourFox and its quite fine for text browsing, and not heavily flash overloaded websites, so might will use it for this too. BTW i got 3 modern Macs at home besides Linux and Windows PCs, but I like G4 for its notable great look and retro feelings.
Glad you got it up and running! Doesn't sound like you needed much help. With the processor at or above 1 GHz, Leopard installs with no trouble. Sounds like you have the DL DVD's. I have none, but do have a larger hard drive (2 HD's and the one SSD). So I used that. I like that you are using Harmon-Kardon speakers. The G4's/G5's do have a nice look. My current project is to get a modern distro of Linux running on it. So far no success.
Best wishes.
 

CooperBox

macrumors 68000
@wnlewis
Thank you man for so detailed explanation! I got imac g4 1.25Ghz and 20 inch display version. Today i have successfully installed 10.5.1 and updated to 10.5.8 MacOSX. I just found dmg image file and burned it with SimpleBurns to 8gb DVD-R.
Installation was made to 256GB Samsung 850 Pro SSD which connected to IDE bus via SATA - IDE adapter. Speed boost is notable but not so high, because it anyways limited to low CPU power. For me was important to get rid spin noise from original hdd as i plan to keep G4 in my bedroom. My usage scenario is listen to a music via harmon karbon speakers and i might try to play some old school games like Age of Empires, Stronghold etc. Also tried TenFourFox and its quite fine for text browsing, and not heavily flash overloaded websites, so might will use it for this too. BTW i got 3 modern Macs at home besides Linux and Windows PCs, but I like G4 for its notable great look and retro feelings.
You have a fine iMac there! Would you mind sharing exactly which SATA - IDE adapter you used (with a photo and/or link if possible), as with the G4 iMac models my experience (this post) shows that not all the adapters are compatible due to the way the connector's offset pin slot is handed. I'm interested to know the make and price of the adapter you used, as this info could assist others wishing to upgrade these very capable iMac's.
 

sparty411

macrumors 6502a
Nov 13, 2018
553
501
For anyone using a Windows machine, I've successfully written @wicknix's Ubuntu images to USB via Rufus, and booted them on my Powerbook G4. This is useful if you don't have access to a Linux command line to use DD.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wicknix and z970

sparty411

macrumors 6502a
Nov 13, 2018
553
501
Sure, I'll add it when I get home from work later on this evening.
Err, yeah, I can't recommend anyone use the Rufus method. It worked on my Powerbook, but all of my other machines fail to boot. Not sure what the deal is.
 

RogerWilco6502

macrumors 68000
Jan 12, 2019
1,823
1,944
Tír na nÓg
Err, yeah, I can't recommend anyone use the Rufus method. It worked on my Powerbook, but all of my other machines fail to boot. Not sure what the deal is.
Something in the way Rufus writes the image I think. I use Etcher for my USB flashing needs and it works well. I've always used either it or dd to write images and neither of those have failed me.

 
  • Like
Reactions: sparty411 and z970

z970

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
Removed Awesome window manager in favor of i3, a slightly lighterweight, more configurable WM.

Removed the Other directory for simplified navigation.

Made other adjustments for better reading.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.