dell released their newest ultrasharp model ,U2723QE, U3223QE ultrasharp monitor

[chekie]

Made an account just because of this thread so thanks to everyone who has helped.

I order 2 Dell UP2723QE on March 16th and received them March 29th three days ahead of the original estimate. Unfortunately I received rev A00 and both were manufactured Dec 2021. I’m going to do some of the testing in this thread and see if I want to exchange them.

I have a personal 2021 MacBook Pro M1 Max with Monterey, and a 2017 MacBook Pro with Big Sur for work. I'll be using the monitors with both.

First opinion so far after using them for half a day for work, is that I am perfectly ok with native resolution and it isn't blurry for me. I'm coming from a single Dell P2419H which is 1080 so this is a big upgrade. I'm a programmer so my biggest reason for buying is the higher resolution to see more on the screen.

Interesting. Not sure how Dell dispatches their products, but I ordered a 2nd one on Mar 11 and received on Mar 17. It was also manufactured Dec 2021 but it's Rev A01. I asked their technical support about the revision and was told that Rev A01 has no functional change and it's just a regulatory change. Whatever that means.

 

[darkes]

Anyone else try using the 3mm on an external display and have any success adjusting volume? Sound comes through the 3mm but I can only adjust volume from within an application not using the keyboard. When I go to System Preferences I get "The selected device has no output controls". I see the speaker/volume icon adjust when I press the key but it doesn't adjust anything. Really annoying. MacBook Pro M1 Max 2021 macOS 12.3 (21E230) with Dell U2723QE.

 

[Degrader]

For the ones who like detailed test results (of Tweakers, Dutch site): U2723QE and U3223QE

 

[chekie]

For the ones who like detailed test results (of Tweakers, Dutch site): U2723QE and U3223QE

Average color temperature

6.092 kelvin

Unbelievable...

 

[RabidMacFan]

Anyone else try using the 3mm on an external display and have any success adjusting volume? Sound comes through the 3mm but I can only adjust volume from within an application not using the keyboard. When I go to System Preferences I get "The selected device has no output controls". I see the speaker/volume icon adjust when I press the key but it doesn't adjust anything. Really annoying. MacBook Pro M1 Max 2021 macOS 12.3 (21E230) with Dell U2723QE.

According to the manual, the Audio line-out is meant for speakers and "does not support headphones".

I think what they mean by that is that the speakers you connect to the audio jack will need their own power and volume controls.

If that doesn't work for you, you might be able to use headphones with inline volume control, or a USB-based DAC for audio instead.

 

[darkes]

According to the manual, the Audio line-out is meant for speakers and "does not support headphones".

I think what they mean by that is that the speakers you connect to the audio jack will need their own power and volume controls.

If that doesn't work for you, you might be able to use headphones with inline volume control, or a USB-based DAC for audio instead.

Thanks, I definitely would like some speakers eventually so that's go to know it should easier than what I had to do right now.

To get it working I just set up SoundSource and I'm going to see to test if it's worth paying for. Only downside is that it shows the speaker/volume being adjusted icon on the main monitor and not the one in focus. I do like that it warned me before quitting the app that I should make sure the volume of what I'm listening to is lowered so it doesn't get too loud. Ended up disabling the volume controls from MonitorControl. The install for SourceSource was kind of convoluted, I was going to try other options especially Sound Control in both design and price. Anyone prefer Sound Control?

 

[darkes]

Gave them both SoundSource and Sound Control a try and they both can do what I need. for me SoundSource is giving me more confidence. Here's a review of both again my setup is MacBook Pro M1 Max 2021 macOS 12.3 (21E230) with dual Dell U2723QE monitors. The reason I am considering either is for 3mm jack in the display for my headphones. Spotify in Safari is my primary use case.

SoundSource
- $40
- Does what I want.
- When listening to something and you quit SoundSource and start it again it works as expected.
- Can adjust volume from keyboard and the slider in the SoundSource UI.
- Install was a hassle.
- Not a of the default green and wish I could just choose a color and not have to mess with OS wide color settings to change it.

Sound Control
- $25
- Does what I want.
- When listening to something and you quit Sound Control and start it again I always have to refresh the browser page.
- Can only adjust volume from keyboard. The slider in the Sound Control UI is disabled like in macOS settings.
- Not sure if install was more convenient because I already did the work for SoundSource.

Both of them show the volume adjustments on the main monitor, and do the loud volume warning.


I'm going to go for SoundSource.

 

[81Tiger04]

A month and a half after ordering, I finally got my U3223QE … Only for it to be one someone else sent back. The box had clearly been ripped open previously and then taped together prior to shipment. I’ll be damned if I’m going to pay $1k for a monitor that someone else clearly rejected. I’m sending back in the morning.

 

[milliways15]

My two U2723QE monitors that I ordered arrived yesterday, in preparation for my Mac Studio Max that should be arriving in a week or two.

I got them to replace my two existing monitors:

• 2017 27" iMac (5k retina display) and my current machine
• 2011 27" iMac (1440p display) connected through Target Display Mode

I set one up, Rev A01 and manufactured in January 2022. I'm planning to set up the other once the Mac Studio arrives.

My primary use cases:

• Photography, color correction and editing in Lightroom
• Work, spreadsheets and documents

Some early notes:

• I have a 2017 MacBook Pro that I use for work. I connected it via the included USB-C cable, and my 2017 iMac through USB-C DisplayPort adapter + the included DisplayPort cable, and it's super convenient to use the input menu to switch back and forth between the two. Orders of magnitude easier than moving the Thunderbolt cable between the MBP and my iMac. The USB hub in the monitor is also really helpful, and eliminated the dongle hub that I was using before.
• When I first connected the 2017 MBP, the refresh rate was 30Hz, not 60Hz. I had to go into System Preferences, and manually set the refresh rate to 60Hz. I'm not sure why this wasn't the default to begin with.
• The brightness and color is great overall. That being said, when I set the color profile to DCI P3 on the Dell monitor, and mirror the same YouTube video between the 2017 5k iMac, the greens appear slightly more vibrant on the iMac. When watching a movie on Disney Plus, the skin tones look slightly warmer on the iMac. I ordered a monitor calibrator, so we'll see if that makes any difference.
• When comparing the 5k iMac to the 4k Dell display purely from a pixel and resolution perspective, the iMac is very marginally better, but not so much that I could easily pick between the two without getting in close. I set the Dell to an interpolated 1440p scale, and from a sitting distance of ~2-3 feet, I don't have any issues with it. This was my biggest concern switching from the iMac to the 4k display, and it doesn't bother me.
• I tried to see if there was any contrast/darkness difference between the 5k iMac and the Dell from the IPS Black, but I couldn't see anything significant.

I was deciding between these monitors, and the Apple Studio Display. I ended up going with these monitors because for less than the price of a single Studio Display, I was able to replace both older iMac displays. At least out of the box, the color gamut appears to be slightly worse than the 5k iMac in a direct comparison. If I wasn't looking at both at once, I'd be very happy with the color and quality of the Dell monitors.

 

[81Tiger04]

A month and a half after ordering, I finally got my U3223QE … Only for it to be one someone else sent back. The box had clearly been ripped open previously and then taped together prior to shipment. I’ll be damned if I’m going to pay $1k for a monitor that someone else clearly rejected. I’m sending back in the morning.

Contacted Dell this morning and they’re sending a new unit. Just showed them the pics and no problem at all. Great customer service!

 

[greenbreadmmm]

well it finally came. Taped up and opened before, missing cables, cardboard and paperwork.

I can't believe this is the condition they deliver this in. Just watched an unboxing video.

 

[Spacegray]

well it finally came. Taped up and opened before, missing cables, cardboard and paperwork.

I can't believe this is the condition they deliver this in. Just watched an unboxing video.

Looks like an early april joke. Where did you buy it?

 

[greenbreadmmm]

Looks like an early april joke. Where did you buy it?

Dell.com

Support has been...challenging, to say the least

 

[greenbreadmmm]

Dell.com

Support has been...challenging, to say the least

Decided to open to up, screen is shattered too.

Jan 22 manufacture date Rev A01

Best support can do is 4/25 replacement..Even worse, they want me to tape up this box and send it back full of broken screens and missing cables.

 

[Degrader]

Average color temperature

6.092 kelvin

Unbelievable...

With my sample which is a Rev A01 the average color temperature is 6750K, so no yellowish hue. With the two Rev A00 I had the color temperature was around the 6200K. I heard from Tweakers that they have tested a Rev A00 unit.

 

[chekie]

With my sample which is a Rev A01 the average color temperature is 6750K, so no yellowish hue. With the two Rev A00 I had the color temperature was around the 6200K. I heard from Tweakers that they have tested a Rev A00 unit.

My A00 unit is also a lot warmer than my A01 - easily 500K+ difference. Something definitely changed. I don't think they were honest in saying there is no functional change and just regulatory change.

 

[chekie]

Decided to open to up, screen is shattered too.

Jan 22 manufacture date Rev A01

Best support can do is 4/25 replacement..Even worse, they want me to tape up this box and send it back full of broken screens and missing cables.

This is the third case I see just in this thread that received an open-box item. Can't say I'm not disappointed.

 

[password1234]

According to the manual, the Audio line-out is meant for speakers and "does not support headphones".

I think what they mean by that is that the speakers you connect to the audio jack will need their own power and volume controls.

If that doesn't work for you, you might be able to use headphones with inline volume control, or a USB-based DAC for audio instead.

What they mean is that it's just output, there is no support for microphone (input).

PS: you can still connect a headphone, the microphone just won't work.

 

[greenbreadmmm]

Decided to open to up, screen is shattered too.

Jan 22 manufacture date Rev A01

Best support can do is 4/25 replacement..Even worse, they want me to tape up this box and send it back full of broken screens and missing cables.

I feel like I'm up **** creek.

This is the third case I see just in this thread that received an open-box item. Can't say I'm not disappointed.

I think this is ups breaking box and trying to rebuild. No power cable, shattered screen, missing cardboard. None less worst customer service I’ve had to interact with in ages.

 

[81Tiger04]

well it finally came. Taped up and opened before, missing cables, cardboard and paperwork.

I can't believe this is the condition they deliver this in. Just watched an unboxing video.

This is exactly what mine looked like when I received it. I sent it back.

 

[greenbreadmmm]

This is exactly what mine looked like when I received it. I sent it back.

did you ask for a replacement? how was that? Also, how long that take to replace?

 

[EPO75]

Anyone got Freesync/VRR to work, I know it's max 60hz, but 40-60hz VRR can make a bit of a difference. With my 32 inch variant I don't have the VRR option available on USB-C. Dell is advertising with Freesync so it should be possible..

 

[greenbreadmmm]

Anyone got Freesync/VRR to work, I know it's max 60hz, but 40-60hz VRR can make a bit of a difference. With my 32 inch variant I don't have the VRR option available on USB-C. Dell is advertising with Freesync so it should be possible..

this is the one monitor on their website that does NOT call out free sync or any variable refresh. Where are you seeing this?

 

[5425642]

Recommended settings after I have calibrated my;
Contrast: 75

Present Modes -> Custom Color
R: 99%
G: 95%
B: 99%

 

[EPO75]

this is the one monitor on their website that does NOT call out free sync or any variable refresh. Where are you seeing this?

Your unfortunately correct, i am blind