Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

RootBeerMan

macrumors 65816
Jan 3, 2016
1,475
5,270
It's the 40th anniversary of "The Stranger", so I've been listening to Billy Joel. This was one of my favourite albums when it first came out and it's still holding up well after all these years. One of the very few albums out there that had a full complement of winners on it. Not a bad song on the album. It was filled with winners.

 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm

cube

Suspended
May 10, 2004
17,011
4,973
51olRDO-t3L.jpg
 

arkitect

macrumors 604
Sep 5, 2005
7,371
16,101
Bath, United Kingdom
In my local bookstore I recently spotted a CD of the full cycle performed as a piano duo. I admit to being deeply tempted but suspect I should absorb the full piece in its symphonic form first; nevertheless, you may find it worthwhile at least sampling its tracks. I'd be curious the thoughts of anyone more familiar with this piece:

Smetana: Ma Vlast https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01GSHSW7Q/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_X2p0zbRC1CSSR
Thanks for the recommendation — I shall look out for it.
It seems to be unavailable to order on Amazon — and also missing on Spotify.

On the whole I am quite partial to piano (or other instrument) transcriptions if done well. Liszt did some great ones of Beethoven Symphonies etc.
:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,205
47,593
In a coffee shop.
Thanks for the recommendation — I shall look out for it.
It seems to be unavailable to order on Amazon — and also missing on Spotify.

On the whole I am quite partial to piano (or other instrument) transcriptions if done well. Liszt did some great ones of Beethoven Symphonies etc.
:)

I heard Beethoven's First Symphony (for the first time) this week-end; yes, - exactly as I had read - it is recognisably Beethoven but is channelling Brahms. His own creative voice he didn't find for another two symphonies, not until the Third.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arkitect

cube

Suspended
May 10, 2004
17,011
4,973
I am listening to all the SACDs that I played only in stereo before, now through my 4.1 "virtual 7.1" system. The difference is massive.

I guess I'll go through all of them again the day I get more and better speakers.
 
Thanks for the recommendation — I shall look out for it.
It seems to be unavailable to order on Amazon — and also missing on Spotify.

On the whole I am quite partial to piano (or other instrument) transcriptions if done well. Liszt did some great ones of Beethoven Symphonies etc.
:)
Well, when you put it that way there's only one logical solution. The bookstore a mile from my house has it very inexpensively. I'll grab it and will through the mysterious ways of the internet grant you access so that you can listen and let me/us know what you think, good or bad. I'll hold off listening to it until I can find a positively regarded symphonic recording -- I simply feel that's the appropriate introduction.

I'm also partial to piano, though I have very little classical piano. By coincidence, though, tomorrow a CD of Van Cliburn performing Tchaikovsky: Piano Concerto No. 1 / Rachmaninoff: Piano Concerto No. 2 should be arriving in my mailbox through the mysterious ways of the United States Post Office. On the piano front, this week I also discovered and bought Ray Charles' Genius After Dark from 1961. I'm not a huge fan of his but this is a piano-driven instrumental recording that falls in the mid-to-slow-tempo jazz and/or R&B mold. It's laid back and not technically brilliant, but boy, does it have a great feel.

Now, today's earworms... both somewhere on the modern baroque pop spectrum (to my ear).

"Tchaikovsky & Solitude" (total coincidence):

And Sia's "Academia" (with Beck on backing vocal):
 

arkitect

macrumors 604
Sep 5, 2005
7,371
16,101
Bath, United Kingdom
I heard Beethoven's First Symphony (for the first time) this week-end; yes, - exactly as I had read - it is recognisably Beethoven but is channelling Brahms. His own creative voice he didn't find for another two symphonies, not until the Third.
I love the 1st — I am glad you became acquainted. For the longest time — up until my late teens I didn't listen to 1,2 or 4 — 8 barely got a look in.
It was 3, 7 and 9 all the way.

Did you mean channeling Haydn? Or Mozart by chance?
Brahms composed his symphonies after Beethoven's death so that channeling would have involved Madame Blavatsky type seances with table knocking and holding hands. :)

Brahms' 1st symphony has been seen by some as Beethoven's 10th. :)
Poor Brahms, he really was in awe of Beethoven — "You have no idea how it is for the likes of us to feel the tread of a giant like him behind us!"
[doublepost=1506932001][/doublepost]
Well, when you put it that way there's only one logical solution. The bookstore a mile from my house has it very inexpensively. I'll grab it and will through the mysterious ways of the internet grant you access so that you can listen and let me/us know what you think, good or bad.
That'd be really wonderful. Thank you! I did find them on Youtube — playing Bach transcriptions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IronWaffle

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,205
47,593
In a coffee shop.
I love the 1st — I am glad you became acquainted. For the longest time — up until my late teens I didn't listen to 1,2 or 4 — 8 barely got a look in.
It was 3, 7 and 9 all the way.

Did you mean channeling Haydn? Or Mozart by chance?
Brahms composed his symphonies after Beethoven's death so that channeling would have involved Madame Blavatsky type seances with table knocking and holding hands. :)

Brahms' 1st symphony has been seen by some as Beethoven's 10th. :)
Poor Brahms, he really was in awe of Beethoven — "You have no idea how it is for the likes of us to feel the tread of a giant like him behind us!"
[doublepost=1506932001][/doublepost]
That'd be really wonderful. Thank you! I did find them on Youtube — playing Bach transcriptions.

Sorry, I am half asleep; not Mozart, rather (channelling) Haydn is what I should have said. Or rather, was what I meant. Well spotted. Mea culpa.

I knew 3, 5,6,7,8, and 9 for an age.

This is the first time I had heard the first symphony anywhere, and I had the privilege of hearing it played live.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: arkitect
That'd be really wonderful. Thank you! I did find them on Youtube — playing Bach transcriptions.

My pleasure. Couldn't get there today. Hopefully tomorrow. I'll PM you once it's in-hand and we can work out a few technical things.

Today hasn't felt terribly musical. Hard not to think of the song below, though. The video was filmed shortly after Roy Orbison's untimely passing. A dozen years later, George, like all things, passed away. Hard to believe Mr. Petty is passing now, too, at just 66:





Let thy Wilbury done.​
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mobilehaathi

Thinking again of Mr. Petty (with the help of his fellow Wilbury), but also on the :apple: front... can't really listen to music right now. Copied my iTunes library to an external drive now connected to a Windows laptop since the Apple Store said my Mac mini's internal drive is beginning to fail. Of course, I could listen on my iPhone... except just now, for the fourth time in a week my phone has spontaneously deleted all its music files. Nothing else. Just the music. All of it -- and while syncing... and while iTunes itself didn't blink and was unaware of the deletions. Several phone calls and a previous appointment on this matter and I'm going in again tomorrow. After that, off to research about setting up a NAS server and, it seems, taking another step out of the reality distortion field walled garden. A series of frustrating developments. All things pass indeed.

Back to Tom Petty, he does a yeoman's job on rhythm guitar during a Rock'n'Roll Hall of Fame tribute to George Harrison but the real star is the also-gone-too-soon Prince's searing guitar solo as the song nears the end.

 

notmach67

macrumors regular
Aug 25, 2016
247
255
Dark side of the Moon
One more goody to finish off the night -
Instrumental psych/stoner rock from France -
Stoned Karma - Soul Trip Ecstasy.
Just some all around good sh** to fade out to.

 
Last edited:

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,205
47,593
In a coffee shop.

Thinking again of Mr. Petty (with the help of his fellow Wilbury), but also on the :apple: front... can't really listen to music right now. Copied my iTunes library to an external drive now connected to a Windows laptop since the Apple Store said my Mac mini's internal drive is beginning to fail. Of course, I could listen on my iPhone... except just now, for the fourth time in a week my phone has spontaneously deleted all its music files. Nothing else. Just the music. All of it -- and while syncing... and while iTunes itself didn't blink and was unaware of the deletions. Several phone calls and a previous appointment on this matter and I'm going in again tomorrow. After that, off to research about setting up a NAS server and, it seems, taking another step out of the reality distortion field walled garden. A series of frustrating developments. All things pass indeed.

Back to Tom Petty, he does a yeoman's job on rhythm guitar during a Rock'n'Roll Hall of Fame tribute to George Harrison but the real star is the also-gone-too-soon Prince's searing guitar solo as the song nears the end.


Love the album "All Things Must Pass" - one tends to forget just how good it was.
 
Love the album "All Things Must Pass" - one tends to forget just how good it was.

Yes. It's also worth buying the updated CD from three or so years ago (not the "colorized" one from 2001ish). It sounds quite good and also includes some interesting bonus cuts. Most are curios, but the acoustic song "I Live for You" is lovely and would have fit perfectly on the album.

Also, if you haven't yet ten get the album Early Takes, Vol. 1 (a cruel title since in the many years since its release). It contains several demos from All Things Must Pass that range from similar (the delicate, intimate take of "I'd Have You Anytime") to very, very different (an early "My Sweet Lord" that bears no relation to "He's So Fine"). These are very clean, clear recordings that offer a glimpse of what a "de-Spectorized" All Things Must Pass might sound like. Beyond that, an Every Brothers cover, a Dylan cover, and a splendid, straightforward and (again) intimate performance of "The Light That Lights the World" that makes me wish for many "stripped" recordings of Harrison's fussy '70s output.

Oh, and while I bloviate, sitting at the Genius Bar, grab the demo version of "Isn't It a Pity" that was an iTunes exclusive bonus track on the compilation Let It Roll.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.