Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Perhaps someone can talk me off the cliff here

I am not just posting this to be that person that says "THAT'S IT, I RAGE QUIT" so somehow virtue signal against what is popular.

I have family in the Philippines and when I travel, I immediately remove my SIM and put in one of the carriers there.

HECK, pre-covid they used to give you a sim ON THE PLANE for this purpose. Smart marketing for Globe (the carrier) for sure.

I pay about $50 US and get 40 gigs of data, then remove the card when I get back to the usa.

This is incredibly convenient because I can walk up to any vendor in the airport, shopping mall or street corner shop, immediately get service and then pop my own network sim back in when I am taxiing back on the runway in the USA.

Middle of nowhere and travel? Good freaking luck in getting a fancy eSIM in a developing nation.

I want the "dynamic island" and I want to have that new camera, but I also want to have the phone connecting without having to go through unnecessary steps.

Am I wrong in this?

edit - APPLE HAS A PAGE... Dedicated to carriers that use esim.
In my country case, both esim providers are POSTPAID.

Contract based. That sucks, and again will disqualify someone like me.
I share your frustrations. The hope with this move is for the carriers to support eSIM on all their plans. Somebody has to put a foot down, and I'm glad that we have a company like Apple that is willing to take that risk. These carriers are too fat and lazy. In my country, Samsung tried persuading the top carriers to support eSIM in accordance to the foldable launch, but it went to deaf ears. Hopefully with Apple taking a stance, there will be better eSIM support globally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ndouglas
Curious what’s in the space of the sim tray. Canadian units will still have it. So what does the US phone has that we don’t?
 
Curious what’s in the space of the sim tray. Canadian units will still have it. So what does the US phone has that we don’t?
I can only imagine. There was a time when Sprint first got the iPhone 4. The Sprint model of that phone had no SIM slot. But it DID have some sort of chip there that did the same sort of thing as a SIM - only it was locked to Sprint.
 
I worry the carriers will charge an activation fee. I switch back and forth between iOS and Android every few weeks, so this is a concern for me as well.
I can’t imagine they will. The rep I spoke to didn’t mention this. I would also like to think that Apple would have thought long and hard about this, knowing that there are people that switch out their SIM cards — and the point is convenience, not inconvenience and expense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nospleen
Perhaps someone can talk me off the cliff here

I am not just posting this to be that person that says "THAT'S IT, I RAGE QUIT" so somehow virtue signal against what is popular.

I have family in the Philippines and when I travel, I immediately remove my SIM and put in one of the carriers there.

HECK, pre-covid they used to give you a sim ON THE PLANE for this purpose. Smart marketing for Globe (the carrier) for sure.

I pay about $50 US and get 40 gigs of data, then remove the card when I get back to the usa.

This is incredibly convenient because I can walk up to any vendor in the airport, shopping mall or street corner shop, immediately get service and then pop my own network sim back in when I am taxiing back on the runway in the USA.

Middle of nowhere and travel? Good freaking luck in getting a fancy eSIM in a developing nation.

I want the "dynamic island" and I want to have that new camera, but I also want to have the phone connecting without having to go through unnecessary steps.

Am I wrong in this?

edit - APPLE HAS A PAGE... Dedicated to carriers that use esim.
In my country case, both esim providers are POSTPAID.

Contract based. That sucks, and again will disqualify someone like me.
Yeah I just got the memo late into the game. I just read that the USA iPhones won’t have physical SIM card capabilities. Bad move as far as I’m concerned, since the places I travel to internationally only supply eSim primarily to their pay monthly customers and not to pay as you go ( prepaid ) customers. This in itself will greatly reduce my choices.

If Apple wanted to truly force carriers to implement eSim tech they should have removed the physical SIM card option globally across the board. Now they’ve just alienated international users.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shirasaki
There are some things that aren’t clear to me, not having recently traveled and dealt with the issues.

1. If I have an eSIM only (a US version), and I own the phone outright, what’s the issue with a post-paid foreign plan? I can cancel it at any time since the phone isn’t financed with rhem, right? And if I stop paying they’ll cancel it for me, lol.

2. If I have a SIM tray and an eSIM, like my current 12 and 13s, I can select which number to use, but if I select line A, then calls and messages to line B will not be received, right? So is there an advantage to using two phones, disregarding the cost?

3. For the models A2890 or A2894 referenced in post #18 above have the same or compatible band frequencies for US use? I would assume so, but better to ask.

TIA

Well chiefly, qualifying for a post paid plan in a country where you are not a legal resident is the issue. I would have to assume most carriers globally have qualifications the same as they do in the USA.

In my case (Philippines), I need to show I am working, have sufficient income, and proof of residence.

Being a tourist, how do I accomplish that? Also, is it an instant decision? I do not even know, and cannot fathom spending an entire day or even several hours dealing with that.

As for point #3, no they do not. Not all countries have the same bands, so some phones simply do not get the same 5g reception in the USA vs what you can get with a phone made for the US market.

Canada, for instance has no rollout of mmWave, but as has been mentioned, that is largely a gimmick.

I am not sure of Tmobile 5gUC works on the same frequency as verizon mmWave, but the networks just between Canada and USA are different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shirasaki
I just saw a thread saying Canada hardware is the same as Yankee hardware

AFAIK it is not. They lack some 5g that US phones have, because the network in Canada is not built out or as fast.
 
This change was driven by Apple. Carriers dragged their feet on eSIM since it makes it easier to switch carriers. Market forces won’t tolerate activation fees for very long when there is no longer a physical card or visit to a store required.
Apple should have made this change a global one if they truly wanted to force Carrie’s hands. . Now they’ve just alienated international users.
 
I remember when I was a Tech Support agent activating an eSim was a major pain. Hope it has changed.
 
Apple should have made this change a global one if they truly wanted to force Carrie’s hands. . Now they’ve just alienated international users.
sooner or later, they will. Apple is simply pcking their battles from the lowest hanging fruit first, the US, where all carriers have eSIM support already. I can see Apple expanding that decision to some European countries or Japan next. All in all, in 3 years, all US iPhones will be eSIM only. Apple pretty much set the deadline for carriers around the world to offer eSIM support.
 
sooner or later, they will. Apple is simply pcking their battles from the lowest hanging fruit first, the US, where all carriers have eSIM support already. I can see Apple expanding that decision to some European countries or Japan next. All in all, in 3 years, all US iPhones will be eSIM only. Apple pretty much set the deadline for carriers around the world to offer eSIM support.

I’m sure they will succeed at this. But in the meantime USA iPhone owners will be greatly impacted with little to no choices when wanting “local SIM cards “ when overseas.
 
I had an eSIM when I traveled to Italy recently with my iPhone 13 Max Pro. Really seemless. And the price seemed cheaper to me (paid $13 for a 10GB plan via Airalo). Had great service. I didn't have a local calling number, just data, but didn't need a local phone line anyway. Physical SIM cards are great, but there are good eSIM providers now. Betcha they'll be even more now.
And I had a Three UK voice and data pSim that got me averaging 800mpbs on 5G on my USA iPhone 13 PM in the UK for approx £15 a month.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JonnyBravo
I had an eSIM when I traveled to Italy recently with my iPhone 13 Max Pro. Really seemless. And the price seemed cheaper to me (paid $13 for a 10GB plan via Airalo). Had great service. I didn't have a local calling number, just data, but didn't need a local phone line anyway. Physical SIM cards are great, but there are good eSIM providers now. Betcha they'll be even more now.
That's what we can hope for, that Apple doing this will force carriers to adopt eSIM. But wireless service is a highly regulated market, and thus the players (telcos) are usually fat and lazy as they don't have to compete much.

My hope with Apple first, Samsung will be brave enough to follow suit. Samsung has more marketshare worldwide, so together with Apple, they might be a more formidable force in forcing these fat lazy carriers to adopt eSIM. There's a deadline, as in 3 years, all US iPhones will eSIM only. If I were the marketing team of existing carriers that offer prepaid/tourist eSIM, I would advertise the hell out of it promoting support for US iPhone users.
 
That's what we can hope for, that Apple doing this will force carriers to adopt eSIM. But wireless service is a highly regulated market, and thus the players (telcos) are usually fat and lazy as they don't have to compete much.

My hope with Apple first, Samsung will be brave enough to follow suit. Samsung has more marketshare worldwide, so together with Apple, they might be a more formidable force in forcing these fat lazy carriers to adopt eSIM. There's a deadline, as in 3 years, all US iPhones will eSIM only. If I were the marketing team of existing carriers that offer prepaid/tourist eSIM, I would advertise the hell out of it promoting support for US iPhone users.
I don’t understand how Apple can force carriers in said countries to eSim which they still sell models of the iPhone 14 with a physical sim tray 😂 I bet they won’t be in any rush
 
I don’t understand how Apple can force carriers in said countries to eSim which they still sell models of the iPhone 14 with a physical sim tray 😂 I bet they won’t be in any rush
Business travellers, tourists, expats, foreign workers, etc. We live in a global world now that a decision in one country can affect others. For example: Once all US iPhones go eSIM only, if you're a carrier in a country that rely on foreign tourists for main revenue, you might want to support eSIM so you can keep selling your service to US visitors. And the pressure will only get bigger once Apple do the same in more countries.

The earliest deadline is pretty much 3 years from now, when we would expect all US iPhones will be eSIM only. I can see some European countries and/or Japan follow suit in iPhone 15 or 16. Carriers in countries like Singapore better wake up now and be prepared.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mrs. Jobs
Business travellers, tourists, expats, foreign workers, etc. We live in a global world now that a decision in one country can affect others. For example: Once all US iPhones go eSIM only, if you're a carrier in a country that rely on foreign tourists for main revenue, you might want to support eSIM so you can keep selling your service to US visitors. And the pressure will only get bigger once Apple do the same in more countries.

The earliest deadline is pretty much 3 years from now, when we would expect all US iPhones will be eSIM only. I can see some European countries and/or Japan follow suit in iPhone 15 or 16. Carriers in countries like Singapore better wake up now and be prepared.
I see your point. However he should have removed the psim tray on all if not more than just the USA market to speed up the process.
 
Seems to me if everyone is traveling internationally so much you can just buy your phone internationally just to make your point to Apple. Also in the past when they only sold locked phones, a few months after release they would sell an unlocked phone that had all bands so it would work in places like China. That may happen again.
 
Off topic slightly but prepaid AT&T users you can natively convert to esim via the cellular settings in your device settings.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.