I just don't get it. I see the value in a MacBook Air. But I don't even WANT a thinner MacBook Pro, even with all else equal. But given its a tradeoff, I'd much prefer more battery, more ports, better cooling, and more solidity/strength. Does anyone really want a thinner Pro?
The Airs are tippy and move around when you plug stuff inm. They feel... flimsy. Ugh.
As someone who uses, loves and hauls around a 16”, 32GB, 1TB, M1 Max MacBook Pro every day, I welcome and would immediately switch to a thinner, lighter MacBook Pro.
My core use cases include agent-based and discrete event simulations and software development.
The M1 Max handles these with ease and can run a 3 year simulation and accelerated time visualization of a 6 team customer service department (1 second transaction granularity, with each team member, process, task, cost, shift individually modeled, and displaying cumulative station statistics while showing every transaction from entry into the department to queueing, routing, processing and egress) in 30 minutes — quick but with sufficient time to observe the system and discuss observations with colleagues and clients before viewing overall statistics. So I personally don’t need any more power.
What I notice most on this beloved beast of a machine is the bulkiness and weight when I pack it up and sling it over my shoulder. The weight and bulkiness ironically causes flashbacks to the event that caused me to switch from PC to Mac two decades ago: A bulky, heavy PC that I have to haul around every day.
A lighter, thinner MacBook Pro is what I want most for my next Mac so I’m holding off an upgrade. If Apple doesn’t provide that I’m trading down to a lighter, thinner and less expensive MacBook Air that comes close to matching the ample and sufficient power of my M1 Max MacBook Pro. I don’t think I’m alone so I believe this represents potentially material lost upgrade revenue for Apple — and if the rumor is true, Apple recognizes this too.
The recent M4 Pro 20 core GPU SOC benchmarks finally match the Geekbench Metal score of the M1 Max 32 core GPU SOC — so the opportunity for an equivalently powerful but lower-power consumption, thinner and lighter alternative seems close. Whether that’s a MacBook Air or Pro remains to be seen.