I was referring to cellular connection and data download speed from the TMobile tower. My WiFi speed is 200 Mbps from Comcast. No issues there.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS Max Is the mobile reception on the xs Max even worse than iPhone X ?
- Thread starter mydogeatsbeats
- Start date
-
- Tags
- iphon xs max
- Sort by reaction score
Only problem is with cellular for me - on ATT in NH. From LTE to 3G on both iPhones Max and iPhone 8 which are both running iOS 12.
iPad Pro which has not been updated still has LTE connection, also with ATT.
Now that somebody has raised the idea, it's going to be very hard to stop.
The only way that I can imagine that iOS can fix anything is to change how iOS asks for the bands to be checked.
At home in the country, I have a low RF signal Band 2 and a high RF signal Band 12.
But Band 2 is still faster for data.
If we have a way to cause iOS to check more intelligently for what is going on, and change bands to be appropriate for what is going on, then that might help with the problem people are reporting.
If I haven't used my iPhone in a long time, I'll pick it up and see that it's camping out on a one-bar Band 2 signal.
But as soon as I dial a number, the iPhone takes ½ a second to switch to three or four bars of Band 12.
I'm no expert, just a friendly user, and I have no idea how iOS decides all this. But I can't help wondering if the minority of users experiencing dropped calls and bad RF signal capture just need to be on a different band and somehow iOS doesn't know to switch them.
Just a wild guess from an amateur. Please don't yell at me.
At home in the country, I have a low RF signal Band 2 and a high RF signal Band 12.
But Band 2 is still faster for data.
If we have a way to cause iOS to check more intelligently for what is going on, and change bands to be appropriate for what is going on, then that might help with the problem people are reporting.
If I haven't used my iPhone in a long time, I'll pick it up and see that it's camping out on a one-bar Band 2 signal.
But as soon as I dial a number, the iPhone takes ½ a second to switch to three or four bars of Band 12.
I'm no expert, just a friendly user, and I have no idea how iOS decides all this. But I can't help wondering if the minority of users experiencing dropped calls and bad RF signal capture just need to be on a different band and somehow iOS doesn't know to switch them.
Just a wild guess from an amateur. Please don't yell at me.
One more voice. XS-Max. Verizon. Linksys/Cisco wireless AP's. No cell issues, but as reported by others, my XS-Max WIFI needs to be toggled off/on 2-3 times per day. Locks up completely. Switching AP's also unfreezes it. Only takes a couple of seconds, so not that big of an issue, but it does need to get fixed. I do have an ipad air2 on IOS12 and it does not have the problem, so it looks like the phone to me. The phone does get on the 5Ghz WIFI bands OK. It's just the intermittent freeze-ups.
I think I'm just gonna return my XS without even messing with it and either get the XR or a Pixel 3. Save my money until late November when all reviews are out for all the hot devices and all the bugs are ironed out.
That article references the guy who wrote the article that I mentioned very early in this thread. I doubt Apple would issue a software update to increase power output to compensate for poor antenna gain. That might run afoul of the FCC's concern about RF radiation near the user and it wouldn't affect the receive signal strength which also depends on antenna gain. Maybe Apple has some other way of dealing with this. We'll see.
Uhhhhhhh boyeeeeeee does this stink. Been limping along with ailing phone among us waiting for this release, finally have the phone in hand and was to take it to carrier to get it activated/set up tomorrow. I'm on the US Cellular network (CDMA, pretty much shares/agrees with Verizon here, act the same) and after reading the Andrew Shepard material am NOT optimistic. The ONE TIME I put all my eggs in a new product release I end up getting roasted.
I may have no choice but to keep limping, return this (so I don't get stuck with it) and see what's up with the Xr and/or Xs fixes. If the Xs stuff IS truly hardware related I don't want to touch the Xs series with a ten foot pole, because no way will Apple take all those phones back and fix the hardware. And I NEED weak area reception. It's a MUST.
I may have no choice but to keep limping, return this (so I don't get stuck with it) and see what's up with the Xr and/or Xs fixes. If the Xs stuff IS truly hardware related I don't want to touch the Xs series with a ten foot pole, because no way will Apple take all those phones back and fix the hardware. And I NEED weak area reception. It's a MUST.
Hows are your support tickets going ? Are you sending apple your logs ?
(TLDR version: XSMax is showing a stronger signal than iPhone7 Plus Qualcomm in my own test):
In an attempt to gather some more info for everyone (mine is a phone that seems to be working fine), I just opened field test on my XS Max and my wife's Qualcomm iPhone7 Plus to see if there's any difference in received signal strength. Here are the results. It appears that the iPhone7 Plus is actually showing a weaker signal than the XS Max on the closest tower (top image is 7Plus and bottom is XS Max)..
In an attempt to gather some more info for everyone (mine is a phone that seems to be working fine), I just opened field test on my XS Max and my wife's Qualcomm iPhone7 Plus to see if there's any difference in received signal strength. Here are the results. It appears that the iPhone7 Plus is actually showing a weaker signal than the XS Max on the closest tower (top image is 7Plus and bottom is XS Max)..
Last edited:
modem in XR is worse.
[doublepost=1537893220][/doublepost]there are reports of this being fixed by restoring the phone as new. Renee Ritchie has a tweet.
this implies the cause has something to do with importing old settings and that there may be an easy settings fix that Apple can push to address this.
[doublepost=1537893277][/doublepost]this is helpful stuff!
In an attempt to gather some more info for everyone (mine is a phone that seems to be working fine), I just opened field test on my XS Max and my wife's Qualcomm iPhone7 Plus to see if there's any difference in received signal strength. Here are the results. It appears that the iPhone7 Plus is actually showing a weaker signal than the XS Max on the closest tower (top image is 7Plus and bottom is XS Max)..
The Xr has a different chassis (new design), so we don't know yet how that antenna will perform. It might be better/worse/same as the Xs. Only time will tell
Reset my network settings...
Works like a charm now.
Works like a charm now.
Now yes, but how about .......now...
I did the reset solution and it only worked for about ten minutes.
At least if it does work for a time this tells us it's a software issue and can be patched.
Not reading all the pages, but I would mention that for some carriers, bars only show the amount of voice coverage you have, NOT how good your data connection is. I don't believe any carrier will tell you if you have "Great Data" versus "So-So Data" directly on the phone as far as speeds go. They show that you either "Have LTE or 3G Data" or "No Data at all".
If the Rene Ritchie twitter fix is correct, seems Apple should be able to send out an update to fix things. I don't have the issue so can't test it.
Yeah, you're telling me. So very annoying. I'm really hoping it can be resolved with a software update, like everyone else, I guess.