I just wanted to say that I also use the star system to rate my music, so you are not alone in this.
The star system is great; sometimes I like a song A LOT!! and rate it 5 stars. Sometimes I like a song more than average, so it gets 3-4 stars. Sometimes I don't really care for a song but still want it in my library to play on certain occasions for other people, so it gets 1-2 stars.
It's a system that works really well and I'll be upset if it goes away. Simply hitting the heart for a track isn't enough; there are different degrees of liking something.
EDIT: I should add that if this does go away we may be able to replicate it with playlists. Just make playlists "5 stars", "4 stars", etc... and populate them as appropriate. You can even use temporary smart playlists to initially populate them. It's clunky, but may be a solution if they take this feature away from us.
I agree with this 100%.
I have been using the star rating system since I first downloaded iTunes in 2004 because it's a great system. It's perfect for evaluating how much you like a song, and then using that evaluation to return to the music you love (i.e. via Smart Playlists).
I like the simpler design of the new iOS 10 Music app, but it's still missing a fundamental piece of the puzzle. My biggest criticism of the app still remains - it's too focused around discovery. With all the curation and Beats Playlists and 'For You' suggestions, Apple Music is built around the desire to always suggest something new to you and it doesn't seem to be built with real music lovers in mind.
As a fellow star rating user, I think you'll really agree with
this article on the matter.
Essentially, the problem with the iOS 9 Music app wasn't simply the complex interface. Rather, it's the fact that it focused far too heavily on discovery, at the expense of playback of your own music library. The whole thing was designed to always recommend new music to you, but there was very little in the way of design or features that centered around allowing you to play
the music you want to hear.
I firmly believe that the #1 feature that Apple Music is lacking is some sort of filter system or a modern equivalent of Smart Playlists, to allow you to specify characteristics
from your own music library that you want to hear. If I want to specify the artist, genre, star ratings, and so on, I should be able to input parameters and have it auto-generate a playlist -
from the music I already know and love. Apple Music didn't do that in iOS 9 and it still doesn't do that in iOS 10. It's all about suggesting things that you don't know, and it places very little emphasis on organizing and playing back things you already know and love.