I would definitely consider a bigger iPad, probably up to 15”. It would be even better for creation and productivity, especially if I could use it as a Cintiq with my 15” mbp. But I also value the 12.9’s portability as a device I carry in my bag almost every day, and often hold in my arm while drawing, and sometimes there’s the issue of table space. It would be a really tough choice so I’m almost glad Apple hasn’t given me the option yet hahah.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad Pro 11 or 12.9 Pro ?
- Thread starter George Dawes
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Even 4GB is not enough? Oh gosh. Apple has gone from excellent optimisation to a brute force style arms race? I feel worried about my $1700 iPad Pro.
In the future you will never know if MacBooks will have a touch screen and removable keyboards. Kind of like the Microsoft Surface Pro.
Greatly depending on what you are doing, depends whether or not 4GB is even enough. I was having trouble with 4GB of ram when editing 4K video, and running certain games with a application minimized. I have touched 5GB of ram being utilized on my 1TB model before. Over 4GB+ of ram was active. And 1GB was in inactive applications. And about 600MB was free.
The 4GB iPads have 3.69GB of available ram, before it is even turned on. So you can surely burn through it and cause performance issues. I could easily repeat this every time.
I have yet to be able to do the same on a 1TB iPad Pro. It seems for now that 6GB is more than enough! Even if I tried over and over again. I couldn’t slow one down. So, I guess it feels kinda like you get what you pay for with a 1TB model.
Apple has spoken against that idea, but yeah who knows, it’s possible they could change their minds. Rather than touch screen and removeable keyboard, however, I’d want pencil input only and a convertible form factor like a yoga (less top heavy and overall weight should be a little lighter).
Uh well. I think I might better waiting for another year or two at the very least to see if Apple raises RAM amount for lower end pros. Investing $2300 on 1TB model for A12X seems too excessive. I need to chop another arm to be able to afford it.
I think the direction of travel will be a merger of MacOS and iOS which will result in a few different forms factors but the modular tablet will win out I think. This is a long way off, next 3-5 years?
The Windows laptop market is now experimenting again with new ideas (dual screen laptops peak my interest) along with Microsofts Surface team and this will help move the concepts and designs on and put pressure on Apple to also innovate. That said I'm sure Apple know their roadmap for the next 10 years at least.
Last edited:
That's not hype, it's just fact. That said, carrying around a letter-sized clipboard, binder or hardbound book feels just as awkward.
Marques Brownlee (MKBHD) has just wrote on Twitter: “It's Day 6 since I took my laptop out my backpack and starting bringing the 11" LTE iPad Pro everywhere. Love the form factor - typing and carrying is definitely easier/more fun than the 12.9". No regrets yet.”
What you think, guys?
What you think, guys?
To each his own.
Once Apple first released the 1st generation 12.9” iPP, I’ve been a believer of the form factor. I just prefer the larger screen real estate, period.
I’m now on the 3rd generation 12.9” iPP and I don’t plan on downsizing. I’m learning new things daily with the iPadOS and can’t wait for others to experience it.
I take my iPP out on occasions, leave my iPhone at home while having the iPP and Apple Watch. And it’s not as dreadful as others claim to be, mainly because I’ve grown accustomed to it..
I don’t know (or care) who that person is but to each their own. Some prefer the bigger, some the smaller device. Just pick the one that works better for yourself - and only you can be the judge of that.
Both are nice tablets at the end of the day.
Currently got a 2017 iPad Pro 12.9
Been debating getting one of the newer ones for a while, today actually been looking at different cellular prices etc
Just can’t make my mind up if “downgrading” from a 12.9 to 11 will be a massive difference/huge miss for me
Need to get to a store and have a go on the 11
Been debating getting one of the newer ones for a while, today actually been looking at different cellular prices etc
Just can’t make my mind up if “downgrading” from a 12.9 to 11 will be a massive difference/huge miss for me
Need to get to a store and have a go on the 11
It's crazy how much smaller the 11 looks in the store compared to the 12.9. This is speaking as someone who switched to the 11. It almost made me think I was making a mistake.
It is possible the 12.9" model will sell better once iPad OS is officially released. It will also probably even slow down the sales of MacBooks.
I for one am super happy with my 11" model and it works great with iPadOs Beta 1.
I have the 1TB LTE model with the extra Ram.
I for one am super happy with my 11" model and it works great with iPadOs Beta 1.
I have the 1TB LTE model with the extra Ram.
What you're saying, all sounds like someone who is not exactly on the level. Why don't you take a look at this video and then explain how your conclusion is so very different:
I bought the 11 soon after it came out, and then started thinking about the 12.9. After endless visits to online reviews, message forums, and stores, I bought the 12.9 when Best Buy recently discounted it $200. My plan was to use the 15 day return window to compare with the 11 and then decide. That came & went, and I now have both iPads, and am happy with my decision. Am not a power user, not a student, just a soon to be retiree who enjoys both for different reasons.
My 11 stays on the sofa & recliner (and occasional trips to the bathroom). Also goes with me when I travel. At home, I enjoy researching TV shows or movies while I watch as well as doing emails and reading digital newspapers during baseball or football games, etc.
The 12.9 stays on the dining room table and is primarily used when I want to read the full digital newspapers or any of the 55 magazines I follow on Apple News+ and also for looking at financial pages. It's almost like viewing the actual magazine page, which I like.
Of course I know it's not cost effective, but I got each of them on sale, which softens the pain.
Once you spend time with the 12.9, the 11 seems so small...but that's what makes it great for the sofa.
My 11 stays on the sofa & recliner (and occasional trips to the bathroom). Also goes with me when I travel. At home, I enjoy researching TV shows or movies while I watch as well as doing emails and reading digital newspapers during baseball or football games, etc.
The 12.9 stays on the dining room table and is primarily used when I want to read the full digital newspapers or any of the 55 magazines I follow on Apple News+ and also for looking at financial pages. It's almost like viewing the actual magazine page, which I like.
Of course I know it's not cost effective, but I got each of them on sale, which softens the pain.
Once you spend time with the 12.9, the 11 seems so small...but that's what makes it great for the sofa.
I think there are good reasons to have two iPads of different sizes. But for me, I prefer more distinction—the 12.9 for productivity and Mini for casual use on the couch and around the home. And when traveling, I take my 12.9 since I like having that big screen option, plus the Mini’s uses can pretty much be filled by either that or my iPhone.
Still not regretting my decision to go 11", even as the role my iPad has taken in my work flows has increased more and more. I still look at the 12.9" models every time I'm in an Apple store just to reset my own perspective a little bit, and they're just not "bigger enough" where I have remorse for not going with the bigger model.
I think for me it's mostly because of where/how I use the iPad. When I do any serious photo editing, art, or anything else creative, I like to be comfortable on the couch or sitting up in bed with the iPad propped up on a pillow. I don't love sitting at a desk while using the Apple Pencil. When I read, I like to have the iPad in landscape with a page of the book on each side, and the 11" feels more the size of a small hardback book to me in that setting. When I'm out running the kids around to their activities, I like having the smaller iPad just because it's that much lighter and smaller and easier to deal with. I know the 12.9" isn't THAT much bigger or heavier, and I'm not going to kill my arms carrying either model, but I do prefer the more portable models.
I still keep an open mind for the next gen models. My photo editing projects have been taking more and more of my time and at some point I might want the bigger one for that. Same with my art projects. But for now, I'm humming along just fine with the smaller model.
I think for me it's mostly because of where/how I use the iPad. When I do any serious photo editing, art, or anything else creative, I like to be comfortable on the couch or sitting up in bed with the iPad propped up on a pillow. I don't love sitting at a desk while using the Apple Pencil. When I read, I like to have the iPad in landscape with a page of the book on each side, and the 11" feels more the size of a small hardback book to me in that setting. When I'm out running the kids around to their activities, I like having the smaller iPad just because it's that much lighter and smaller and easier to deal with. I know the 12.9" isn't THAT much bigger or heavier, and I'm not going to kill my arms carrying either model, but I do prefer the more portable models.
I still keep an open mind for the next gen models. My photo editing projects have been taking more and more of my time and at some point I might want the bigger one for that. Same with my art projects. But for now, I'm humming along just fine with the smaller model.
Used the 11 inch for quite a while and then got rid of it. Got the 12.9 and tried that and got rid of it. I liked the mobility of the 11 so got it again, but then started to realize a key factor for me - how much more productive I was using the 12.9. I now have the 12.9 again and don’t regret one bit.
IMO 12.9 adds a lot more flexibility that the 11 cannot. Weight is an issue, but the 12.9 enables me to leave my MBP at home. If I need Mac functionality, I just use VNC to connect remotely.
IMO 12.9 adds a lot more flexibility that the 11 cannot. Weight is an issue, but the 12.9 enables me to leave my MBP at home. If I need Mac functionality, I just use VNC to connect remotely.
That’s quite a lot of back and forth but on the other hand you made sure you got the tool that really works best for you based on your experiences! It might be easier next time to just get both sizes, test them, then return the one you don’t like so much and keep the other. Thanks for sharing!