Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,788
12,191
I think next I will install a spinner so I can see what advantage going to mSata -drive had.
QuickBench/Xbench don't measure random access time, which is where SSDs totally obliterate any spinner. So they're not painting the full picture.

The OWC disk pretty much tops at less than 75MB/s averages being in the 36-53 MB/s region. I had not before benchmarked SSD in FW bus and was quite surpriced by this. Expected it to be a bit better. But, its quite obvious the FW bus limits the top speed.
FireWire 800 is 786 Mbit/s max (so they're rounding up here) which translates to 78 MB/s due to 8b/10b encoding. So 75 MB/s max is quite good, but the averages are quite low for an SSD.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ToniCH

ToniCH

macrumors 6502a
Oct 23, 2020
737
935
Ok, so I plugged an Apple (Samsung HD103SI) 1TB spinner into the G5. According to Quickbench sequential reads are quite good, it tops at 112 MB/s and averages at 80MB/s. Sequential writes are even better: max 126MB/s and average 86MB/s. But random reads and writes are horrible, we are talking like single digits in small files, better in large files like 53MB/s random writes and 75MB/s random writes. They average at 17 and 29 MB/s.

So, obviously access times are better for the mSata and also random reads and writes are super fast compared to the spinner.

Its quite all right for a data disk and occasional photo editing I guess. The OWC SSD would probably be very nice if installed into the internal SATA bus. Maybe I'll test it next to see if it improves on averages vs. when installed to FW box.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,788
12,191
But random reads and writes are horrible, we are talking like single digits in small files [...]
And since this is what happens when booting an OS and launching applications, spinners absolutely suck for that.
 

ToniCH

macrumors 6502a
Oct 23, 2020
737
935
Here is the final comparison. All disks tested in the 2005 G5 internal SATA bus. Its funny, the dirt cheap Dogfish mSata (my G5 boot disk) has faster transfer speeds in the internal SATA bus than the expensive OWC 6G SATA3 SSD.

HD-comparison-G5.jpg


Ps. I earlier wrote that the mSata is installed with an Delock brand adapter but that is not true. I misremembered. The actual adapter used is a no name chinese one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,788
12,191
Its funny, the dirt cheap Dogfish mSata (my G5 boot disk) has faster transfer speeds in the internal SATA bus than the expensive OWC 6G SATA3 SSD.
OWC’s products are somewhat overpriced.

Ps. I earlier wrote that the mSata is installed with an Delock brand adapter but that is not true. I misremembered. The actual adapter used is a no name chinese one.
You could also have gone for a standard 2.5” SSD in the G5. Any particular reason to go for mSATA? :)
 

ToniCH

macrumors 6502a
Oct 23, 2020
737
935
OWC’s products are somewhat overpriced.


You could also have gone for a standard 2.5” SSD in the G5. Any particular reason to go for mSATA? :)
Luckily I recently bought a box of Mac goodies from our local "graigslist" kind of thing. Pic below. All that for 47€ incl. postage. :cool: Came with OWC invoice/receipt which was dated 2 years back. 👍🏻

Why mSata? I actually did go with the normal Sata SSD originally, the OWC was in there few days ago but then I thought of the mSatas. I have several in shelf which are meant for my vintage machines. I had trouble getting my Cube to boot from several normal SATA SSD's recently and ordered a bunch of cheap replacements + pile of different adapters which I thought could work in both G4 and G5 machines. So I just chose one and put it into the G5 to see if it works. And it does. I could just leave the OWC SSD (1TB) in there as the only drive and use the mSata (256GB) elsewhere. But, I really don't have need for that much drive space in the G5, I don't plan to use it all the time and data can be in my server too. Haven't completely decided what to do about it yet. Lets see.

Next step is to try to flash the new GPUs to it. EDIT: and get the wifi working somehow.

The box of goodies. All unused except the Jetdrive which was used briefly as a backup drive.
Mac-goodies.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1

ToniCH

macrumors 6502a
Oct 23, 2020
737
935
Hahaa!! Success! 😁 I found an old Bearextender 802.11n USB -thing in my parts bin. I remember buying it at some time in 2010-11 or something. And soon after it became obsolete. So, I thought there is a chance it was an older product at that time. After going through many google links I managed to find a driver and it works! Now I have wifi. Not as elegant as internal card but at least it works. 😎

Weirdly it appears as USB Ethernet in the Network tab.

Bearextender-G5.jpg



EDIT: Here cometh my 1st piece of written text in the internet with a G5 in almost 20 years. This sentence here, written using TenFourFox and a late 2005 G5! :)
 

Certificate of Excellence

macrumors 6502a
Feb 9, 2021
951
1,463
My revB B&W has been acting bonkers, crashing and KPing all over the place. My initial plan was to use this mac as part of the 2023 PPC challenge but it has become more a lets fix it n get the demon possession out. I lumped this in with general maintenance, so I reseated PCI cards and SDRam, cleaned and repasted the CPU. I picked up a neat NOS tiny cpu fan at the local thrift for $1.00 NIB, so threw that on the CPU heatsink, pulled the suspect 7000 out for reflashing & installed the OG Rage128, and reset PRAM. I also swapped out the boot S3 SSD for another and also swapped in some storage in the form of a Sata 80gb spinner.
-1.jpg

All in all, the box is much happier now and I have begun to use it for mundane tasks where fun is the priority and speed unecessary. I still plan on getting the 7000 back in the box for a snappier GUI but it needs some work before I get it slotted back in.
-2.jpg

I noticed how hot the SDRAM and other components get in this elderly box, so am considering some additional heatsinks for aging componentry and maybe some bondi blue (that would look neat I think) or aluminum heatsinks for the ram sticks.
 

theMarble

macrumors 65816
Sep 27, 2020
1,020
1,497
Earth, Sol System, Alpha Quadrant
Today I got the RAID0 array working on my G5. For those who haven't seen my post here recently, it was meant to be made up of 2 Kingston A400 240GB SSDs, however one of the disks was not being detected internally. After some fiddling, I decided to use a SanDisk SSD of the same capacity to replace it. I know that mixing brands is probably not the greatest thing to do, but I don't rely on this G5 for any important so I'm fine with it.

Screen Shot 2023-01-24 at 10.40.12 PM.png
RAID2.jpg


I also used Interface Builder to remake the HUD About this Mac window, it was originally made over on macthemes.net, but the Wayback Machine didn't backup the download. This goes best with the Black Mac OS X theme for Leopard :)

Screen Shot 2023-01-24 at 10.29.44 PM.png
 

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,788
12,191
I also used Interface Builder to remake the HUD About this Mac window, it was originally made over on macthemes.net, but the Wayback Machine didn't backup the download. This goes best with the Black Mac OS X theme for Leopard :)
Is it possible to make the two buttons black as well?
 

theMarble

macrumors 65816
Sep 27, 2020
1,020
1,497
Earth, Sol System, Alpha Quadrant
Is it possible to make the two buttons black as well?
If I could work out how to decompile and recompile SArtFile.bin and ArtFile.bin, then yes. However, since all push buttons are drawn from the same image file, it would make every single one in the OS black as well.

Secondly, I'm not sure if there are any ThemePark versions for PPC Leopard floating around anymore, without it I'm not sure there is any way to decompile those files.
 

mectojic

macrumors 65816
Dec 27, 2020
1,324
2,513
Sydney, Australia
Today I cleaned up my G4 Sawtooth internet setup dramatically. Until now I had been using the Airport card for OS9, and an Airport Extreme PCI card in OSX. This works, but I wanted something faster and better.

I installed a Gigabit Ethernet card with the 8169 chipset, and to make it wireless, plugged it into a VONETS Wifi bridge, which powers itself via USB. MacOS detects the connection as ethernet. This allowed me to eradicate the Airport PCI card and the Airport card entirely. I don't really bother with speed testing, but server file transfers are much faster now than Airport Extreme.

There is some confusion about which gigabit cards work in MacOS9, because most don't. After some browsing of old forums, I chose this card, Trendnet TEG-PCITXR, which works great. The box itself only supplies Windows drivers, but you can get OS9 drivers on EveryMac; OSX works out of the box.

IMG_2918.jpg
 

Certificate of Excellence

macrumors 6502a
Feb 9, 2021
951
1,463
I thought it was cool having the G3 powermac case displayed while I had it out and was working on it last week, so connected it to my gaming pc monitor with the G3 side panel and blue lever/apple facing outward, displaying that graphic that I rarely see. I think that looks pretty cool :) :apple:

22764439-0FFC-40C6-8321-3481A8646D00.jpeg


Long live my cranky B&W rev B. :cool: :apple:
 
Last edited:

mortlocli

macrumors 6502a
Feb 23, 2020
729
665
Tried a new way of setting up a laptop or desktop as a monitor for a raspberry pi using only a standard network cable as a connection. I was using my ibook..but though it stated there was a connection made it wasn't working. One prob that can occur with older mac is a firewall block of port 443, but that wasn't a factor in my setup.
Links to this process are here:


Not sure if anyone else has succeeded in trying this..maybe a no go with PPC machines?
 
  • Like
Reactions: dextructor

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,788
12,191
Tried a new way of setting up a laptop or desktop as a monitor for a raspberry pi using only a standard network cable as a connection. I was using my ibook..but though it stated there was a connection made it wasn't working.
What didn’t work? SSH or X11 forwarding?
 
Last edited:

mortlocli

macrumors 6502a
Feb 23, 2020
729
665
What didn’t work? SSH or X11 forwarding?
Im fairly ignorant on network matters, Ame...but I think its using Bonjour via SSH.

The tut is a bit sketchy in some places and Id like to see a youtube bout how it all fits together...like if the connection is there your Rpi desktop just suddenly pops up on your laptop screen???

Just wondered if any other PPC owners had travelled this road..successfully...or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.