Bravo. All of it.
----------
My memory may not be serving me right, but I recall you being quite fervent that the S3-to-S4 upgrades were "just like Apple -- small upgrades." You went on and on about the irony of how Samsung has become the very thing Apple-haters hate about Apple. Minor upgrades, etc.
If I'm remembering this all wrong (it was many months ago) then excuse me. My apologies.
No you're pretty correct. But I think I tend to have a different definition of minor upgrades and innovations than most here.
While I think the GS3 > GS4 was nothing mind-blowing or innovative, I thought and still think it was a nice update. Same as I think about the 4S > 5.
The whole Samsung irony thing is true in a lot of ways. But it really only has to do with fanboys on each side - each accusing the other side of the same stuff.
I've had to say this a lot today, for whatever reason. If I'm an Apple fanboy, I'm a terrible one because my daily driver is a GS4 and I'll readily admit I like it.
As for the above post you so fervently agree with - this is the part where it begins to break down:
"Saying innovation has reached a plateau is nonsense and I see it spoken by iPhone users all the time. You personally may find no need for further advances (though I doubt that) but millions of others don't."
Saying innovation has reached a plateau does not mean I don't find any need for further advances. In fact, saying we reached a slowing in innovation has nothing to do with my own preferences on the matter. I'm (and others) are simply saying to expect innovation year after year is ludicrous (and setting yourself up for disappointment) because of the simple place the smartphone industry is in.
Would we welcome innovation if it came? Of course! But that doesn't mean we have to complain and cry for it when the phones work perfectly well already.
I find it hilarious that many times, when I try to bring forth the idea that people are overreacting and that Apple is fine, I'm labeled a fanboy. When the reality is, I'm simply content. Is this a crime?
Innovation won't happen because forum posters cry about wanting more features and complain that one platform is behind.
----------
The funny thing is I'm not even necessarily asking or requiring Apple to innovate.
Nearly everything I would ask of Apple for the iPhone has already been done. I would just like them to do it! Larger screens, more customization, more freedom (even a hair more), better keyboard, file sharing, etc.
These aren't demands for innovations. These are demands to catch up.
You shouldn't be demanding these at all from Apple - you should simply go with the platform that works the best for you.
I know you heard this before, but I'll say it again:
Apple has a philosophy. Google has a philosophy (along with the OEMs). It is not within Apple's philosophy to offer all these things. Perhaps they will acquiesce on some (larger screens for instance) but others, like a file system or more customization (depending on what you even mean as that's a very general statement) probably won't happen because it's not within the nature of iOS.
Obviously you think the above statements ludicrous. Which is why Android exists. You are free to go with a platform that offers all of these choices you list. While those of us who prefer iOS the way it is (philosophically speaking) continue to use iPhones. You don't have to understand WHY we prefer iOS, just accept that some of us like it the way it is.
That doesn't mean we don't want ANYTHING changed. But I actually happen to prefer the way iOS handles files. There are improvements to be made for sure, but I don't want a file system and would find that a negative if it were implemented in iOS as it is in Android.
I've asked you this before - maybe you'll answer this time. If Android offers you everything you want (at least the stuff you mentioned iOS needs) and the ecosystem thing isn' a problem (which you've stated), WHY do you want iOS to change so much? Why is a big enough deal to you that you post about it? Why not just use Android and be happy?