Anybody else feeling like this after seeing them side by side?
I'm kind of the opposite: I was prepared to be all in on the nano, but when I saw them side by side at a flagship Apple Store, I was ultimately convinced that glossy is for me.
The nano certainly impresses with the way it kills reflections dead. It's like every pixel on the screen is made of colored Vantablack that absorbs incoming light into nanotubes.
However, when not facing the nano directly, the colors fade quite noticeably. The screen also isn't as bright overall relative to the glossy (though of course still a very bright screen), and seems to not have the same pop.
Looking close up at the screen surface texture, it still has the "brushed with steel wool" appearance that matte screens have, not the "invisible to the human eye" appearance I first imagined when hearing "nano".
And for text, a lot of what I do involves reading traditional black text on a white background. I spent a good 20-30 mins doing just this at the Apple Store, comparing the same content and going between the two monitors. Text was noticeably sharper on the glossy and didn't have the matte screen fuzziness that I'd hoped would somehow be possible (again, a scattering surface that might be invisible to the human eye).
Although I would see these as distinct compromises, if you are in an environment with bright lights or a window behind you, they are quite probably worth it for the sheer benefit of removing reflections. After all, what good is a sharp screen if opaque white blobs obscure it, or reflections compete with the screen content.
Apple is very clever showing both screens in the bright lights of the Apple Store. In the store I was at (Sydney), the side of the store is literally a
glass wall on the side of the street, with summer sunlight streaming in, and the display was set up just inside the pavement (far left table).
In such bright lighting, the glossy was virtually unusable. I actually had to turn it to face the store interior, so it "only" had Apple's 1000 lux overhead lights to cope with.
The nano was perfect in the bright light and looked like a very high res newspaper.
For me, I control the lighting in my environment and don't need to accept the compromises of the nano, so glossy is the one for me.
forums.macrumors.com
