Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.





Apple-WWDC24-Apple-Intelligence-Writing-Tools-240610.jpg

“Siri, when was my last flight” just yielded this, so don’t get your hopes too high
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3853.png
    IMG_3853.png
    1 MB · Views: 47
The whole compose and rewrite feature is ChatGPT.

Apples intelligence? Just more of the same we’re used to. Anything significant will be handed off to ChatGPT.
Did you see the demo where it uses ChatGPT? In those cases a dialog appears asking if you want to use ChatGPT. That is not part of the other experiences. They were very clear that that was making a clear distinction between their AI and ChatGPT. The text rewriting is not exclusive to ChatGPT. Other LLMs can do that including Apple's Ajax LLM.
 
I'm extremely skeptical about this. I'm all for privacy so Apple also has their hands tied. I use GPT voice to keep track of random stuff. I would have loved if new AI Siri would manage my day to day more. Such as I just want to tell Siri (naturally) what items i'm missing in my fridge and automatically set reminders and location reminders when I'm near a shop. Apple has this opportunity to make a local assistant. I don't need one where I'm always checking my phone and asking question after question like in the demo.
 
Apple “Intelligence” my butt. Apple trying to pretend they did the hard, intellectual work when this is just a repackaged ChatGPT program.

I'm pretty sure the on device stuff and the compute stuff on Apple's server are Apple's own technology and not OpenAI's.

Are you saying OpenAIs LLMs are going to run on device and on Apple's servers? Did OpenAI provide the source code for these LLMs so they could be compiled as part of iOS?
 
I have the same number of feet as Messi. Doesn't make us equally good footballers, sadly.

I hear and understand that point (it's fair), but has their processor really changed THAT much in 1-year with the same number of cores? They've been advertising that they have the most-advanced AI chips in the industry for years now, but, Android smartphones released much prior to the iPhone 14 are capable of the same on-device AI features.

I suppose my counter would be - if Nike releases (2) high performances shoes (same model name), one in 2022 and the other in 2023, do you think the resistance/added comfort/capabilities would be far apart?
 
Last edited:
The default Apple Intelligence is in-house, no?

Yes, that's the way I interpret it.

There are basically two types of artificial intelligence technologies here.

1) One internal/on device using Apple's own machine learning, neural networks, LLMs, transformers etc.

2) External AIs where ChatGPT is one instance
 
I hear understand that point, but has their processor really changed THAT much in 1-year with the same number of cores? They've been advertising that they have the most-advanced AI chips in the industry for years now, but, Android smartphones released much prior to the iPhone 14 are capable of the same on-device AI features.

I suppose buy counter would be - if Nike releases (2) high performances shoes, one in 2022 and the other in 2023, do you think the resistance would be far apart?
Apple started trying a lot harder with their Neural Engines... they have improved a lot. It can't be compared with annual running shoe updates.
 
Copilot is a far less insufferable and misleading name.

So how do you know Apple Intelligence is using OpenAIs technology?

To me there seems to be to different technology stacks here:

1) Internal / on-device which uses Apple's machine learning, neural networks, LLMs, transformers etc.

2) External which integrates with Siri and other frameworks which ChatGPT is one instance and more are coming later.
 
M1 has more RAM. Also, M1 in Macs can run for much longer at max speed before thermals become an issue.
I’m really thinking it’s a ram thing. Everything that has been confirmed has 8 gigs of ram or more.

Although, the mail, and priority features and even the Genmoji’s I’m pretty sure you don’t need 8 gigs of ram for that. Since every iPhone I have had have those features via Outlook or Spark.
 
Not really, there is a reason why Microsoft requires all windows copilot+ PCs to have minimum 45 TOPs and 16GB RAM to enable similar features. A17 Pro has 35 TOPS vs A16 17 TOPS, A15 15.8 TOPS. But also equally important is RAM, iPhone 15 Pro has 8GB of RAM, devices below that have just 6GB. They are trying to do as much on device as possible.
I otherwise agree with your post, but you're comparing TOPS figures that cannot be compared due to differing levels of accuracy. (8bit vs 16bit)
 
The fact that the "Apple Intelligence" features are only available on the iPhone 15 Pro/Max is absolutely unnecessary, and pushing towards e-waste. Is has the same number of "neural cores" as the iPhone 14 Pro/Max ffs!
GPvVZ8vawAAoGC-
… the A16 doesn’t have 8GB of RAM, and the A17 Pro does.

In fact, all of the supported devices have 8 Gigs of ram or better. I think that’s the constant.
 
I otherwise agree with your post, but you're comparing TOPS figures that cannot be compared due to differing levels of accuracy. (8bit vs 16bit)
I tried to research this topic (8bit vs 16bit), but could not find good information. Do you happen to have a source for this?
 
I tried to research this topic (8bit vs 16bit), but could not find good information. Do you happen to have a source for this?

To some extent, TOPS numbers we are fed are bullsh*t pie in the sky stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MilaM
Apple Intelligence is an unusual name for such a feature… I think their marketing ran out of ideas for names or had none on this feature.

What it does is cool, and looks very promising. But that name.. Im not so sure… I mean it’s not even their own AI technology. It’s a little misleading.
Apple Intelligence. It's using AI in an Apple-like way: to further bring CON-neck-tivity between you and your device and loved ones, privately, securely, personally.
 
I don't think this is true, they would have stated that its being handed off to ChatGPT in those cases. My first thought was that this looks like Grammarly. This isn't new tech, it's possible Apple developed it in-house or it comes from one of the AI startups they've purchased over the years. While it wasn't mind-blowing, examples like these that seemed to come from within the company were hopeful hints that they're taking the catch-up game seriously, same with the Private Cloud powered by Apple Silicon servers.

With ChatGPT from OpenAI integrated into Siri and Writing Tools, you get even more expertise when it might be helpful for you — no need to jump between tools. Siri can tap into ChatGPT for certain requests, including questions about photos or documents. And with Compose in Writing Tools, you can create and illustrate original content from scratch.
 
Some cool use cases, can’t help but notice that for few of them it still feels longer to tell or type what you want it to do than actually doing it yourself.

We’ll see how this works when people start using it. And we’ll see how reliable this is, as AI is known to be…quirky, lol
 
It was pretty clear nothing from Apple Inteligence is done by chat gpt. The only thing they are using ChatGPT for is when you use Siri and they will tell you if you want to do the search on ChatGPT. It’s not integrated, it’s not doing any of the queries, it’s literally just an external link

With ChatGPT from OpenAI integrated into Siri and Writing Tools, you get even more expertise when it might be helpful for you — no need to jump between tools. Siri can tap into ChatGPT for certain requests, including questions about photos or documents. And with Compose in Writing Tools, you can create and illustrate original content from scratch.
 
Well that was a gigantic waste of 30 minutes of my life. Not sure how they can justify gate-keeping their headline feature by only releasing it to ONE of their phones.
By the time iOS releases, Apple will likely have a new generation of phones as well. Plus any supported Macs and iPads. The auto industry works this way as well. Concept cars reveal fatures/specs years ahead of general availability in mid market products, then luxury models, then your average Ford.
 
Did you watch the presentation? Did you notice the only part about ChatGPT was that bit at the end where they can, optionally, send some requests to OpenAI? The rest was all Apple. ChatGPT is an accessory.

With ChatGPT from OpenAI integrated into Siri and Writing Tools, you get even more expertise when it might be helpful for you — no need to jump between tools. Siri can tap into ChatGPT for certain requests, including questions about photos or documents. And with Compose in Writing Tools, you can create and illustrate original content from scratch.
 
Some cool use cases, can’t help but notice that for few of them it still feels longer to tell or type what you want it to do than actually doing it yourself.

We’ll see how this works when people start using it.
I thought the same as well. It's why I don't use predictive text. It takes longer time and more actions to read through several predicted words and select each one than if I just typed or dictated what I want to say.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.