I would suggest getting a d-brand skin for the Pixel 2 XL. It covers the entire back, sides, top, and bottom. Got the matte black skin myself, it feels almost the same as naked.
Also got the Dome Glass screen protector and it is by far the best screen protector I've ever had. There's no dot matrix, it covers the entire screen, and does not peel up / bubble on sides at all. I am buying this brand for every future cell phone I get.
This combo of screen protector + skin is so awesome and eliminates all of the bulk.
My husband had one of the first batch ones and wasn’t too impressed. But he saw one at Best Buy today that looked gorgeous. Google really must have done something to improve their displays. There were two sample units that had beautiful displays to rival most other displays I’ve seen.
He loved the fluidity of stock Android and if he doesn’t get along well with the S9+ he ordered he will send it back and get a Pixel 2 XL. He has enjoyed Samsung in the past so he felt he’d give them one more chance to impress him.
I agree there are really great ones and really bad ones, the difference is striking. Rumor I read was phones manufactured December 2017 onward have improved. Mine is totally uniform in terms of brightness and color and has very minimal blue shift, just like the good ones I played with at the store. It isn't iPhone X quality (when you get a good one) but it is a stellar display. I've seen many iPhone X displays that pale in comparison to my P2 XL. QC issues aplenty with every company.
I'm also eyeing the standard S9 because I too am an addict...