Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I've been wrestling, probably like many others, about the comparative price and performance of the 2021 iPP Pro with (for me my ordered and outfitted with 16GB iPP) and a MacBook.

Added to this price consideration is the my need for a new MK. I just don't think I'll be happy with an ill fitting 2018 MK vs. the 2021 MK. I'm wondering if I'd be better off investing the cost of the 2021 MK into a MacBook (using the funds to upgrade RAM/SSD) and keep my 2018 iPP for the goodness that tables offer?

In the last six months I had a 12" MacBook die on me. While it was a slow-poke, I did like the overall ergonomics of it vs. my 2018 iPP with the MK.

Yes, yes, I know the 2021 iPP has the new screen, and a 5G cellular modem. But so much depends on whether Apple's iOS/developers's apps. really take advantage of the M1 and 16GB.

I think I need to go to the local Apple Store and check out the newest MacBooks as my finger hovers over the iPP cancel order button.
Yeah that’s a good point. I think the reality for a lot of 2018/2020 iPad Pro users is there was such a leap forward with those models in CPU/GPU performance, design with FaceID, Apple Pencil 2, Magic Keyboard that it’s made for a tough decision to upgrade to the 2021 iPad Pro. That’s what it came down to for me. I decided to replace my Mac instead. I ultimately landed on the MacBook Air and the crazy thing is you get an amazing laptop, with M1, 16GB of RAM for sub $1200.
 
Why on earth would you want to upgrade? The need to upgrade every generation needs to die. There is not such thing (in 99% of cases) that anyone would need to upgrade.
Enjoy your device and upgrade when its time, not when new "shiny thing" is out.

The more people take this approach the more we will be better as a society.



I can't see the value right now, but it's no doubt a capable device. I just need see more from iPadOS to justify upgrading my 2018 11 inch Pro. It's my daily driver and hasn't given me an issue with work since it came out. I am still tempted to upgrade, but want to wait to see what happens at WWDC.
 
I can't see the value right now, but it's no doubt a capable device. I just need see more from iPadOS to justify upgrading my 2018 11 inch Pro. It's my daily driver and hasn't given me an issue with work since it came out. I am still tempted to upgrade, but want to wait to see what happens at WWDC.
Just do it if it pleases you and you have the spare money.
Life is short. Always enjoy what you want.
 
Why on earth would you want to upgrade? The need to upgrade every generation needs to die. There is not such thing (in 99% of cases) that anyone would need to upgrade.
Enjoy your device and upgrade when its time, not when new "shiny thing" is out.

The more people take this approach the more we will be better as a society.

Apart from the fact that the post doesn’t indicate yearly updates it’s perfectly fine to do whatever the heck we want with our money.

We’ll be a better society if you learn to focus on yourself rather than eyeing the purchases of others in order to get fake outraged over strangers’ buying patterns.
 
I have to admit, I purchase the 12.9 1TB as an upgrade from my 2018 11" ipp... I still love my 11" and it has pretty much replaced my personal mbp as my daily driver for home use. I still keep second-guessing myself and tbh probably will continue until the 12.9 arrives, but I know that little techie kid inside of me will be all smiles when it does. Yes, it's a LOT of money, but I really have to believe that there is a bigger plan within Apple rather than just bumping the HW specs. Now my biggest question is the case, I really like the magic keyboard but it doesn't seem to offer much protection, I'm eyeing the new Logitec case, but really want to see if the new magic keyboard has any surprises once it comes out with the new ipp... ugh real problem, too many choices.
 
Where did I say yearly?

Sure, everyone can do whatever they want with their money but at the same time why not be sensible?

Our grandparents didn't live in this crazy 'consumerism' time so why not learn a bit from that? Is it really that terrible to tell someone to enjoy the device he/she has when its perfectly fine for his/her needs?

Anyway, have a great week. ;-)

Apart from the fact that the post doesn’t indicate yearly updates it’s perfectly fine to do whatever the heck we want with our money.

We’ll be a better society if you learn to focus on yourself rather than eyeing the purchases of others in order to get fake outraged over strangers’ buying patterns.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Broadus
Why on earth would you want to upgrade? The need to upgrade every generation needs to die. There is not such thing (in 99% of cases) that anyone would need to upgrade.
Enjoy your device and upgrade when its time, not when new "shiny thing" is out.

The more people take this approach the more we will be better as a society.
I agree and my mindset has certainly changed the last few years. I tended to always upgrade, but it just feels so meaningless nowadays with no tangible difference from device to device. Of course, everyone's usage and needs are different, so it's certainly not a blanket statement. Just a personal one.
 
Reformatted the original post so it's easier to read:

Originally I had decided on the 12.9" iPad Pro 256GB w/ Cellular (in Silver, with coordinating White Magic Keyboard) for just slightly north of my $2,000 budget upon adding AppleCare and applying account credit. After further careful consideration:

I'm the weirdo who
  • doesn't "consume" much tele-visual media [movies, shows]
  • doesn't work in a demandingly creative field or do a lot of digital art
  • prefers to reduce his cellular usage/bill where possible
  • doesn't gravitate toward the largest of displays anyway for the sake of portability and simplicity [still using my trusty 10.6" display-equipped 256GB/8GB Surface Pro 2 from 2013]
  • clearly needs his investment to last as long as possible
I decided last night to cancel my original iPad Pro XDR pre-order and go with something potentially far more logical — and powerful — for similar funds (approx. $70 more, all things [cheaper AppleCare/keyboard] considered).

Enter iPad Pro 11", 1TB, Wi-Fi (in Space Gray with Black Magic Keyboard).

I know I said I'm not the most power-hungry user but as a tech nerd I can and certainly do appreciate:
  • sheer power and capability especially where it may extend the potential lifespan of my investment and
  • improve general, day-to-day quality of life within the confines of Apple's walled garden OS
Heck, if 16GB of RAM can virtually eliminate the chances of a Safari tab or entire application having to reload as well as help ensure the device's longevity as iPadOS and future software grow potentially more resource-greedy, then I'm all for it).

The earlier slated date of arrival (May 24-Jun 1, as opposed to the XDR's Jun 2-Jun 9), to be fully honest, helped assuage any lingering fears I may have made the wrong decision.

:)

Postscript/edit: I just checked the receipts to be sure and the price increase was actually more like $32 for 4x the storage and 2x the RAM—not too shabby. Sorry I wasn’t more accurate in my original post.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: sorgo †
I agree and my mindset has certainly changed the last few years. I tended to always upgrade, but it just feels so meaningless nowadays with no tangible difference from device to device. Of course, everyone's usage and needs are different, so it's certainly not a blanket statement. Just a personal one.
I upgraded from a Surface Go to a Surface Go 2 for half an inch of screen real estate and possibly a little spec bump. I’ve had 9.7, 10.5, and 2018 iPP 11, Mini 4 and Mini 5. Plan to get 2021 iPP 11 and probably a new Mini when the next generation is released.

I am running a 10-year-old Windows workstation that’s been upgraded with RAM and a couple of SSDs but I overbought processor when I bought and the two 24” screens running in portrait mode are doing just dandy. I drive a 17-year-old car, buy clothes at thrift stores or other relatively inexpensive places. Don’t have cable, biggest TV is 32” flat screen several years old.

Don’t spend money on travel or fancy meals or fancy food.

Portable computing devices are my main “vice”. I’m pretty frugal about just about everything else.

It’s nobody else’s business what someone sets as priorities for their spending.
 
I wanted to downsize to the M1 11" from my 2018 IPP 12.9". The lack of Mini-LED just made me hesitate.

After thinking about it. I just decided to cancel it. I am certainly buying the 16" M1 MBP that is going to be coming soon.

Better to save up money so that I can get the configuration that I want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: calstanford
Keeping my 12.9 cellular model on order. My current iPad Pro is a first gen 9.7” from 2015. 120hz screen, cellular, and microLED display are all upgrades for me.
I'm in the exact same position! The 9.7 is still working fine, although the battery's hurting a tish and I'm looking forward to the new screen. I ended up going for the 256GB - the 128GB on my 9.7 hadn't been an issue aside from some of my apps auto offloading whenever I download some videos.
 
I’ve got an air 2 since it’s launch already. So I’m really looking forward to my 12.9 iPP.
I think it’s really situation dependent. If you have an iPP2020, why on earth upgrade?
If you have an iPad Air 2? Man, it’s gonna be an insane upgrade!
Same, I wanna finally upgrade from iPad Air 2! Performance and Battery-life is literally non existent! :D Have it since 01/2015!
 
I've been using an iPad Mini for years, going through the various iterations. I really like their size, but got the 12.9" pro because 'bigger is better'. *sigh*

It has a dead pixel, which is irking me, but...

So 'big' is BIG. It's faster, it has more storage, I also got the combo unit, JIC. Bonus that it fits in my main carry-on too (I didn't check before ordering it).

I'm not sorry I got BIG, but I could have saved some by going 11" and drop the cellular. I really debated with myself if I would actually like BIG, and thought that with the Pencil, and such, it offers flexibility.

So, how is it going? It's BIG for sure. I'm using it more and more, and the Mini less, basically because I bought the dang thing... It's pretty awesome. Minus the dead pixel shining back at me, BIG is great so far.

I could have lived with the 11", but the difference was so small, it seemed like an argument for spending the few bucks and getting BIG for a change. I may still get the next iteration of the Mini. I do like the size for quick trips, etc...

Sometime big is just right. I can't see anything bigger. Yikes...


Funny on the price difference, I had a spreadsheet (definitally not overthinking that decision, yep), and had a hard time talking myself out of BIG. 'It's only 'X' number of dollars'. Damn you APPLE!!! 😀😀😀
 
And why would a doctor’s office spend $20 for a thumb drive to give you when a $0.25 DVD gets the job done for 80 times less expense?
They shouldn’t do either. The US healthcare system is a mess, but they don’t hand out CDs with your info on it. They have software that shares this info electronically and if that doesn’t work, snail-mail printed info or just have them hand you a paper copy. And those are small doctors offices. This isn’t a big ask. It’s 2021 and healthcare isn’t cheap.

I wasn’t SUGGESTING doctors SHOULD use thumb drives. I was suggesting they SHOULDNT use CDs.

On a completely different level -
Thumb drives don’t cost $20. That’s a joke. Buy in bulk (like an office would) maybe a dollar. Maybe!

Plus… an alchohol swab doesn’t cost $40, but in the US, that’s what your bill could say if you don’t have insurance.
 
I upgraded from a Surface Go to a Surface Go 2 for half an inch of screen real estate and possibly a little spec bump. I’ve had 9.7, 10.5, and 2018 iPP 11, Mini 4 and Mini 5. Plan to get 2021 iPP 11 and probably a new Mini when the next generation is released.

I am running a 10-year-old Windows workstation that’s been upgraded with RAM and a couple of SSDs but I overbought processor when I bought and the two 24” screens running in portrait mode are doing just dandy. I drive a 17-year-old car, buy clothes at thrift stores or other relatively inexpensive places. Don’t have cable, biggest TV is 32” flat screen several years old.

Don’t spend money on travel or fancy meals or fancy food.

Portable computing devices are my main “vice”. I’m pretty frugal about just about everything else.

It’s nobody else’s business what someone sets as priorities for their spending.
I agree. I gave my opinion, like I said.
 
They shouldn’t do either. The US healthcare system is a mess, but they don’t hand out CDs with your info on it. They have software that shares this info electronically and if that doesn’t work, snail-mail printed info or just have them hand you a paper copy. And those are small doctors offices. This isn’t a big ask. It’s 2021 and healthcare isn’t cheap.

I wasn’t SUGGESTING doctors SHOULD use thumb drives. I was suggesting they SHOULDNT use CDs.

On a completely different level -
Thumb drives don’t cost $20. That’s a joke. Buy in bulk (like an office would) maybe a dollar. Maybe!

Plus… an alchohol swab doesn’t cost $40, but in the US, that’s what your bill could say if you don’t have insurance.

Non sequitur...
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.