Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

zmunkz

macrumors 6502a
Nov 4, 2007
921
229
And that mark is still on him and the reason why he can be tracked by the walkers. Benjen said the wall is protected by magic and he can't cross it. If Bran cross the wall, it may cause that protection to disappear in the same way as the cave of the Three Eyed Raven.

That, or someone has their hands on the Horn of Winter and it will be moot. I suspect one way or the other we will have a "collapse of the wall" scene before the end of this series.
 

C DM

macrumors Sandy Bridge
Oct 17, 2011
51,392
19,461
During the first meeting with Bran's group at the cave of the Three Eyed Raven, the children of the forest claimed that the walkers cannot set foot in the cave because it is protected. The whole "Hold the door!" debacle was because Bran got marked and the protection of the cave is no longer in effect. And that mark is still on him and the reason why he can be tracked by the walkers. Benjen said the wall is protected by magic and he can't cross it. If Bran cross the wall, it may cause that protection to disappear in the same way as the cave of the Three Eyed Raven.
Good point. I guess I didn't quite associate the marking being connected with them being able to cross into the cave (more in the sense that they were able to track him using the mark and were able to cross into the cave because of something else like the magic no longer being powerful enough or them getting more powerful over time).
[doublepost=1467212485][/doublepost]
That, or someone has their hands on the Horn of Winter and it will be moot. I suspect one way or the other we will have a "collapse of the wall" scene before the end of this series.
Yeah, I was mostly connecting the crossing of the wall with something like that as far as how it would likely happen.
 

BernyMac

macrumors regular
May 18, 2015
201
676
USA
That, or someone has their hands on the Horn of Winter and it will be moot. I suspect one way or the other we will have a "collapse of the wall" scene before the end of this series.
I thought they already found the Horn of Winter in Season 2??? Wasn't it buried North of the wall under that inscribed stone tablet? When Green was digging around in the snow and struck stone with Sam Tarly looking on and recognizing dragon glass, there was a horn buried with the stash and Sam kept it.
 

zmunkz

macrumors 6502a
Nov 4, 2007
921
229
I thought they already found the Horn of Winter in Season 2??? Wasn't it buried North of the wall under that inscribed stone tablet? When Green was digging around in the snow and struck stone with Sam Tarly looking on and recognizing dragon glass, there was a horn buried with the stash and Sam kept it.

Really? I didn't remember that. I know Manse claimed to have it, but in the end he admitted he never did. So you are talking about the scene where Tarly first gets the dragon glass bag?

EDIT: Well holy $h*t.
 

C DM

macrumors Sandy Bridge
Oct 17, 2011
51,392
19,461
I thought they already found the Horn of Winter in Season 2??? Wasn't it buried North of the wall under that inscribed stone tablet? When Green was digging around in the snow and struck stone with Sam Tarly looking on and recognizing dragon glass, there was a horn buried with the stash and Sam kept it.

Really? I didn't remember that. I know Manse claimed to have it, but in the end he admitted he never did. So you are talking about the scene where Tarly first gets the dragon glass bag?

EDIT: Well holy $h*t.
Interesting, interesting. They don't really say anything about it or even really notice it. But then why have it there at all? So many things you kind of forget over the years as the show goes on.
 
Last edited:

giantfan1224

macrumors 6502a
Mar 9, 2012
870
1,115
Really? I didn't remember that. I know Manse claimed to have it, but in the end he admitted he never did. So you are talking about the scene where Tarly first gets the dragon glass bag?

EDIT: Well holy $h*t.
According to Game of Thrones Wiki:
The warhorn is found along with spear and arrow heads made of dragonglass, all wrapped in the black cloak of a brother of the Night's Watch. Sam and Grenn do not take notice of the warhorn, as they are more interested in the rare dragonglass weapons.

So not necessarily the Horn of Winter and we don't know what happened to it.
 

BernyMac

macrumors regular
May 18, 2015
201
676
USA
Really? I didn't remember that. I know Manse claimed to have it, but in the end he admitted he never did. So you are talking about the scene where Tarly first gets the dragon glass bag?

EDIT: Well holy $h*t.
Yes, that's the one. We were going ooh and ahh over the dragon glass and totally glossed over the horn that was bundled in there. I was wondering about that when someone mentioned "Horn of Winter" earlier.
[doublepost=1467228462][/doublepost]
According to Game of Thrones Wiki:


So not necessarily the Horn of Winter and we don't know what happened to it.

True...I was just speculating when I binge-watched the series. :p
 

fitshaced

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2011
1,742
3,632
Just having a read on the Game of Thrones wiki and am super impressed with how 'history repeated itself' by conveying the likeness between Cersei Lannister and Maegor Targaryen - and how they dealt with the Faith of the Seven.

Is George R R Martin a genius? I think he is.
 

nj-morris

macrumors 68000
Nov 30, 2014
1,897
804
UK
Surely he is the son of Lyanna Stark and Robert Baratheon? We know Lyanna is his mother but the whole 'black of hair' issue got Ned Stark killed in a way. So, he is the true heir to Roberts throne.

No, HBO confirmed that Rhaegar was his father in an infographic:
image.jpeg
And also, he's still a bastard. With that mentality Gendry would have a claim as well.
 

fitshaced

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2011
1,742
3,632
No, HBO confirmed that Rhaegar was his father in an infographic:
View attachment 638323
And also, he's still a bastard. With that mentality Gendry would have a claim as well.
Yes I saw this earlier, plus the timeline doesn't add up for him to be Roberts son. Gendry would have had a claim to the throne. In fact, according to the wiki page, Robert Baratheon was elected King because of his half blood relationship with the Targaryens once Aerys II was killed. Also, Maegor was a bastard who was then King. The wiki is seriously deep.
 

nj-morris

macrumors 68000
Nov 30, 2014
1,897
804
UK
Yes I saw this earlier, plus the timeline doesn't add up for him to be Roberts son. Gendry would have had a claim to the throne. In fact, according to the wiki page, Robert Baratheon was elected King because of his half blood relationship with the Targaryens once Aerys II was killed. Also, Maegor was a bastard who was then King. The wiki is seriously deep.

Was Maegor one of Aegon IV's bastards? I'm pretty sure he legitimised all of them. That wouldn't happen to Jon.
 

fitshaced

macrumors 68000
Jul 2, 2011
1,742
3,632
Was Maegor one of Aegon IV's bastards? I'm pretty sure he legitimised all of them. That wouldn't happen to Jon.
Actually I'm wrong about Maegor. He was Targaryen/Targaryen but a bastard through incest.

Also, other similarities to Cersei. He poisoned himself whilst sitting on the throne as he was about to face defeat. Cersei almost did the same with Tommen when Stannis attacked Kings Landing. There's obviously also a big incest connection. Maybe Cersei and Jamie are in fact Targaryen children of the mad King without Tywin's knowledge?
[doublepost=1467288838][/doublepost]Roose Bolton - pre GoT.

 

cdcastillo

macrumors 68000
Dec 22, 2007
1,714
2,672
The cesspit of civilization
... And what happened to the Lannister Uncle who was supervising the crown until Tomen came of age to rule? Or was that a Baratheon? I'd think he'd be next in line.

In the books he was killed by Varys, who returned to Westeros from Mereen only to make sure the kingdom stayed on turmoil, because Kevan was "too good at ruling". In the show, he died on the septon.


Not sure how the "mark" would have an effect like that.

Exactly what BernyMac said.
 

Huntn

macrumors Core
Original poster
May 5, 2008
23,977
27,056
The Misty Mountains
In the books he was killed by Varys, who returned to Westeros from Mereen only to make sure the kingdom stayed on turmoil, because Kevan was "too good at ruling". In the show, he died on the septon.




Exactly what BernyMac said.

Are you serious or kidding? I don't remember in the books Varys returning to Westeros, just disappeared after Joffery was killed. Maybe I'm losing my memory... :oops:
 
Last edited:

Channan

macrumors 68030
Mar 7, 2012
2,890
3,119
New Orleans
Great episode, still an outline! :D

I think we now know that Jon Snow is not Edward Stark's bastard son, but a Stark by his sister who may of had sexual relations with a Targarian, which may make Jon and Daenerys related, maybe even brother and sister. :eek:
It's confirmed.
 
Last edited:

ActionableMango

macrumors G3
Sep 21, 2010
9,612
6,909
Looking at the sails, you can see sigils for the various families that have joined behind Dany at that point. So Varys traveled back to Meereen with the Martell ships before setting sail for Westeros.

That was very informative for me, thank you. I noticed the dragon and kraken sigils, but not the others.

Looking at a map of the world, it is plausible for the Martell fleet to meet up with the fleet from Meereen, not to mention that the trip between King's Landing and Water Gardens is always depicted with ships.

But I don't know why the Tyrells would go all that way. They have a direct road to King's Landing.
 

Huntn

macrumors Core
Original poster
May 5, 2008
23,977
27,056
The Misty Mountains
I thought they already found the Horn of Winter in Season 2??? Wasn't it buried North of the wall under that inscribed stone tablet? When Green was digging around in the snow and struck stone with Sam Tarly looking on and recognizing dragon glass, there was a horn buried with the stash and Sam kept it.

I remember it being found and did they burn it?
 

AlliFlowers

macrumors 601
Jan 1, 2011
4,542
15,756
L.A. (Lower Alabama)
I was finally able to watch the season finale yesterday (have been out of town attending a conference), and thus able to read this thread. Good stuff!

I was mostly pleased with the episode. Cersei had gone off the deep end. With no children left, she has nothing to lose. And she probably knows that with what she's done she's now lost Jaime as well.

Tyrion has finally found the sister he always wished he had in Cersei. Of course, it will be a happy surprise when they discover they are actually related (since Tyrion's father is also questionable).

I did not see Tommen's suicide coming, although it made perfect sense. It was very sad.

Jon will wind up in King's Landing, but not as king. He will, most likely become the Royal Consort.
 

Khalanad75

macrumors 6502a
Jul 8, 2015
543
1,881
land of confusion
I was finally able to watch the season finale yesterday (have been out of town attending a conference), and thus able to read this thread. Good stuff!

I was mostly pleased with the episode. Cersei had gone off the deep end. With no children left, she has nothing to lose. And she probably knows that with what she's done she's now lost Jaime as well.

Tyrion has finally found the sister he always wished he had in Cersei. Of course, it will be a happy surprise when they discover they are actually related (since Tyrion's father is also questionable).

I did not see Tommen's suicide coming, although it made perfect sense. It was very sad.

Jon will wind up in King's Landing, but not as king. He will, most likely become the Royal Consort.

Wait...

Since when has Tyrion's parentage been in question?

I've read the books and watched all the shows, not once have I ever questioned him being Tywin's son.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Strider64

nj-morris

macrumors 68000
Nov 30, 2014
1,897
804
UK
Wait...

Since when has Tyrion's parentage been in question?

I've read the books and watched all the shows, not once have I ever questioned him being Tywin's son.

There's a theory that Tyrion is the son of the Mad King and Tywin's wife. I don't buy it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.