Shouldn't the mac be easing the journey from novice to expert, instead of shoring up class distinctions?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
El Capitan: Does this mark the death of OS X as a serious OS?
- Thread starter B-Eugen
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Shouldn't the mac be easing the journey from novice to expert, instead of shoring up class distinctions?
that's probably the most juvenile post i've seen on the macrumors forums in some time; congrats!
The obscurity? I accept that it’s a necessity, but it’s an unfortunate loss of intuitiveness and comes at the cost of hiding useful features from users who might otherwise never find them unless specifically told where to look.
So, apple stopped an animation for the time machine icon spinning (so it is now less distracting and consumes less power and potentially a little less CPU because there's no animation when backing up), and you're running a pre-release OS that isn't finished, OS X is dead as a professional OS?
Right....
Methinks you aren't a professional at all, if those even rate in your list of quibbles about whether or not an OS is professional, and the fact that you're running a beta or developer preview on your production machine and making judgements on the state of OS X with it.
Right....
Methinks you aren't a professional at all, if those even rate in your list of quibbles about whether or not an OS is professional, and the fact that you're running a beta or developer preview on your production machine and making judgements on the state of OS X with it.
I have submitted a bug report that the button label should change to 'Calibrate (expert)' or something like that when option key is pressed. I agree that right now the behaviour is not transparent.
You must be kidding. Jony would look at Kim Kardashian in disgust and mutter "make it thinner".
Last edited:
but OS X is (and has been) full of these 'second-level' options; and, if someone needs that functionality, easy enough to ask an apple 'genius', or google the issue, or post for help on a forum like this. the internet's perfect for this sort of thing!
When you don't know functionality exists, you can't ask how to use it. Hiding useful functionality is not a user-friendly gesture.
Since 10.7 onwards, OS X never came out of BETA...
Dunno, it took me exactly 3 seconds to find it. Without knowing where or how to look. The OS is really very consistent about hidden features. If you are missing a feature, press and hold the option key. If nothing changed, then probably there is not advanced functionality. There is no need to document this, just as there is no need to document that the button 'Open Profile' opens a profile file.
So far, the only real issue I can see that the Calibrate button does not change when you press the option key, thus not giving you any indication that its behaviour will change. That is a clear bug and has to be fixed.
You surely mean 10.0
If you guys think OS X never came out of BETA, well you haven't been running Windows since 3.1 like I have...
that makes no sense. if you don't need a certain function, it makes no difference if it's visible or not. and if you do need it, you can easily find out if it's do-able, and how to do it. simple!
Time Machine is a "set and forget" system. Being constantly bugged with an animation is not part of such a system. Backups are done regularly, every hour so missing a few backups isn't that much of a problem. The system should also be intelligent enough to accustom for being interrupted while doing the backup procedure. It seems that they've managed to get it to do just that. In other words: you simply turn it on and that's it. You don't have to worry about it which was and still is the entire purpose of Time Machine. If you take a look at special backup software and how Windows and Solaris do it then you'll see that they don't do it that much differently than Time Machine. They only give you a message when the backup procedure is done (backup failed, backup successful), usually via e-mail.
Except that Exposé has never been removed from OS X.
Which has always been the case. If you want proper adjustment of your display you need hardware plus accompanying software (aka a colorimeter at the very least) and you need to calibrate regularly (depending on what you do this could be once a year up to continuously). You never ever use the option in the OS to do this as this is entirely software only with no measurement of the display whatsoever. So is this is a showstopper? Absolutely not. Know your tools
Btw, if you think that you only need to calibrate your display to have accurate colours you are absolutely wrong. The workplace has to be adjusted and so do the other equipment and the lighting (which cannot be changed because if you do, you need to recalibrate everything). There simply is so much more to it.
It's not the OS that is dumbing down here. What I see here is someone not (fully) understanding his tools and blaming it on something else. It is better to invest some time in getting to know your tools and how you should do things (use a colorimeter and NOT the tooling in OS X for example).
Last edited:
No, it's not the death of OS X as a serious OS. This is a beta. It's not ready for public or professional consumption.
Wait until it's released to complain about how it jacks up your work flow.
People have been complaining of "dumbing down" OS X since Lion got some interface elements that reminded of iOS. People confuse consistency across devices with dumbing down.
In fact, when compared to Windows, OS X is much more "work oriented". It never gets in my way, offers tools that I can't find in Windows, let's me focus on my work. A lot of options I don't care about and would only distract me are hidden, but can be accessed easily if I really wanted them and the instructions are just one Google search away. While Microsoft is still toying around with how things look skin deep, Apple adds functionality, performance and new ways to boost productivity.
Some people will always find things to complain about, but for me, OS X has never felt better for "real work".
In fact, when compared to Windows, OS X is much more "work oriented". It never gets in my way, offers tools that I can't find in Windows, let's me focus on my work. A lot of options I don't care about and would only distract me are hidden, but can be accessed easily if I really wanted them and the instructions are just one Google search away. While Microsoft is still toying around with how things look skin deep, Apple adds functionality, performance and new ways to boost productivity.
Some people will always find things to complain about, but for me, OS X has never felt better for "real work".
Because the majority of Windows users are clearly adept at the intuitive tool Regedit, right?
If the option is there, you can’t assume that people may not want to use it. That would be pointless. Again, nobody is suggesting that the solution is bad. But it is a fact that hidden options are not user friendly. Sometimes even the worst implementation is still a solution to a problem.
i genuinely don't get what you're saying; how hard is it to google? or ask on forums like this? even, say, 90% of users don't need a certain function...all is well. and for the others, there are resources, with answers.
either way, this seems to be apple's philosophy, so we adapt...or go elsewhere. thankfully, there are options (hidden or not), that we can access and use...
The point is that someone must know first and there is no way to figure these things out other than by guessing, even if you are experienced. You hold the option key to reveal something else or, like in this case, you simultaneously click on a button and see whether something different happens. Apple doesn’t provide a comprehensive manual and even if they would do it, no one is going to read it. In practice, yes, people can find things if they look for for it in external sources. But technically, it is not an ideal solution. A hidden option is an option you don’t see unless you know where to look for.
seriously, do you think that no one knows of these mysterious options? or that, if apple provided a comprehensive manual, no one would read it? no one?? anyway, here are always users who explore everything; we have some of those people on this very forum. so, if there are questions, there will be answers, or, at least, discussion, and the hunt for answers. meanwhile, as i said, this is apple's way...so we adapt... or not.
I’m done discussing this. Again: a hidden option is an option you don’t see or know about. It might as well not exist unless you specifically look or ask for it or just encounter it by chance. The gist of it is that it is bad usability-wise and I don’t – and I stress this – blame Apple for doing it if they don’t know what else to do. But it’s bad usability nonetheless.