Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS I'm on my 16th iPhone Xs
- Thread starter PumpkingKing
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
As I've always said, there is a different breed of people on these forums. There are so many options of smartphones out there. The iPhone XS isn't the end all be all phone. After 16 iPhone XS's (sp?), at this point going with something else is probably the better solution. At the end of the day it's a phone, a tool. It's something that is mass produced on an assembly line and not going to be 100% perfect REGARDLESS of the amount of money you paid. It's meant to be used, abused, incorporated into your daily life. I just can't imagine the process for the OP when buying a new car...
I had the same issue with my X, it was a freakshow I had to replace 6 iPhone X models. I switched to the XS Max, it's alot better than the X, in other words I didn't like the X
Im very amused with the people saying that it must be OP's fault because it is statistically impossible to get so many bad phones. well, winning the lottery is also statistically impossible, but there is always someone who wins eventually. statistics only tells you the likelihood of something happening, so as long as the probability is not zero, there is always a chance, albeit a remote one. which is also why none of you have experienced it, and hence are writing OP off. without full information, im inclined to believe that the faults are real because the store actually let him exchange 16 times. unless of course OP is lying.
Unfortunately with millions of iPhones being made not all are perfect. Not that they shouldn’t be
Quality Control has improved at Apple but can still go further as we all know
If your not satisfied after 16 iPhones then stick with the one you had before this model
Quality Control has improved at Apple but can still go further as we all know
If your not satisfied after 16 iPhones then stick with the one you had before this model
I guess the baffling thing for me is, surely you know that there are people out there without issues. And surely, having admitted that you haven't found many threads about Xs issues, you realize its not some widespread problem. And surely this shouldn't change the fact that you did have issues. Just don't see what you stand to gain here outside of telling the world you have gone through 16 iPhones. It's a crappy situation, and I'm not implying it didn't happen, I just don't know that anyone here can help you, outside of possibly offering their sympathies. As I mentioned earlier, you've already dealt with more than I'd be willing to put up with.
The OP isn’t lying. Actually, probably the polar opposite being that all 16 phones did have problems of some sort. The reality is, the OP is intentionally and vehemently seeking for defects on _each and every_ iPhone. They’re actually looking defects, no matter what, that is their main goal to seek perfection, when most who use their phones, simply don’t look for defects and if there is a problem, it usually arises where the defect will affect the experience with the iPhone, which then they simply make a return.
In this specific situation, all 16 iPhones are under the scrutiny of an extreme ‘microscope’ per se, which, that’s the OP’s prerogative.
I believe the OP could have had 16 bad units in a row because there's always a chance that there was a problem in production the caused a bad batch of units to be produced. What I would have done different is that after getting a few bad ones in a row I'd have either tried another store or waited a while before getting another so as to allow time for the bad batch to be used up.
After 3 or 4 exchanges I wouldn't have given up on getting a good phone but I would definitely have given up on the current store for at least a week or two.
If OP has not given up completely then that would remain my advice at this stage. Either try other stores or if that isn't possible for you then wait a few weeks before trying again at the same store.
After 3 or 4 exchanges I wouldn't have given up on getting a good phone but I would definitely have given up on the current store for at least a week or two.
If OP has not given up completely then that would remain my advice at this stage. Either try other stores or if that isn't possible for you then wait a few weeks before trying again at the same store.
I believe Op and I understand he wants a perfect phone but 16 exchanges is to much.
Step away for a couple of months and try again later.
Maybe they will have a better batch of phones by then that meets your standards? If not try another brand just to see how their QC is in comparison but don’t expect them to be as accommodating as Apple is.
Step away for a couple of months and try again later.
Maybe they will have a better batch of phones by then that meets your standards? If not try another brand just to see how their QC is in comparison but don’t expect them to be as accommodating as Apple is.
I feel sorry for the company you buy furniture from in the future.
Well, yes, I would say I’m very OCD about things, and it definitely is not always a fun experience (although sometimes it can have benefits) but it’s not normal for me to return things like this. I have had a few iPhones, and I’ve never returned or exchanged any of them. Yes, I’ve had to get some repairs later on, but that’s it. Let me just reiterate, because it seems you and many others are reading into something else, that I am not returning these over little ‘ocd’ things. These are actual physical and potentially ‘worsening over time’ defects. Yes, variances can occur, and I accept that, as with they can occur with anything. But dust in a camera, in ANY camera, is unacceptable, but particularly unacceptable when it can’t be removed by the user of the camera. Buttons that become mushy over time (couple minutes to a few hours, over a few presses) are unacceptable because they are prone to worsening even further to the point of not working at all, and probably quite quickly to set in seeing as the timeframe for them to become mushy is almost instantaneous in a couple cases. Water seal and bezel separation is, also yes, unacceptable when it is a feature of the phone to be water resistant, and introduction of water to the phone would become detrimental to the functionality due to the gaps in the bezel and the seal, even if said introduction is accidental, the peace of mind for that type of liquid-phone interaction is gone.
[doublepost=1541761600][/doublepost]Another thing I will reiterate is, that while you are free to suggest what you will, and some run me down as you will, I am not looking for particular advice. I am seeking people who may have had any of the particular defects I have mentioned with their phones. I am not looking for others who have had to return their phones as many times as I, or criticism on how many I have returned, just so I can find a working one and one that will work for a while.
I thank all who have been helpful and genuine, and I will also say that I thought this forum would be a bit more helpful or positive, and not so critical. I have come here asking for others experiences with their phones, if they’d like to share them with me. I would not be here mentioning my experience if this wasn’t a real experience, and to be honest, I have to say that I am disappointed in some of the community here. I can understand it’s something hard to believe, but I have tried to provide a little proof for doubters and be as genuine and positive as possible.
[doublepost=1541762289][/doublepost]
Actually, you’re somewhat right and somewhat wrong. In the beginning, looking for defects was not a thing. Once the defects presented themselves in a multitude of cases (4), it was then that I was forced to look for the same defects for ones I had encountered previously, which low and behold appeared in all of them, hence my theory of a bad batch, seeing as many of you are critics and lack of support. You are wrong in that they developed over use, and unfortunately are noticeable almost immediately. The strange thing about the criticism I am receiving on this thread is that many seem to be just responding to the first thing they see—16 iPhones. They are not noticing the actual reasons for the returns. Either that, or an obviously defective phone is something people are willing to live with, when they can expect a repair down the line, or problematic photography and video—something that pertains to me the most.
Last edited:
I think it’s also equally as important for you to understand that it’s extremely rare, if almost unheard of that a customer would return 16 iPhones, and when somebody reads you returned 16 iPhones, clearly that goes beyond the ‘norm’, so you have to be able to accept criticism (In which, you sort of are ignoring) in addition to positive support from others in this thread. Some of the criticism is actually valid and some of it is frivolous.
I still stand by what I believe, and that you’re intentionally looking for defects immediately, because that’s how your mind is trained after having 16 iPhones, you simply can’t buy an iPhone and enjoy it for what it is, you have to over analyze every single aspect ratio of the iPhone just to make sure it’s ‘Perfect’, when I don’t believe your 17th iPhone will meet your expectations either, as you will likely find something wrong with that one too. As I said before, that’s your prerogative, but it just seems mentally exhausting to want to have the mind-set you do, but there has to be a point when the line is drawn, where‘Enough is enough.’ The real question is, does Apple put the stop on the returns or do you.
Last edited:
When the 7+ came out with the hissing noise, I had to have mine exchanged 3 times because the noise was so loud in videos you couldn’t hear any other noise. Once I got my 4th device, I was tired of exchanging it, so I dealt with it until the X launched and I received a perfect launch day device.
I'm on my 10th Xs Max which is coming today, I have varied supplier and colour of phone and ALL have had some form of scratch on the front or back or both. Fit and finish has been variable on all as well, some having sharp edges and some being tightly assembled. A couple had a mushy volume up button with a recessed or flush button. They were all produced in China, Zhengzhou - Foxconn. These phones cost £1100.00 and should be well made so I fully intend to keep going until I get a phone that meets my expectations and Apples marketing hype. I have had reasonably consistent screen brightness but some have had a horrible gradient from top to bottom or left to right. I pretty much always have to return multiple units of any apple products and am actually genuinely surprised and elated when I get one that is perfect (or as close to as you can reasonably expect). For people who don't have a critical eye and are happy if a device merely turns on and works good for you. I expect exemplary quality at this price point and have not had these issues with Samsung products but love the Apple Watch and need an iOS device. I also have iMac, iPad Pro etc etc. I love the design and material choices on Apple products but not Foxconn quality control or apparent lack of it.
Remember, to most the return process would be a huge hassle and not worth it. After the third unacceptable phone, most would give up.
But there are a bunch of folks that relish it.
They walk with purpose to the Apple store, they can't wait talk to a sales drone and go through every "I'm not crazy" checklist.
They walk out from the store and pump their fist and when they get home and scour over the new device to see a minuscule scratch, they pump their fist again and count down the time until they go back to the Apple store.
After the third time, I don't blame the customer, it is the store's fault (and manager) for enabling the behavior.
If you think the customer is worth keeping, on the third return, you tell them the party is over, flag them and either don't allow returns or don't sell.
But there are a bunch of folks that relish it.
They walk with purpose to the Apple store, they can't wait talk to a sales drone and go through every "I'm not crazy" checklist.
They walk out from the store and pump their fist and when they get home and scour over the new device to see a minuscule scratch, they pump their fist again and count down the time until they go back to the Apple store.
After the third time, I don't blame the customer, it is the store's fault (and manager) for enabling the behavior.
If you think the customer is worth keeping, on the third return, you tell them the party is over, flag them and either don't allow returns or don't sell.
So, are you pronouncing you wouldn’t mind a phone with dust in the camera? I use the camera on the daily, so it’s an important part of my life, it gets a lot of usage.
[doublepost=1541771519][/doublepost]
Thanks for your input, it’s heavily appreciated!
[doublepost=1541772165][/doublepost]
Not a helpful comment, and I don’t appreciate the insinuation. Who in their right mind would want to drive 40 minutes to their nearest apple store, (as I would need to do) just to tell apple they want a new phone for fun? I don’t want to be in there, I want to enjoy my phone. I want to forget about the phone and be on my way, and not have to worry about a phone that could just stop working the next day in some way. The only reason I didn’t order online is because I wanted it launch day, since I thought it would be exciting to get the product in hand. I’ve been waiting for one and a half years just to get this phone — X model, but gold color. I knew they’d release it, as they always do for their own typical money making scheme, so I laid low when the X came out, but followed the so called ‘rumors’ of the phones until it was time to order it.
I never looked for dust until I saw it. As in, I was wiping my camera off, and realized I couldn’t wipe some dust off, and found it was inside the camera enclosure. So, naturally I wanted to make sure the next one I had wouldn’t have dust in there. I feel that is a reasonable thought. I feel especially since as a new phone, I would assume there wouldn’t be any pre-existing grime upon the lens.
And I’m not looking for any validation, literally just asking to see if anyone else has noticed any of the things I mentioned on any of their phones, anywhere else in the world, since I’ve found so many with the same exact issues. This is regardless of whether the answer is no or yes, happy to have both answers. It’s unnecessary to have the negative, insinuating, and suggestive comments regarding my person in terms of personality, sanity, and the like. You seem worked up, and I feel there is no need for that, if you came into the thread with an open mind and a positive attitude, I’m sure you’d feel much better.
seems genuine looking at the first post with the receipts in?
Also, what I’m trying to make clear, is that I do not inspect new products. I never have. In fact, in terms of what you’re talking about, I’ve never even inspected any of the phones in question. Every thing that I’ve mentioned is just noticeable with phone use. As for the dust, all I had to do was turn over the phone and it’s visible. I’ve had these phones in the hands of employees, as well as family and friends, because I, myself, was worried that I was actually going insane, as some of you are suggesting. Yet anything I’ve come across has been seen and felt by everyone that has had a hand on it, without being told what the issue may be.
I don’t know how many times I’ve taken pictures that were clear as day and then I happen to look at the camera lens to see it covered in finger prints and smudge. So I don’t know how much a spec of dust is going to affect any picture quality!