Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Amnesia, all the way. That game's messed up. Check out the demo on Steam.

But only if you play in the dark with headphones...

Do some searching around on YouTube. There's a few videos of some guy playing it while talking to his friend on Ventrilo. I have never laughed so hard, even though that game scared the bajesus out of me!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loSzpvq73FY

Watch that. I PROMISE it;s worth it!
 
It was either Doom 3 or Quake 4, I can't remember.

When I was in school several years ago I used to have a habit of playing video games at all hours of the night. So there I was, playing at like 3 in the morning with all the lights off and there was a noise that sounded as if it were behind me. I turned around and looked behind me and of course there was nothing there, so I kept playing... took what had to have been 5 or 6 steps forward around a corner and this ungodly monster jumped out at me.

Scared the life out of me, that's for sure.
 
I would also suggest the Penumbra collection from Frictional Games (the developers of Amnesia). These games are very similar to Amnesia, are quite cheap ($10), and run very well on Macs.

They also scare the daylights out of players.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.