I think I'm guilty of bashing it a bit. I admit some bitterness that IMO google fumbled this. I had aspirations of Google being probably the only company left which could rival Apple (with Samsung being knocked out until the S8 due to the Note 7 fiasco). So I think some of my criticism of the pixel is rooted in that bitterness and disappointment in Google. Oh god I know I sound like an old guy yelling at the kids to get off his lawn, but we all know how important our smartphones are to us. I do have high hopes for AI, but today there isn't much difference between google assistant and google now, at least in the reviews I've been reading and playing around with Allo. If the AI does evolve I'm not so sure that Google alienating the rest of the Android world, even its own Nexus users, by making it exclusive to themselves is the best strategy. Honestly I'm still baffled at why Google would care more about hardware profits than selling the most devices with Android on them.
I also don't see Google telling anyone they need to play by the rules. It's already been announced that Verizon will handle the OS updates for the Verizon Pixel, so they totally caved on that one like a wet paper bag.
Yeah I know Google Assistant is nothing really really special when compared to Google Now, but it's a lot better then anything anyone else can offer. So I get that you don't see it as this huge leap forward. I compare it to Siri, or S voice. It runs circles around those, and hopefully this pushes them to work to make something to complete.
In terms of me saying Google telling people to play by their rules, I don't mean carriers. They lost that battle to them a long time ago. If they had not agreed to let Verizon do the updates, I am pretty sure that would have been game over for them with Verizon. The same would have been the case with AT&T. Maybe T-Mobile or Sprint would have been more open, but you get way less reach with either of those companies.
When I said they are telling people to play by their rules, I am talking OEMs. Samsung has played by their own for a long time now. They have furthered themselves away from Android every single new phone they make with TouchWiz. Then they gave a big middle finger to Google when they made their smart watch with Tizen. Now it's Google's turn to fire back. If they would like to continue to make these decisions, well then the best features of the newest versions of Android won't be coming to Samsung. They may not even get the newest version. Samsung may not be able to afford that right now. All the US carriers are pulling the Note 7, and I just saw something that they were trying to hide that one of the replacements exploded. They think they can just sweep this under the rug and it will go away. More then ever they need Google and Android support, and I think more then ever it's time for Google to say FU.
I will go back to a scenario I used before. So we have average Joe/Jane walk into Best Buy to get a new phone on Verizon. They are looking for an Android phone.
Samsung guy @ BB- How can I help you today?
Joes/Jane- I am looking to get a new android phone on Verizon.
Samsung guy- Great, well I have this awesome Galaxy 7 that has an amazing screen.
Joe/Jane- Don't those phone explode or something?
Samsung guy- That was just our Note 7, and it was a small problem. We fixed the issue.
Joe/Jane- Ok? Where is that phone?
Samsung guy- The Verizon decided to not sell it anymore, but they have the S7 and it's a really great phone.
Joe/Jane- Ok, well I have been seeing the ads for Google assistant. I really want that, does this phone have that?
Samsung guy- Not right now, but we have S voice that is very similar as well as Google Now. Both are very similar and do the same things.
Joe/Jane- So it can do all the stuff they show on tv right?
Samsung guy- Mostly, and it does things in a different way.
Joe/Jane- It does not really sound the same. Will this phone get Google assistant?
Samsung guy- Right now we don't have it, but we hope to get it in a future update.
Joe/James- So your not sure if you will get it or not? That is the one I really want.
Samsung guy- We hope to be getting it soon, but we have this amazing screen and really great battery life. We also have the S7 Edge that the screen wraps around the edge. Take a look isn't it amazing?
Joe/Jane- It does look nice, but I really like Google assistant and I believe the phone on tv was called the Pixel. Do you guys have that?
Samsung guy- Let me find Simone in the mobile phone department to help you with that.
Honestly specs don't matter to people like this. They see the cool new feature, and that is what they want. They don't care that Google Now is pretty much the same. They want GA. The problem is, Samsung has not idea if they will even get it. People aren't going to want to hear that. I think this will be a big selling point for the Pixel. We also all know most customers aren't going to care that Verizon is handling the updates. They don't even know when their phone updates.