I enjoyed my 1st gen iPhone, but I think the 2nd gen looks much sharper. I could care less about the aluminum back. Who looks at the back. Same with fingerprints. The back might show prints, but no more than the front does, and that is what everybody looks at. I hated that 2 tone back. It should of been one piece like the new one. Lastly, the new shape fits the hand so much better they say. I never dropped mine, but the metal back did make it feel real slick that you felt like you were going to drop it.