Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

batman75

macrumors 6502a
Apr 15, 2010
726
175
So to everyone here who has both a Leather Loop and a new Leather Link - which one do you prefer and why?

The leather link is vastly superior. I already gave away my black leather loop after getting the leather link.

4 reasons:
1) The watch sits better on your wrist and it sits more symmetrically whereas the leather loop was lifted on one side where the buckle was. The overall look is more fitted and custom because of how it fits close to your skin (versus the bulge you have with the loop).
2) It looks much better. It generally has a more sleek and modern look.
3) It feels a bit more secure. The magnets are more curved and help secure it better than the flatter magnet on the leather loop.
4) It dries off better after washing your hands whereas the loop tended to trap water because the channels between the magnets were too shallow.

I'm surprised they didn't discontinue the loop. I can't imagine why anyone would choose that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mikeyde1989

D3ggy

macrumors 6502a
Mar 26, 2019
517
450
The leather link is vastly superior. I already gave away my black leather loop after getting the leather link.

4 reasons:
1) The watch sits better on your wrist and it sits more symmetrically whereas the leather loop was lifted on one side where the buckle was. The overall look is more fitted and custom because of how it fits close to your skin (versus the bulge you have with the loop).
2) It looks much better. It generally has a more sleek and modern look.
3) It feels a bit more secure. The magnets are more curved and help secure it better than the flatter magnet on the leather loop.
4) It dries off better after washing your hands whereas the loop tended to trap water because the channels between the magnets were too shallow.

I'm surprised they didn't discontinue the loop. I can't imagine why anyone would choose that.

I agree with everything you said.
 

Arcontia

macrumors 6502a
Apr 6, 2017
927
2,510
The leather link is vastly superior. I already gave away my black leather loop after getting the leather link.

4 reasons:
1) The watch sits better on your wrist and it sits more symmetrically whereas the leather loop was lifted on one side where the buckle was. The overall look is more fitted and custom because of how it fits close to your skin (versus the bulge you have with the loop).
2) It looks much better. It generally has a more sleek and modern look.
3) It feels a bit more secure. The magnets are more curved and help secure it better than the flatter magnet on the leather loop.
4) It dries off better after washing your hands whereas the loop tended to trap water because the channels between the magnets were too shallow.

I'm surprised they didn't discontinue the loop. I can't imagine why anyone would choose that.

Interestingg

I can see what you mean about it sitting more symmetrically on the wrist, thats absolutely a plus
 
  • Like
Reactions: twanj

Boardiesboi

macrumors 601
Sep 3, 2013
4,608
10,676
Sydney Australia
My California poppy is finally here! Love the band! The lumps are not as conspicuous as photos show and its light weight yet feels very high quality. I might get the Baltic blue as well.
3EF37933-F4E6-4C09-8453-1BF75F8B35D8.jpeg
79801315-1120-4961-A746-66218275ADC5.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • 0803ECDB-A33D-4C81-9A9E-F3D12C03A344.jpeg
    0803ECDB-A33D-4C81-9A9E-F3D12C03A344.jpeg
    219.5 KB · Views: 199

Arcontia

macrumors 6502a
Apr 6, 2017
927
2,510
The leather link is vastly superior. I already gave away my black leather loop after getting the leather link.

4 reasons:
1) The watch sits better on your wrist and it sits more symmetrically whereas the leather loop was lifted on one side where the buckle was. The overall look is more fitted and custom because of how it fits close to your skin (versus the bulge you have with the loop).
2) It looks much better. It generally has a more sleek and modern look.
3) It feels a bit more secure. The magnets are more curved and help secure it better than the flatter magnet on the leather loop.
4) It dries off better after washing your hands whereas the loop tended to trap water because the channels between the magnets were too shallow.

I'm surprised they didn't discontinue the loop. I can't imagine why anyone would choose that.

But I'd also add in a slight counterpoint, something I personally like better about the Leather Loop is that the actual leather band itself, is thicker. The Leather Link itself is actually pretty thin. I feel the thicker leather on the Loop helps contribute to making it look more premium but that could just be me
 

batman75

macrumors 6502a
Apr 15, 2010
726
175
But I'd also add in a slight counterpoint, something I personally like better about the Leather Loop is that the actual leather band itself, is thicker. The Leather Link itself is actually pretty thin. I feel the thicker leather on the Loop helps contribute to making it look more premium but that could just be me

Obviously everyone should buy what they prefer. But I don’t see it that way. I can’t tell a difference in thickness, and the new design also seems to have a nicer leather.

If you like thick leather then you should look at something like Strapa. Neither of the Apple bands are a thick leather on that level.
 

H. Flower

macrumors 6502a
Jul 23, 2008
758
852
I really love the look of these bands, but am cautious about getting another Apple leather product, which I've always regretted. After about only a year of use (in some cases only months), my apple leather phone cases and leather bands have always looked terrible.

Any hope these would somehow be different?
 

batman75

macrumors 6502a
Apr 15, 2010
726
175
C
I really love the look of these bands, but am cautious about getting another Apple leather product, which I've always regretted. After about only a year of use (in some cases only months), my apple leather phone cases and leather bands have always looked terrible.

Any hope these would somehow be different?

Valid concern. I have had a black Leather loop before and I found it to be very durable. I got it with my Series 0 and it is still immaculate. Can't comment about colored bands though. So far my Saddle Brown and Baltic Blue Leather Links look perfect but it is early days.

I do think there is no comparison between these bands and the phone cases. The phone cases are designed to patina and there is no protection on the leather. It is not designed to withstand skin oils, lotion or water. The leather phone case is junk IMO.
 

batman75

macrumors 6502a
Apr 15, 2010
726
175
Depends what you mean by terrible. Leather always get darker as you use them, even with expensive luxury leather makers eg Hermès.
Not necessarily. Some leathers are protected and can be cleaned to restore the original look. I have a White leather sofa by Roche Bobois and it looks the same as when I bought it 6 years ago. Roche Bobois is a high end French furniture maker and they use leather from the same Tuscan tanneries as some of the top European fashion houses.
 
Last edited:

Frankfurt

macrumors 6502a
Dec 4, 2016
740
889
USA
I returned the California Poppy link. Hated the color (more mustard, was hoping a bit more orange). Further, the link takes more time to put on. I prefer the Solo Loops and got another one of those.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twanj

vroom2

macrumors 6502
Oct 20, 2019
314
286
Can someone please directly compare a baltic blue leather link with a forest green leather loop, they look very close, a side by side would be helpful.
Thanks
 

TotalMacMove

macrumors 65816
Jun 18, 2013
1,189
1,831
USA
Has anyone here bought a leather link from Amazon that already shipped? I ordered it mid September and still has no update!
 

triangletechie

macrumors 65816
Apr 21, 2017
1,016
1,748
NC
I got my saddle brown leather link today and like it so far. I never was a fan of the leather loop. Mine would loosen up over the course of a day. Hopefully the link will stay in place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrianSoCal

Piman

macrumors newbie
Jun 29, 2020
2
1
Has anyone here bought a leather link from Amazon that already shipped? I ordered it mid September and still has no update!
Same here, I bought one back in September but no update. Amazon still has it listed with an expected delivery date of 10/30 if that even means anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TotalMacMove

schlupps

macrumors 6502
Sep 22, 2020
323
296
RheinMain - Germany
Can someone please directly compare a baltic blue leather link with a forest green leather loop, they look very close, a side by side would be helpful.
Thanks
@vroom2: i think you are right: it is close. The pic was taken in pretty bright sunlight, but obviously, i was not really successful in catching the difference between those two colors properly.. but, there is one =)
My fav is the forest green for sure. Apple chose a really nice tone with the baltic blue as well!
maybe someone with a little better cam/hand chimes in ;)
As a side note i have to admit, that the forest green strap already was worn quite a lot and got a little darker over the time. The baltic blue arrived about a week ago and was worn for about 20 hours max.
 

Attachments

  • screeny.png
    screeny.png
    2.9 MB · Views: 225
Last edited:

Toonartist

macrumors 6502
Sep 19, 2017
459
433
Newcastle Upon Tyne
Here’s a few of the California Poppy on a S6 SBTI that I posted on another thread.

I’ve adjusted the white balance and tint to get as close as possible match to the actual colour of the strap.

ec602c622a76a449dec0f56015926814.jpg
4686de594d9c04ea995ce7bce74b436a.jpg
ce607ca9d0cb681787ee07420f7f895d.jpg
 

vroom2

macrumors 6502
Oct 20, 2019
314
286
@vroom2: i think you are right: it is close. The pic was taken in pretty bright sunlight, but obviously, i was not really successful in catching the difference between those two colors properly.. but, there is one =)
My fav is the forest green for sure. Apple chose a really nice tone with the baltic blue as well!
maybe someone with a little better cam/hand chimes in ;)
As a side note i have to admit, that the forest green strap already was worn quite a lot and got a little darker over the time. The baltic blue arrived about a week ago and was worn for about 20 hours max.
Wow, those are very close, love my Forest Green, picked up a California Poppy link and really like the new design as well. Thanks for posting
 
  • Like
Reactions: schlupps

D3ggy

macrumors 6502a
Mar 26, 2019
517
450
Normally I put my watch on in the dark. This morning I noticed black spots appearing which look like where the magnet peaks are.

Is anyone else seeing this? Should I be sending it back for a replacement? It’s very disappointing for a premium strap.

6d84045d37ed4c29f2d617f6ad6ecdea.jpg

2965c9ee9bb3e003efbaa7158c5fce4e.jpg
 

vroom2

macrumors 6502
Oct 20, 2019
314
286
Normally I put my watch on in the dark. This morning I noticed black spots appearing which look like where the magnet peaks are.

Is anyone else seeing this? Should I be sending it back for a replacement? It’s very disappointing for a premium strap.

6d84045d37ed4c29f2d617f6ad6ecdea.jpg

2965c9ee9bb3e003efbaa7158c5fce4e.jpg
I have (and love) that band, haven’t seen any kind of spots forming. Have you tried to gently clean the area where they are to see if they come off? If not, yes, that would be something your warranty on the band would cover.
 

D3ggy

macrumors 6502a
Mar 26, 2019
517
450
I have (and love) that band, haven’t seen any kind of spots forming. Have you tried to gently clean the area where they are to see if they come off? If not, yes, that would be something your warranty on the band would cover.

Yes I have tried cleaning and the marks don’t come off. Apple are investigating and I have been promised a call back on Tuesday.
 

Zenga13

macrumors member
Apr 30, 2015
56
20
Netherlands
Normally I put my watch on in the dark. This morning I noticed black spots appearing which look like where the magnet peaks are.

Is anyone else seeing this? Should I be sending it back for a replacement? It’s very disappointing for a premium strap.

6d84045d37ed4c29f2d617f6ad6ecdea.jpg

2965c9ee9bb3e003efbaa7158c5fce4e.jpg

Yes, I have the same problem with my Baltic Blue link. Contacted Apple last week and today I have received a new Link. It looks to me like a problem with the magnets.

9527F7DB-1730-4CFC-9F67-5A074A8D04CC.jpeg
3DC4F792-EE34-46C1-AC41-EF61BEB9EC62.jpeg
 
  • Wow
Reactions: twanj
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.