Hi. I have some of the cases mentioned for my 15P and here are my thoughts and opinions on them. I also list them in ascending order of personal preference. YMMV.
Mujjo Dark Tan Closed Bottom (CB)
I had high hopes for this and bought it without hesitation after having a Mujjo for my XR. Plastic look and feeling leather, with an enormous camera frame and buttons that stick out way too much. Huge disappointment.
Ryan London Dark Brown CB
Got the open bottom (OB) when it came out, so knowing the quality of Ryan London I preordered the CB case. Didn’t like the black camera frame of the saddle brown so bought the dark brown, to start with. Colour looks more purple than brown and put me off it. A lot of conditioning did make it less purple but still not what I wanted. Leather is not as nice as the RL-OB in texture and feel. Still, a quality case though.
Ryan London Saddle Brown CB
Because of above, decided to buy the saddle brown as well. I thought a different colour might use different leather and it should be like the RL-OB saddle brown right? Sadly, nothing like it. Dry and hard with no texture and the colour is also different to the OB saddle brown. Not what I expected at all.
YMW Nappa Leather Grey CB
This is a good case. Grippy supple feel. Nice shade of grey with matching camera frame and buttons. Buttons and holes are aligned and generally well built.
YMW Horween Latigo Cognac OB
If not for the RL-OB this would be my favourite case. Top quality leather and I’ve no reason to doubt it’s not Horween. Fit and finish is identical to the RL-OB. In fact apart from the button colour and leather they are the same in every other way. Only thing which doesn’t make it my second favourite is the button colour. Silver doesn’t really match the leather for me.
YMW USA-SBF Amber Brown CB
Again another well made case. This was grippy right out of the box. They say it’s oil tanned and that might explain why it’s so grippy and supple. Lovely smell and feel. A great companion to:
Ryan London Saddle Brown OB
My favourite case. The open bottom doesn’t concern me. I had a Mujjo OB for 5 years on my XR and the iPhone 6 Apple leather case on my 6S before that. The RL-OB saddle brown has amazing leather texture and a deep rich colour. Gets even better with use and conditioning. Top notch build quality to round off a perfect case for me.
View attachment 2351032