and we will address the chipset issue
Until we figure out the chipset issue (which MLforAll has replied about today), the only other workaround, known to disable SIP without using the recovery partition is to use the hackintosh bootloader clover, which may backfire and cause other issues of old macs with EFI32.
It's great that MLforAll has replied today, will you share what he actually said? I am still curious if his iMac screenshot was done via screen sharing or if he has working kexts for USB. Since you said "until we figure out the chipset issue" I'm guessing that means he created the screenshot via Screen Sharing. It's a simple question, and yet you have dodged it. If he was able to get USB working in one of the earlier versions where "rootless" worked, then there is hope.
If that is the case, I am the only person on the planet with a EFI32 Mac (other then the Pro models) that can run El Capitan normally and access Recovery partition and run with SIP turned off. (as shown in previous post)
That being the case, it would seem likely that you will need me to test some kexts, if and when you get them finished.
Some suggestions, since the USB works during boot it must be enabled via EFI drivers. The curious thing is it gets turned off once the OS loads. It may very well be that by removing certain USB kexts you could retain the EFI drivers and at least navigate the screen and use keyboard. As a "for instance", with our Maxwell cards the EFI can run the screen, but the OS X default drivers crash when they load. The way to use those cards in OS X default is to run with the Nvidia drivers disabled. It seems backwards, but the key to making the cards useable sometimes is to keep the OS X drivers from supplanting the EFI ones that were loaded prior to boot.
Also, I have no idea how you can test anything if SIP is stuck on. Before I had to correct you when you thought that this setting was kept on the OS install. Since it is in NVRAM, it is much more difficult to turn off. The guys who developed the latest El Cap boot.efi may very well know what property in NVRAM needs to be set, and they may know how to set it without Recovery. They also may not know, but they certainly know better then anyone outside 1 Infinite Loop.
To avoid confusion, I think that you should update the first post in this thread to reflect the following:
A. The only Macs from EFI32 era that are currently able to run El Capitan are 1,1 and 2,1 Mac Pros. (And my 2007 Mini ) There are no other Macs from this group that have working USB, and certainly no other ones with Recovery Partition. Until the USB issue gets figured out, it is likely that everyone else who tries will find no ability to move mouse, enter with keyboard, or use Bluetooth. Only workarounds found so far:
1. Screen sharing, very laggy.
2. PCMCIA card, also apparently very laggy
3. Put USB card in via Mini PCIE (working great in my 2007 Mini, but an ugly kludge until better fix found)
B. It is possible that a model that has not been tested yet may have working USB. So maybe good idea to check each one off as it gets confirmed that USB works or doesn't. This is why you need people with those other machines to try it out.
C. To encourage more to test, maybe offer a shortcut method? That list of instructions terrified me, and I do this stuff all the time. Easy route is to create the install on a supported machine, boot into an earlier OS, switch the 2 boot.efi files and try in the EFI32 machine. Your other refinements won't be important if USB doesn't work.