I went into the Stanford Hermes store and they refused to punch an additional hole in the strap, despite the fact that an SA of theirs had said that sending it to the SF store to do so could be done. Since I bought the watch on Hermes.com (and hence could not return to the store), I called Hermes.com. They told me that since I had already paired the watch to my phone, they would not accept returns. They also told me that since punching an additional hole is up to the boutique, I could try calling every Hermes store in the country to see if they could do it!
I know for a fact that numerous members in this forum have been able to get an additional hole punched. Moreover, this YouTube video with nearly 400k views states that an "Apple specialist" allows the punching of an additional hole:
.
I told them that this was unacceptable. Either they would have to find a way to have an additional hole punched for me, or I would need to get the watch returned, as a watch that does not fit is nothing more than an expensive paperweight. They are now talking with their manager to see what can be done. This is truly some of the worst customer service I have experienced from any brand.