Welllll…
Last weekend is really when this happened, but I'm only posting about it now. I have a 4TB HD in bay 2 on my MP. I use it as a media/download/burn drive. I got the idea last weekend to start moving things off of it to make it solely a media drive. I have to be careful because I have a backup to a 3TB drive and I don't want to run out of drive space on that 3TB.
But I also had some old disk images stored there and one in particular was giving me issues in copying. So, I finally resorted to trying a CCC copy of that particular disk image while moving other stuff off the drive.
The copy got almost to the end and then the Mac kernel panicked. So, I force-rebooted, only to discover that the 4TB drive no longer mounts to the desktop. Fortunately, everything else had already been pulled off, either to another drive or to my 6TB network NAS.
The MP sees the drive, but it will not partition it. It errors when trying to write. I'm not happy about the drive failing, but for once all of this happened AFTER I pulled all the data off! And the fact that I tend to make backups meant a loss of only one recently downloaded media file. Easily re-downloaded.
My network NAS and G4 NAS handled the copy over ethernet of 2.04TB TWICE ('cause I'm an idiot) without a hitch, without an issue and no errors. THAT made me very happy because it means these two things are stable and I can count on them.
So, I went looking for a replacement. My rule in replacement is the same or larger. I can't afford a 4TB SSD and an 8TB SSD is approaching $900!
So, for now, I stick with spinners. I've got an 8TB WD NAS drive on my eBay watchlist - $109.
PS. It takes about 2 days to copy 2.04TB over gigabit ethernet.
