Agree on all points, but I have fairly large hands so that's not really a concern for me. Didn't have any issues with the One X+ I was using so I doubt I'll run into any issues with the One.
Consider me weird but as much as I hate the dedicated home button, I actually end up enjoying it just for the sake of waking up a device. It just feels more natural to me rather than sliding up finger up the side or top of the device. It does sort of break the flow and design of the device, but in return offers "tactile" benefits. So on that aspect its a wash for me.
Battery life will most likely sway in Samsung's favor simply due to a larger battery plus the option to swap/upgrade to higher capacity packs. But as of now that's the only thing that makes a check mark next to S4 for me.
Good points.
The battery life for the HTC One is a major concern for me. Reviews have it ranging from decent to average, and with HTC's history regarding battery life, that worries me a great deal. The HTC One X, when first reviewed, said the battery life was good too, but my experiences were horrendous when it came to lasting a day.
I suppose time will tell.
----------
It certainly looks like real metal in the first leaked video. And that brushed metal '4' in the ads hopefully does point to something. Here's to hoping! Even though the rest of the casing would be plastic, a metal frame around the sides would certainly improve the feel of the whole thing.
I hope so!