Thanks . I first saw the Ansel Adams version in a library book some years back and was fascinated by it also . Looks surreal , although it could be a shot of the back any one of a bunch of similar Spanish Mission churches in the area . They all seem to have same floor plan pretty much . Almost like they said to the missionary Fathers " Hey , by the way , we'd like you to build a church wherever you end up . To help you , here's a copy of the February 1602 edition of Popular Mechanics . Check out the article called 'Build your own church out of mud and straw"'.
I found the image to be a lot more of a challenge than it appears . They were re-mudding the exterior of the church at the time and had 2 cranes plus ladders , plus a bunch of orange cones around the site . Plus there's a parking lot behind the site with cars . Without sitting on someone's car , or in the traffic lane ,I couldn't get wide enough with my 24-105 . Had to use a 17-40 . At around 17 to 20 . Here's the original :
I originally was going to make the blacks darker as you suggested . Played around some in Silver Efex , but wasn't happy with the result . Either really forbidding looking or I lost the right side . So I ended up doing the B&W in Adobe Camera Raw , and then editing,cropping,cloning , and healing everything until I got something I could live with . Usually I spend maybe 5 minutes on an image , just minor adjustments for exposure , lens correction , and a bit of color tweaking to make it look good to my aging eyes . Probably spent a couple of hours exploring various permutations on this one , though .