Add me to the
Andor fan club. I'm six episodes in and enjoying the heck out of it. FYI, I kept wondering why rebel Vel Sarth looked familiar. Turns out the actress, Faye Marsay, played the waif opposite Arya in GOT.
It is a very good series. The writing, casting, and performances are all fantastic, with the usual high standards for production design seen in the SW universe.
But it appeals to a more mature audience, and not those looking for spaces battles, creatures, and the like.
It is a work that can stand on its own outside of being SW, but the fact that it is part of that universe is the cherry on top.
It's almost everything Lucas set out to do in the prequels, painting the picture of the universe, the brewing conflict, the origins of the characters, and setting the scene for the original trilogy, but failed miserably to do, with shallow writing, frivolous characters, and poor performances.
Compared to something like Boba Fett, where we basically learned little about a character that was never all that interesting to begin with, with Andor, it paints a vivid picture of what the Empire is, its power and breadth, and why it's truly evil, way beyond being Bad Guys with Better Weapons and Menacing Costumes. It's brutal without simply showing or explaining the macro extinction of a planet or species, and illustrates that it can be far more cruel to allow something to live, and not simply kill it.
And not just pertaining to a select group of characters, but to the people, and universe as a whole, from the lowliest guard to the mid-level managers, and in the streets and trenches, not the generals who command from their ivory towers. More real, and meanacing without ever seeing a Vader, or just hearing a mention of the Emperor.
It's great that Disney has allowed that group of producers, with their track record, to offer their vision of a SW story, and it would be a pity if it wasn't allowed to happen again, because the most of the audience expected more empty calories like they've been fed of late.