Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ariel

macrumors regular
Sep 15, 2003
149
8
All in all, everyone is entitled to their opinion. I just couldn't resist commenting. I wonder if the developer would have grounds for a law suit based on the contractual agreement between apple and developers- I don't think they can censor apps based on content verses price. Who are they to say how much the content of an app is worth. It seems he simply sold an image for a large amount of money. This app could set a precedence for future apps. I would think he could sue for loss of revenue or something like that -provided he didn't violate the developers agreement

Just wanted you to know that i read your comments but refuse to comment. Not worth my time
 

whooleytoo

macrumors 604
Aug 2, 2002
6,607
716
Cork, Ireland.
All in all, everyone is entitled to their opinion. I just couldn't resist commenting. I wonder if the developer would have grounds for a law suit based on the contractual agreement between apple and developers- I don't think they can censor apps based on content verses price. Who are they to say how much the content of an app is worth. It seems he simply sold an image for a large amount of money. This app could set a precedence for future apps. I would think he could sue for loss of revenue or something like that -provided he didn't violate the developers agreement

Hmm, maybe if I made an app with 2 diamonds for just 499.99, that's much better value, they'd HAVE to let that one up there! :)
 

branjosef

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2007
940
0
1.222.333.456
Hmm, maybe if I made an app with 2 diamonds for just 499.99, that's much better value, they'd HAVE to let that one up there! :)

OH! if you make them "Product Red", then apple would have to let you sell them. As my one friend says "It goes to help the Africas" *She's an idiot
 

bytethese

macrumors 68030
Jun 20, 2007
2,707
120
except you need vista to play DX10 games but your a mac user so i guess you dont play games except for maybe.. EA's harry potter?

I'm a Mac user, but I play games on my PS3. :) Nothing like 1080p games on a 56" tv. :)
 

Pandora01

macrumors regular
Mar 21, 2008
213
0
Toronto
I don't understand why Apple would allow this in the store anyway. It's not even an app, it's just an icon. Don't they have any sort of vetting process, or do they just allow everything in the store that is submitted to them, as long as it doesn't violate any laws?

Anyway, as a woman, I thank you all for assuming the buyers were men. I wholeheartedly agree with you that only guys would be this stupid. ;)
 

Darkroom

Guest
Dec 15, 2006
2,445
0
Montréal, Canada
I think we're all jealous. The developer is a genius, and Apple is wrong for pulling it.

i agree... it's really great work... a successful performance piece that underlined the indulgence of some members of the modern upper class... apple has no right to take it down... the show must go on.
 

kyleb822

macrumors member
Jun 9, 2008
96
0
this dude is smart...he just made $5600 because only 8 dumb people bought his app. Who cares if Apple decided to pull the plug this guy made some bank!!
 

branjosef

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2007
940
0
1.222.333.456
I don't understand why Apple would allow this in the store anyway. It's not even an app, it's just an icon. Don't they have any sort of vetting process, or do they just allow everything in the store that is submitted to them, as long as it doesn't violate any laws?

Anyway, as a woman, I thank you all for assuming the buyers were men. I wholeheartedly agree with you that only guys would be this stupid. ;)

The only way a women would have bought this is if her man lied to her about the price ;)
 

Gasu E.

macrumors 603
Mar 20, 2004
5,089
3,207
Not far from Boston, MA.
I am so desperate to get this application, I would pay three times the original price.

Its art, and its brilliant. Not everything you pay for has to have an application. Screw practicality.

In the words of Werner Herzog "money is cowardly" - if you have it coming out of your ears why not spend it...as Jobs once said "who want to be the richest guy in cemetery". I say you only live once.

You are quite right. In fact this thread itself is fantastic conceptual art. We should all get royalties!
 

branjosef

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2007
940
0
1.222.333.456
I know this is off the subject, but I wanted to pass this out to everyone...


http://www.9to5mac.com/police_state

Apparently this has been in effect since the beginning of the year. I started another forum for this and sent it in to macrumors news info. I know there was a forum about it potentially becoming a law, but I guess it is already in effect. Just trying to get the word out.
 

jdechko

macrumors 601
Jul 1, 2004
4,230
325
I'm going to agree with all the people asking where the personal responsibility is. If you've got 1-Click enabled, you have to be more careful. It's not the Developers fault that you have set preferences in iTunes. And to say that Apple should prompt you on any purchase over $X.XX (for any value of X), that's why the shopping cart is there in the first place - it's a way to ask "Are you sure?" But I do think Apple should actually allow you to place apps in a shopping cart. As it stands, it does, however, prompt you before making a purchase.
 

ariel

macrumors regular
Sep 15, 2003
149
8
I'm going to agree with all the people asking where the personal responsibility is. If you've got 1-Click enabled, you have to be more careful. It's not the Developers fault that you have set preferences in iTunes. And to say that Apple should prompt you on any purchase over $X.XX (for any value of X), that's why the shopping cart is there in the first place - it's a way to ask "Are you sure?" But I do think Apple should actually allow you to place apps in a shopping cart. As it stands, it does, however, prompt you before making a purchase.

Ah, but alas, the App store works differently than your other settings!

I have "Buy using a shopping cart" selected in my iTunes preferences. Yet, clicking on an application does NOT go to my cart - it is an instant purchase!

This is totally contrary to expected behavior. anyone who has purchased songs with the "store" would NOT (edited to add the NOT that i left out before) expect the application store to work differently yet it does. I have never been prompted when buying in the app store in iTunes... purchases are instant and i get no confirmation or option to approve.

There is no tab in the preferences anywhere for changing the behavior of the Application Store and therefore Apple has made a mistake here. And therefore should refund anyone who mistakenly purchased this application.

Calling people idiots for something that is clearly an unexpected behavior is in my opinion not appropriate. Apple should make all purchases work the same way.

It is also true that you don't have a shopping cart on the phone itself. Purchases there are instant too.
 

philbeeney

macrumors 6502
Jul 24, 2004
496
50
Vankleek Hill
I read the review calling this app a scam and how apple needs to screen better. Whatever happened to being responsible for your own actions. if I want to put an app on the app store that says "Sucker" and offer it for $3.00 or $3000 and someone buys it, then thats on them. I saw the app when it came out and the last thing I was going to do was hit "buy". I think the developer should get his money and no one should get a refund. We have a problem with people thinking they can do what they want to and won't be held accountable. What's sad is that this is true. People just say they made a mistake or they didn't know and its okay- everyone forgives them. Maybe we need a good depression to instill some strife in everyone. I don't ever recall old people acting this way when I grew up. They were very responsible and frugal. Way to screw it up baby boomers. :eek:

I totally agree 100% with what you say. People should not be anywhere near the app store let alone an iphone or ipod touch if they don't know how to use it properly. I wouldn't let anybody near a car if they didn't know how to drive.

The developer described exactly what the app was and did. Those people saying the app is a scam obviously have no brain cells or any scrap of common sense. Those are the people we should be afraid of.
 

branjosef

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2007
940
0
1.222.333.456
Ah, but alas, the App store works differently than your other settings!

I have "Buy using a shopping cart" selected in my iTunes preferences. Yet, clicking on an application does NOT go to my cart - it is an instant purchase!

This is totally contrary to expected behavior. anyone who has purchased songs with the "store" would NOT (edited to add the NOT that i left out before) expect the application store to work differently yet it does. I have never been prompted when buying in the app store in iTunes... purchases are instant and i get no confirmation or option to approve.

There is no tab in the preferences anywhere for changing the behavior of the Application Store and therefore Apple has made a mistake here. And therefore should refund anyone who mistakenly purchased this application.

Calling people idiots for something that is clearly an unexpected behavior is in my opinion not appropriate. Apple should make all purchases work the same way.

It is also true that you don't have a shopping cart on the phone itself. Purchases there are instant too.


I agree with your point about the app store operating differently. When I initially downloaded apps, I tried out a free one first just to make sure I was doing everything correctly- Once I figured out how everything worked, I moved on to a few paid apps. I did see this app and just stayed away. I do think your point is valid
 

ariel

macrumors regular
Sep 15, 2003
149
8
I totally agree 100% with what you say. People should not be anywhere near the app store let alone an iphone or ipod touch if they don't know how to use it properly.

Just how do you know how to use it 'properly' when Apple has programmed it to work differently than every other part of the store? iTunes is ignoring my "add to cart" choice in the preferences and for an application does "instant purchase" - the only way to learn that is to click the buy button.

Call me an idiot if you want - but applications that don't follow expected user behavior are not the fault of the user.
 

mac jones

macrumors 68040
Apr 6, 2006
3,257
2
UH

The 8 or 9 people who purchased this app are most certainly a statistical glitch.

such as:

1) mistaking 999. for 9.99
2) mistaken location of links and buttons (hitting wrong app).
3) other random results.
4) juveniles with stolen credit cards (or parents/sibling cards)

Yet you all seem to imagine other scenarios where some nouveau riche are flaunting money while wallowing in hubris .

such imaginations.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.