Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mortlocli

macrumors 6502a
Feb 23, 2020
729
665
Watched a DVD on my Powerbook G3 Lombard. A very uninteresting thing one might say but the lead up to it shows just how dumb I was and have been. I was kicking myself when i realised I could play DVD's in the machine because I had no idea it could and more importantly, it was not something I was looking for as part of my purchasing decision.

I purchased the machine second hand a very very long time ago to replace my aging 3400. The previous owner had installed OSX 10 on it and I left it at that. I had checked it over before purchase and noticed it had CD drive, battery, pc card slot and a number of connections on the back hidden by a drop down cover. Well i used the machine for a year before the display hinges gave out. Couldn't afford replacements so put it into storage until I could afford them. A few years later I found a set of replacement hinges but never fitted them because I was already doing other stuff with a windows laptop at the time so yep, hinges went into storage.

Well move on to present day. I had to do some clean up and found the hinges. This time I had time on my hands so got the G3 out of storage to replace the hinges. During the dismantle of the machine I removed the battery and cd drive and checked on the side of the machine where the pc card slot was and here is the kicker. In all the time I've owned the G3 I thought there was a door on the card slot, just like those you find on pcmcia slots and never thought anything more of it, never inspected it very closely, just assumed the black thing I saw was a door protecting the slot. Well yep those who know, it was not a door but something actually in the slot. I pressed on the lever which allowed me to push out what ever was in the slot and I was shocked at what I saw, a PC card that said 'Macintosh Powerbook DVD-Video PC Card for Powerbook G3 Series'. I was like what the ****. I investigated what this card was and found out that it does not work in OSX but in OS 9 and when working in OS 9 you see a icon on the desktop and in the task bar telling you the DVD card is installed BUT it does not show on the desktop in OSX BUT it does show up in the taskbar, something I did not bother to look into.

All this time I had this G3 and not once did I bother checking that it had the all the items necessary to watch DVD's (used to watch DVD movies on my windows laptop because of it). After I fitted the new hinges and installed OS 9 on a different partition of the hard drive, there it was on the desktop, the icon for the DVD card. I clicked on it and Apple DVD Player program opened. I clicked play button and the DVD i had put in started playing (the Black Hole), I couldn't believe it, I was over joyed but yet my heart still sank because it dawned on me that I could have been watching DVD's on this G3 all those years ago way way before I got a windows laptop to play DVD's. Man I feel so stupid. Live and learn as they say.
..so always something to learn
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheShortTimer

Macbookprodude

Suspended
Jan 1, 2018
3,306
898
Correct me if I am wrong, but the Lombard out of the box can't play DVD's without some DVD decoder I think, where as Pismo can ?
 

TheShortTimer

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2017
3,264
5,665
London, UK
Correct me if I am wrong, but the Lombard out of the box can't play DVD's without some DVD decoder I think, where as Pismo can ?


Optical Drive: Lombards are not inherently able to play DVDs. They require a special DVD decoder that was integrated into the second release of the Lombard. If your Lombard didn't come with a DVD drive, then you probably don't have one. There are PC card solutions to this problem, but their effectiveness varies greatly. If you have the decoder, you can only watch DVDs in OS 9. It will not work in OS X or classic. Apple never developed the hardware for it.

Edit: VLC will however play DVDs in OS X on a Lombard that possesses a decoder.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: laptech

Macbookprodude

Suspended
Jan 1, 2018
3,306
898
I guess I am glad I never owned one. I have a Pismo G4(was G3 500).. When I got the Pismo I was surprised it came with a G4 after all the bad things I heard about the weakness the G3 had. I despised the G3 as to me, it sounded inferior to the G4. While I do have a G3 500 processor, I am never using it as it has a G4 550. I believe all PowerPC development should be focused on G4-G5 as it is currently, the G3 just doesn't have the power to do what G4 and G5 can do.
 

TheShortTimer

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2017
3,264
5,665
London, UK
I guess I am glad I never owned one. I have a Pismo G4(was G3 500).. When I got the Pismo I was surprised it came with a G4 after all the bad things I heard about the weakness the G3 had. I despised the G3 as to me, it sounded inferior to the G4.

The G4 would be superior given that it was the successor to the G3 and benefited from numerous improvements - particularly the addition of Altivec which provided a tremendous performance boost in many important areas. ;)

While I do have a G3 500 processor, I am never using it as it has a G4 550. I believe all PowerPC development should be focused on G4-G5 as it is currently, the G3 just doesn't have the power to do what G4 and G5 can do.

I disagree. Whilst the G3 has shortcomings it can still pull off good results with a bit of effort and resourcefulness.

The G3 variants in the Nintendo Gamecube, Wii and Wii-U respectively certainly have the power to achieve the tasks of a G4 and some G5's. :D
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MacFoxG4 and z970

appleorchardtech

macrumors newbie
Nov 14, 2021
1
1
Love My DLSD. anyone get a lead on good batteries for these?
 

Attachments

  • PB130901.jpg
    PB130901.jpg
    413.6 KB · Views: 63
  • Like
Reactions: Jack Neill

z970

macrumors 68040
Jun 2, 2017
3,589
4,541
@TheShortTimer Green Ham Gaming made a video a couple years back detailing the hardware capabilities of the Wii U, and what it can achieve on the software side as a result of extensive code and asset optimization. I still think it's borderline awe inspiring that titles like FAST Racing Neo and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild can even run on something like a tri-core PowerPC 750CL (G3), albeit with great assistance from the console's AMD Radeon GX2 graphics chip all the while.


I thought it was so impressive in fact, that Nintendo and Shin'en's (along with many other talented studios) clever techniques used to get their relatively demanding software running smoothly on the resource-constrained hardware not only in an enjoyable state, but in many instances even at a stable 60 FPS (in HD, no less!), was actually what originally inspired me to dive into performance optimization here in vintage Mac land.

They definitely had technical wizards staffed and working behind the scenes of the GameCube, Wii, and Wii U software libraries. In my opinion, it's positively amazing what deep platform-specific knowledge and a healthy serving of elbow grease can achieve - which are of course now seldom-used concepts that will do wonders for any architecture, not just PowerPC.

Case in point, some of the stuff on the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 (both G5-based) were really impressive too, years before the Wii U became available.
 
Last edited:

TheShortTimer

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2017
3,264
5,665
London, UK
@TheShortTimer Green Ham Gaming made a video a couple years back detailing the hardware capabilities of the Wii U, and what it can achieve on the software side as a result of extensive code and asset optimization. I still think it's borderline awe inspiring that titles like FAST Racing Neo and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild can even run on something like a tri-core PowerPC 750CL (G3), albeit with great assistance from the console's AMD Radeon GX2 graphics chip all the while.


Thanks for that video - it was fascinating viewing! :)

I thought it was so impressive in fact, that Nintendo and Shin'en's (along with many other talented studios) clever techniques used to get their relatively demanding software running smoothly on the resource-constrained hardware not only in an enjoyable state, but in many instances even at a stable 60 FPS (in HD, no less!), was actually what originally inspired me to dive into performance optimization here in vintage Mac land.

They definitely had technical wizards staffed and working behind the scenes of the GameCube, Wii, and Wii U software libraries. In my opinion, it's positively amazing what deep platform-specific knowledge and a healthy serving of elbow grease can achieve - which are of course now seldom-used concepts that will do wonders for any architecture, not just PowerPC.

Case in point, some of the stuff on the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 (both G5-based) were really impressive too, years before the Wii U became available.

Totally agree and as I've no doubt mentioned in other posts, I own all three PowerPC based Nintendo machines and upon first powering up my Gamecube, I was blown away by Rogue Squadron II and its full-screen FMV Star Wars footage. That was the only console I'd ever purchased brand new and it was worth the money for that impressive sight alone.

It's a shame that the Wii-U never managed to enjoy the commercial success of its predecessor - especially considering that the Wii itself was technically outclassed by the PS3 and Xbox 360 but nonetheless sold a phenomenal amount of units. There is some consolation that the Wii-U and its catalogue has been favourably reassessed of late.
 

Amethyst1

macrumors G3
Oct 28, 2015
9,807
12,222
considering that the Wii itself was technically outclassed by the PS3 and Xbox 360 but nonetheless sold a phenomenal amount of units.
This was presumably due to the Wii's unique controller concept neither the PS3 nor the Three-Sixty offered. I also presume this concept and the games that took advantage of it managed to attract quite a few non-gamers.
 
Last edited:

TheShortTimer

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2017
3,264
5,665
London, UK
This was presumably due to the Wii's unique controller concept neither the PS3 nor the Three-Sixty offered. I also presume this concept and the games that took advantage of it managed to attract quite a few non-gamers.

You are correct - I remember several non-gamers purchasing Wii's on the strength of Wii Sports etc. :)

Gosh, I recall my mother who's a pensioner and never had any interest in my childhood gaming enquiring about the console after seeing mine. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1

laptech

macrumors 601
Apr 26, 2013
4,119
4,443
Earth
ooooo that's interesting, i never knew that. I will have to try it out when I get a chance to.
Update to my post. Tried watching a DVD with VLC in OSX on my G3 Lombard and the results were not good. My G3 has 10.4.7 installed on it and first tried VLC for power pc 0.9.10. It played the DVD but audio only, no picture. Tried changing many setting but still the same, audio only, no picture. I then tried version 0.8.6i and whilst this worked, the picture was very very laggy.

DVD in OS 9 was smoooth :)
 

laptech

macrumors 601
Apr 26, 2013
4,119
4,443
Earth
Can VLC make use of the Lombard’s MPEG-2 encoder?
I think somebody mentioned that there are 2 different version of the G3 Lombard, 400Mhz and 333Mhz with the 400Mhz having the MPEG2-decoder. I have the 333Mhz version which requires the use of the DVD-Video PC card.
 

Macbookprodude

Suspended
Jan 1, 2018
3,306
898
Update to my post. Tried watching a DVD with VLC in OSX on my G3 Lombard and the results were not good. My G3 has 10.4.7 installed on it and first tried VLC for power pc 0.9.10. It played the DVD but audio only, no picture. Tried changing many setting but still the same, audio only, no picture. I then tried version 0.8.6i and whilst this worked, the picture was very very laggy.

DVD in OS 9 was smoooth :)
Speaking of OS 9, playing DVD with DVD player 2.7 I keep getting pooping sounds - was there a fix for this ? I try to watch a DVD on my titanium under 9.2.2, and keep getting popping sounds.
 
It was a wee bit chilly this evening when I got to my work desk, but I didn’t feel like firing up the space heater. So I sent all my PowerPC Macs, save one, into running a macports “port upgrade outdated” — something I haven’t done for a few weeks. A few hours on, the G5 has easily brought the room up by two degrees and the room’s ambient temperature is now just right. :)
 

swamprock

macrumors 65816
Aug 2, 2015
1,261
1,837
Michigan
Replaced the keyboard in my 12” PowerBook G4 1.5 ghz, and brought the 1.42ghz (overclocked) Mac Mini back to life running OS 9.2.2 on a 64gb SD card; both undertaken once again thanks to @Raging Dufus and his generosity. I need to strip the 12” down one of these days and replace the mold-damaged speakers, bend the keyboard back a bit to fix some minor bowing, and upgrade the anemic OWC SSD, but she runs fine enough for now.

2B703ACA-77BA-4A7D-98AD-1FD0D4A7E953.jpeg

0FF93A30-D4FE-492C-9CCD-709D5A30C624.jpeg

My 2009 Mini is on the left, G4 on the right.
 
Last edited:

MacFoxG4

macrumors 6502
Nov 22, 2019
447
623
Can someone please assist with this ? Playing a DVD is giving popping sounds under 9 and 9.2.2.
This reminds me of a problem I had where the audio was skipping while playing DVDs in OS 9 on my Sawtooth. I solved it by turning the resolution down to 1152x870 or lower.

Currently using my recently purchased 1.9ghz iMac G5 iSight. This thing looks beautiful. I think I might use it for digitizing my records and tapes and for video capture of my older consoles given that I put it in the same room as my main stereo setup and retro video game consoles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheShortTimer
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.