A lot of more advanced Mac users are bothered by the skeumorphism Apple is introducing into a lot of their apps, but I think these people are missing the reason behind the changes. It's not to be cute, it's to create
familiarity for users.
The video of Chris Prillo's dad using a Mac for the first time is really the best example of this I've seen.
http://joelhousman.com/2012/03/15/chris-prillos-dad-compares-windows-8-to-os-x/
This is an older guy who has never used OS X, but he understands what the apps are because he is
familiar with iOS. It looks the same, it must be the same, it is the same.
It's like Launchpad. Advanced Mac users thought Launchpad was so stupid. We use Spotlight or Quicksilver or Alfred to launch our apps. But regular users use the dock, and that's it. There was no chance they were going to navigate into the applications folder to realize there are more apps in there. Launchpad is the greatest thing for them, because it bridges the gap between the apps in the dock and the rest of the apps on their system.
John Siracusa has a great rant about this on episode #59 of his show Hypercritical
http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/59