Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

newellj

macrumors G3
Oct 15, 2014
8,154
3,047
East of Eden
Sorry to hear that you have problems. Yosemite has been very stable and well-performing for me and my colleagues. I maintain a user base of around two dozens Macs, most of them running Yosemite by now, and I haven't got a single serious complain about the OS.

BTW, I used to have bad WiFi issues with Mavericks. Yosemite has fixed that. And Safari and Mail are very much usable, unlike Snow Leopard/Lion.

No problems here with Yo (other than the cartoon interface... :roll eyes: ) and like you it solved problems with Mavericks (sleep/wake issues) that I hadn't been able to solve. So it's been an improvement for my machines.
 

bobr1952

macrumors 68020
Jan 21, 2008
2,040
39
Melbourne, FL
It is interesting that with the limited (compared to Windows) configuration options available, that some have so many major problems--and others (like myself) had a seamless update from Mavericks. :confused:
 

Queen6

macrumors G4
Yosemite has been a non issue on all our Mac`s, Apple will likely continue to improve on it. Not wild about the UI, equally it works, if it doesn't for you just revert to Mavericks, as realistically no one is so concerned, least of all Apple.

Q-6
 

JoeLr

macrumors newbie
Sep 20, 2014
15
0
:shrug: I like Yosemite better than Mavericks on my mid/late 2012 rMBP. I don't doubt that others have had issues, but thankfully, none for me.
 

Cassady

macrumors 6502a
Jul 7, 2012
568
205
Sqornshellous
Double shrug. Loving Yosemite, on an upgraded mid-2012 cMBP. Rock-solid.

Judging by this thread - am I obligated to put the above in a 4000 word tome?
 

Mr. Buzzcut

macrumors 65816
Jul 25, 2011
1,037
488
Ohio
TL;DR. What OS was as big or bigger disaster than Yosemite? Lion. Major issues with things not working. Had to hard boot due to not coming out of sleep was a real gem of a bug.

Yosemite has had some quirks but I wouldn't call it a disaster.
 

dav1dd

macrumors regular
Oct 25, 2013
200
171
Oz
It is interesting that with the limited (compared to Windows) configuration options available, that some have so many major problems--and others (like myself) had a seamless update from Mavericks. :confused:

I have a theory that the problems only occur with 2013+ models. May well be wrong though.
 

Irishman

macrumors 68040
Nov 2, 2006
3,449
859
I agree with the OP.
For me, alarm bells went off as soon as they started offering the OS for free. From a business perspective, that means less resources will be allocated to a cost centre that literally produces no income. You don't get rich by pouring a lot of money into something that generates no income. Otherwise, how can you be the world's most valuable company?
Common sense, really.

I still have my Snow Leopard disk that I paid $90 for and it operates fine on my 2006 MB. On the other hand I upgraded to 10.10.2 yesterday morning, found it broke my wifi, and then rolled back using Time Machine last night.

Did alarm bells similarly go off for you when iOS went free? Why or why not?
 

Paradoxally

macrumors 68000
Feb 4, 2011
1,987
2,898
People were saying the same thing about Mavericks this time last year.

In a year, people will be complaining about OS X Diablo and wanting to go back to the rock solid 10.10.5.

You've posted this like 500 times on this forum...let's get creative, shall we?
 

Ethosik

Contributor
Oct 21, 2009
8,142
7,120
Seriously, if you depend on your system THAT MUCH for business, follow this simple advice: DO NOT UPGRADE!

Why do you think there are businesses still on Windows XP? It is because those businesses got crappy developers that only coded for a specific OS or browser. Upgrading would cause their applications to break. They TESTED it.

TEST the operating system before you upgrade. If your system cannot suffer from any issues, simply do not upgrade.

Why did you upgrade in the first place? If it aint broke, don't fix it. It is not like you were on Leopard, Mavericks is still okay to use.
 

aristobrat

macrumors G5
Oct 14, 2005
12,292
1,403
For those of you having a smooth, trouble-free Yosemite experience and are obviously not interested in reading about or are selectively unaware of the 'nightmares' other people are having with this operating system as discussed extensively on this forum and in many other fields - (music, business, printing, photography, communication, wi-fi etc etc)
I've only been a member of this forum since 2005, but since then I can't recall a single OS X or iOS release that hasn't caused 'nightmares' for some, including professionals in various fields.

What version of OS X are you on, that you feel is the most stable? Because I can pretty much guarantee you that if you spend 5-10 minutes using the forum search function, you're going to find people having similar issues with that version's .0, .1, and .2 versions that people are having with Yosemite.
 

scaredpoet

macrumors 604
Apr 6, 2007
6,628
360
For those of you having a smooth, trouble-free Yosemite experience and are obviously not interested in reading about or are selectively unaware of the 'nightmares' other people are having with this operating system as discussed extensively on this forum and in many other fields -

I'm sorry you're having trouble. Really, I am. But the only selective bias here is in assuming that because you and some others are having trouble, that it MUST be everyone else - the numerous people who are finding Yosemite to be quite fine - that are somehow using it wrong.

So, rather than troubleshoot, you rant... great. Feel better? Because this has not fixed your broken mac, and is unlikely to in the near future. Screaming about what you feel are Apple's problems and how they just aren't listening doesn't make them listen. Giving feedback where Apple actually does listen, including clearly explaining what your problems are, will stand a better chance.

No, I mean it. Writing a wall of text that only amounts to "Yosemite sucks and Apple sucks and THEY BETTER FIX IT OR ELSE!" does not give anyone enough info to fix your issue.


(music, business, printing, photography, communication, wi-fi etc etc)


Yeah, see, this doesn't help. Apple doesn't make apps called music, photography or communication. Printing it does do. WiFi it does do. So, you should probably detail to them your problems with printing and WiFi.

is this just a 'rant' or a not very subtle communication to the powers that be at Apple that it's users deserve something better from a so-called system upgrade.

Considering that "the powers that be" at Apple are not going to be hanging out in this forum, and aren't going to read through your wall of text, it looks like this is just a rant. Sorry to break it to you.

We need bare minimum - 1) Easy installation

I've installed Yosemite on three personally owned Macs, and just deployed it to about 50 iMacs at work. Unlike Windows, I didn't need to resort to a third party software package to set up my own image or deal with image servers to deploy. I just run an update, clicked the install button and walked away. Easy peasy.

What problems did you have that made yours not easy to install?

2)The Basics intact and working,

So, does this mean your mac is no longer booting? Or something higher level. Again, "it doesn't work" doesn't cut it.

3) Connection (within a reasonable time) to all our old and young(!) apps, plug-ins, printers, wi-fi networks etc - that means liaising with these producers in a respectful, cooperative manner well in advance of launch day so they can have time to prepare drivers that will integrate seamlessly with the new operating system

Funny you should say that, because Yosemite was probably by far under the widest beta test I've seen for any piece of Apple software. Even non developers had official betas they could try out, without paying a dime.

And to be fair, the first beta of Yosemite was a real dog. VERY unstable. And then it improved dramatically leading up to the launch, no doubt because of some of the feedback they received.

So, I'm not sure how much more liaising Apple could've done here, save for Craig Federighi personally doing the coding for each and every developer that needed to update. Devs and ordinary users had PLENTY of access to Yosemite ahead of its official launch.

The sooner Apple wakes up to that fact and gets it's arrogant head out of its ass and starts to work with companies,

Again, explain what you want done here. It's not like Yosemite came out of nowhere; it was announced well in advance. Developers had beta access; it was pretty easy to get. What more should Apple have done?


And another thing while we are in, what I like to call 'Constructive Criticism' mode rather than just 'ranting' ……. Let it be we users who decide when we think our hard-earned add-ons/peripherals/apps are obsolete - not Apple.

Well, you don't HAVE to upgrade if you don't want to. Mountain Lion and Mavericks continue to be supported for now.

Oh, yeah, looks like I "reproduced" parts of your post without e-mailing you first. Whoopsie.

Though, it appears you've been doing some copying of your own.
 

Sheza

macrumors 68020
Aug 14, 2010
2,091
1,807
The OP reads like a Daily Mail comment (or article, they're of the same calibre).
 

DJEmergency

macrumors regular
Nov 4, 2011
100
4
This happens with every version of OS X when it comes out.. People complain how something looks, afraid to update, someone doesn't do a fresh install so they blame Apple for the problems, etc..

I don't have any problems after I did a clean install when 10.10 came out, besides bluetooth issues due to hardware...
 

thejadedmonkey

macrumors G3
May 28, 2005
9,240
3,499
Pennsylvania
while there's always been ranting/whining/complaining here, these forums (at least, as i remember it) were once more about people posting issues, and looking for solutions; making suggestions...troubleshooting.

Apple doesn't really let you troubleshoot anymore. Now-a-days it's either the computer is working (bugs aside) or it's FUBAR'd and needs to be repaired/replaced by Apple. Heck, even things as simple as modding the dock have gotten harder and harder.

So actual tech-support type questions have slowly disappeared, because the only acceptable "Apple approved" answer is to "take it to an apple store". The only other types of posts that remain are "What should I buy" or "Apple sux".

Oh well, at least it's 1mm slimmer than the last version.

This happens with every version of OS X when it comes out.. People complain how something looks, afraid to update, someone doesn't do a fresh install so they blame Apple for the problems, etc..

I don't have any problems after I did a clean install when 10.10 came out, besides bluetooth issues due to hardware...

Only in the past few years, since their QC has plummeted. It used to be people queueing up in lines for Snow Leopard (Apple even handed out complementary water bottles) and than racing home to install it ASAP. Now even the Apple faithful take a more wait-and-see approach.
 

DJEmergency

macrumors regular
Nov 4, 2011
100
4
Apple doesn't really let you troubleshoot anymore. Now-a-days it's either the computer is working (bugs aside) or it's FUBAR'd and needs to be repaired/replaced by Apple. Heck, even things as simple as modding the dock have gotten harder and harder.

So actual tech-support type questions have slowly disappeared, because the only acceptable "Apple approved" answer is to "take it to an apple store". The only other types of posts that remain are "What should I buy" or "Apple sux".

Oh well, at least it's 1mm slimmer than the last version.



Only in the past few years, since their QC has plummeted. It used to be people queueing up in lines for Snow Leopard (Apple even handed out complementary water bottles) and than racing home to install it ASAP. Now even the Apple faithful take a more wait-and-see approach.

This still happens though. Every time a new OS hits the Mac App Store it takes forever to download or you're better off waiting until the servers are clear.
 

fisherking

macrumors G4
Jul 16, 2010
11,252
5,563
ny somewhere
Apple doesn't really let you troubleshoot anymore. Now-a-days it's either the computer is working (bugs aside) or it's FUBAR'd and needs to be repaired/replaced by Apple. Heck, even things as simple as modding the dock have gotten harder and harder.

So actual tech-support type questions have slowly disappeared, because the only acceptable "Apple approved" answer is to "take it to an apple store". The only other types of posts that remain are "What should I buy" or "Apple sux".

you're kidding right? much of what happens on this forum (and macrumors forums in general) is troubleshooting; finding fixes, and when needed, workarounds. really, outside of the whining threads, THAT'S mostly what this forum is for. and btw, modding the dock is NOT a general OS X function...it's not apple's job to support modding the OS (which i do a lot of :cool: ).

we need a separate forum here for whining, and this particular forum can go back to asking for, and providing, help...
 

leman

macrumors Core
Oct 14, 2008
19,521
19,678
It used to be people queueing up in lines for Snow Leopard (Apple even handed out complementary water bottles) and than racing home to install it ASAP.
Now even the Apple faithful take a more wait-and-see approach.

First of all, this is not true. Yosemite was installed on over 40% of Macs just 2 month after its release. Snow Leopard was at 27% half a year after its release (source: http://appleinsider.com/articles/10/02/27/mac_os_x_market_share_up_29_leopard_still_most_common). I find it odd that you measure the popularity of the OS by 'people queuing up in lines'. How should one queue up in line for a download?

Also, there is no doubt that Apple has been rushing things lately, even more then they usually do (and Apple has been notorious for early and buggy releases for its software since at least a decade ago). But again, its quite interesting that Snow Leopard is now perceived as a pinnacle of OS X stability, while at the same time being the OS with the critical bug that could destroy all your data.

I remember the massive complaints about Lion and Mountain Lion on these very forums and an awful drama when Mavericks came out ('Apple does not care about Pros anymore! They try to turn Mac into an iPhone! Its so slow and buggy!'). And now the same thing happens with Yosemite. So nothing to get exited about. After few years, everyone will remember Yosemite as that 'last real OS X' before Apple spoiled it all :rolleyes:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.