Is the s22 Ultra more comfortable?
For me, yes it is! I think there have been others who tried it and didn’t get on well with it though.
From what I can tell, some people who have participated on this thread simply can’t tolerate pulse width modulation at all. They can’t get on with any device that uses it.
Then there’s myself and a couple of others who also can’t use Apple’s LCD devices that don’t use pwm and possibly also don’t use temporal dithering. Those folks differ from me in that they can’t use the LCD nor can they use another company’s OLED. They’re clearly sensitive to all flickering of any kind.
I’m this weird case where I can use some devices with really obvious janky pwm. My Pixel 2 display flickers like a strobe light and I used it just fine for several years. I use that phone off and on and never had a problem with it.
But I can’t use any iOS device without neurological repercussions. I won’t necessarily get the same symptoms with my iPhone 11 or my SE2. I won’t always get headaches or eye strain, though sometimes I do.
It’s more alarming than that: I gradually lose my left eye’s vision starting at the periphery and the longer I use the phone it works its way in. It gets overtaken by a white shimmering “curtain”. It’s just the one eye so far. At least I think so. Come to think of it, since I side part my hair it may be on the other eye too but my curtain of hair on the right side keeps me from noticing it. When I stop using these devices the curtain recedes. The flicker is still there, but very faint and no longer appears like a curtain.
My eye doctor has checked my eyes very carefully and says it’s not a physical problem with the eye but likely neurological.
Honestly the shimmering curtain problem is so alarming I’d rather use an Apple OLED phone and get a conventional headache and eye discomfort than use the LCD too often anymore.
I wasn’t particularly sensitive to my Pixel 6 Pro Display until I got my iPhone 14 Pro Max and that phone sensitized me in a way that made me unable to use the Pixel 6 Pro anymore.
I have to be careful because different OLED iPhones have the potential to ruin my ability to use other OLED devices I was previously fine using. It can then become uncertain that I’ll ever be able to use them again.
My iPhone 13 Pro made me unable to use my Samsung displays for awhile. About a couple of months or so. Thank goodness that sensitization faded eventually.
I’m lucky that so far I can switch between my 14 Pro Max and my S22 Ultra. I’m now very reluctant to part with this 14 Pro Max. If it lets me use the S23 Ultra then I’m keeping the 14 Pro Max and hopefully the S23 Ultra as long as I can. (That wasn’t a typo; I plan to trade the S22 Ultra in for the S23 Ultra to get better performance).
I’m sorry this is such a long post but I wanted to make the point this is a weird, nuanced problem. Definitely there’s no one size fits all solution.
While I’ve had iPhones that made me unable to use other phones, I’ve yet to come across and Android phone that’s rendered me unable to use any other device. I don’t switch around enough on tablets or computers to speak about anything other than the effects of phone displays.
Apple is doing “something”. Whatever this “something” is, it’s something they do to their LCD and their OLED displays.