My short review
I have one - I ordered it without really waiting for reviews. I wish I had waited. In short, it is very beautiful, but is completely useless when it comes to practicality.
So the good parts:
1. The leather is very nice, smells good, and looks expensive.
2. It looks sleek and very nice
3. The adhesive is very strong, I have no worries of it ever accidentally coming off. However its still easy to remove if you want to, and I can see it coming off and on as many times as you want.
The bad:
1. What on earth to do with the front flap when taking a call? Take a look at their marketing photos - none of them are actually using the phone, because its terribly awkward.
2. The front flap doesn't stay shut, as there are no magnets on the phone/case.
3. Doing a few 'drop-tests' on a soft landing, the front cover always opens, and the phone goes splat on the screen.
4. It offers no edge protection. If it was a few mm bigger in each direction it would stop the edges of the iPhone coming in contact with anything, but its not. If you drop your phone or put it down on its edge, the metal will hit first, not the leather case (they say its 'not a case', but thats just marketing

).
5. The front flap doesn't wrap around the back very nicely, so two-thumbed typing becomes difficult.
I handed the phone around a few people in the office and they all had the same reaction - looks amazing, but a total pain when it comes to practicality. Again mainly due to what to do with the front flap when actually using the phone!
I want to love it, and i've tried to convince myself, I'm still looking at it now trying to persuade myself as its such a beautiful cover, but in the end - it fails too badly on practicality for me. Returning it won't be an option as it was an international order (to the UK), so i may stick it on ebay.
A lot of money wasted for me ($59.99 with international shipping), I guess its why I usually research things for weeks

----------
can anyone confirm for me that if you ordered one online that you received an email back confirming your order from
twlevesouthnr@gmail.com
Yes, thats who sends it. I guess they don't realise its pretty easy to have gmail send emails out as
_____@yourdomain.com!
---------
An update after a couple of days - the leather has softened and the flap now bends behind the phone a lot easier.
I'm still undecided though- its the most beautiful case, but a bit pointless
