Ugh this thread is filled with some HORRIBLE advice from likely 18-year-olds who think they know how the real world works.
DO NOT call Best Buy and tell them "Oh gee I think I have your stolen iPad, I'd love to give it back but I can't, because see, I paid good money for it... Maybe you can sell me a new one at a discount?" LOL I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the room of the Best Buy manager who answers that call. They'd probably send a cop to your house in no time flat. Best Buy is a huge corporation with callous customer service practices, not a mom and pop shop who will barter with you.
DO NOT call Best Buy and tell them "Oh gee I think I have your stolen iPad, I'd love to give it back but I can't, because see, I paid good money for it... Maybe you can sell me a new one at a discount?" LOL I'd love to be a fly on the wall in the room of the Best Buy manager who answers that call. They'd probably send a cop to your house in no time flat. Best Buy is a huge corporation with callous customer service practices, not a mom and pop shop who will barter with you.