Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Macshroomer

macrumors 65816
Dec 6, 2009
1,305
733
Ok, so one more reply and then I am outta here until my new IPad Pro arrives in about a month.

We have a guy who posted a question and then gets testy when given some rather personalized but still valid advice. I don’t really follow enthusiast forums for the most part but in the case of Mcnut dude, I keep seeing hard line his way or the Highway replies that just add to the smoldering aspect of the banter.

He does not present is opinions in a manner that it is qualified as such but comes across rather blanket, absolute.
So I weigh in with my 33+ years of professional experience in how I don’t agree with his full and complete disdain for wireless transfer as a tool to use for it’s strengths. Crickets at first…and then more advice from an obvious amateur as to how to run my mid six figure high end commercial advertising and fine art photo business.

It’s just a weird as heck landscape if not diorama of what used to be a hobby of joy and photos from many and now it is gear, “expert” advice and chest beating. This is not the only photo forum this happens, there are lots.

I just find it sad is all, the simplicity of if a photo is good or not utterly polluted with one upsmanship banter based on nothing that really adds to making an emotionally connected photograph.

As a means to give back, I taught three semesters at a good photo school one day a week and a lot of those students are now working in good paying photo jobs with actual benefits. Not all are because not all had the talent to make it happen, nothing new under the sun.

But they think and act differently, you know? Different than on here, different than on other forums and I just have to wonder what is up with the attitude on forums?

I’ll see you all in a month or two when I can report as to the practical use of the iPad Pro in my workflow.

Get out and find joy in your hobby instead of being on here…it’s better that way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grey Beard

Slartibart

macrumors 68040
Aug 19, 2020
3,142
2,817
But the I constant I am just an amateur vindication thing, freaking odd man, lol!!’
Im just wondering why it is that this happens? It’s like some odd chest beating mating ritual on enthusiast photo forums, I see it in no other so called hobby?

Enlighten me then, you know?
I can see your point, but there's another perspective here - we have a fundamental need to evaluate ourselves, and the only way to do that is in reference to something else. And since we live in a world populated by other life forms that look and behave a lot like us, that something else becomes someone else — other people. In the context of this forum “professionals” and “amateurs” - to put a name tag on the opposite ends of a large range. This serves at least two functions:
First, to reduce uncertainty in the areas in which we’re comparing ourselves.
And second, to learn how to define ourselves.
Additionally stating wether you do something professionally or not is probably just to avoid any cognitive bias that causes oneself to overestimate the degree to which ones beliefs, values, characteristics, and behaviors are shared by others.

EDIT: the OPs start and follow ups carry indeed no value for many who participated here. “Small files are faster to transfer“ etc. ?‍♂️ I at least was able to take two things from this: the reminder that there is a difference in taking a picture and doing a photograph. And I discovered that MR offered an ignore-function in its forums. ?
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.