Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How does Nintendo allow this? They are so protective of their content. Is this actually legal?
I believe Retroarch does not provide any bios files, and in some cases, they use open-source versions. The emulator itself is perfectly legal. What people do with it however is probably not.
 
So excited for this and then the thing I dreaded came to pass. The app shutdowns podcasts when you switch to it. I believe this does not happen when using Retroarch through Steamlink on the Apple tv. Bummer!!! I know, a very me problem. I also thought the game I ran looked slightly better than it did on Steam Deck Retroarch but nothing too significant. Maybe just brighter.
 
There no illegal market. People are legally allowed to make digital copies of their legitimately purchased Nintendo games that they OWN and run them in an emulator.

Nintendo having a subscription service is irrelevant to the legality of making copies of things you already own.

The competition is between the developers who have it in the AppStore and 3rd party stores.

Please, you didn't copy it from your Gameboy cartridge to your iPhone, but downloaded an illegal ROM from an illegal website.
 
Please, you didn't copy it from your Gameboy cartridge to your iPhone, but downloaded an illegal ROM from an illegal website.
is there a difference between me dumping my rom myself or downloading it?

end result is i have a rom file of my game either way
 
i actually have my pokémon red physical cartridge in my drawer lol does nintendo need to watch me dump it or can i just download the copy

you’re such a corporate stooge lmao
 
Did you download the ROM from an illegal ROM website to your iPhone? If yes, it's not your copy that you are using.

not all rom sites are illegal anyway which is another area of concern you are woefully under informed about
 
Blizzard has been banning people from their games, forcing them to buy a new copy of the game. So they can do it.

And pirated games also often come with a license key generator, so it's not your license that you are using.

i think you don’t understand the topic.

we are discussing old rom files of retro consoles like gameboys and the nes

you are talking about modern software piracy lol you are not having the same conversation

please reread the entire post and thread
 
no they can’t lol what are you talking about 😂
The recent mig dumper for the Switch, copies a license key from the game itself when you dump the game on the Switch. If you trade in or sell your official copy to someone, Nintendo can detect multiple copies of the same license key out in the wild and actually ban your console. At least that's how I understand it.
 
i think you don’t understand the topic.

we are discussing old rom files of retro consoles like gameboys and the nes

you are talking about modern software piracy lol you are not having the same conversation

please reread the entire post and thread

A game on a console or a game on a PC is the same thing. They are games or software.
 
The recent mig dumper for the Switch, copies a license key from the game itself when you dump the game on the Switch. If you trade in or sell your official copy to someone, Nintendo can detect multiple copies of the same license key out in the wild and actually ban your console. At least that's how I understand it.

well this conversation is about old retro game rom files so i’d ask we stay remotely on topic
 
Good luck once Nintendo goes after Apple and potentially even gets a list of all the people who have been pirating their Ninendo games.

You guys deserve it.

these apps have been out for decades and nintendo literally cannot do anything about it because you actually do not understand the difference between retro gaming and modern software piracy
 
hi friends I already have the games for retroarch for the  tv but how can I add them if the  tv does not have the option for files in icloud

thanks
 
hi friends I already have the games for retroarch for the  tv but how can I add them if the  tv does not have the option for files in icloud

thanks
When you first boot up Retroarch on the Apple TV it gives you 2 links to type into your webrowser (phone, pc). They both take you to the same place. From there you can download the file on the device and remotely transfer it to the downloads directory of Retroarch. I don't believe icloud is involved in anyway, perhaps it is but you don't see it during the process.
Similar to KDE Plasma for SteamDeck (for those who have a Windows PC and need to transfer files to the Deck).
 
these apps have been out for decades and nintendo literally cannot do anything about it because you actually do not understand the difference between retro gaming and modern software piracy

So you think you are free to pirate the Star Wars trilogy because they are "retro" movies and Disney can go screw themselves after having paid billions for those rights?

You think you can walk into WallMart and steal a BluRay copy of Star Wars because you bought this movie 20+ years ago and it is "retro"?

Get real.

If you want to play these "retro" games, Nintendo has a subscription service for this, so you are literally stealing money from Nintendo by pirating illegal ROMs.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Poot Windbreaker
Blizzard has been banning people from their games, forcing them to buy a new copy of the game. So they can do it.

And pirated games also often come with a license key generator, so it's not your license that you are using.
This is absolutely hilarious.

But it’s so true! Little did everyone know, back in the days when most console games were around 5-10 kilobytes in size, that those companies would put in multiple megs of ownership checking code that could be updated remotely using technologies that would not yet exist for a dozen years or so. It was just so cumbersome carrying around a 20 pound drive with each cartridge, and those huge antennae could poke your eye out!

Just because YOU pirate pc games (and obviously with a comment about key generators, you do), doesn’t mean that those of us that do things legally have to tuck our tails when you understand things so erroneously.
 
This is absolutely hilarious.

But it’s so true! Little did everyone know, back in the days when most console games were around 5-10 kilobytes in size, that those companies would put in multiple megs of ownership checking code that could be updated remotely using technologies that would not yet exist for a dozen years or so. It was just so cumbersome carrying around a 20 pound drive with each cartridge, and those huge antennae could poke your eye out!

Just because YOU pirate pc games (and obviously with a comment about key generators, you do), doesn’t mean that those of us that do things legally have to tuck our tails when you understand things so erroneously.

I don't, you cannot pirate on a Xbox Series X. I own all my games legally.
 
Sony and Nintendo are offering players retro streaming services. People will want to pirate. Some people get a buzz from downloading stuff for free. Then brag about freedom and human rights stuff. Then the buzz wears off and they start playing the new Call of Duty or Helldivers.



They got the market share back. The iPod doesn’t exist anymore and the Walkman line still does 😛

It’s amazing how confident people sound when they are badly informed.
A quick scan of your posting history reveals that you consider yourself a millennial; I suppose you're a little too young to remember Steve Jobs introducing the original iPhone as three devices in one - one of those, of course, being an iPod. 😉 Apple has sold 2.3 billion iPhones since its launch in 2007. To date, Sony has sold about 400 million Walkmans (tape players, MD players, and digital media players), according to Wikipedia. So I suppose it's fair to say that more people listen to music on iPods and iPhones than Walkmans. 🤣

You're probably too young to remember, but Sony did not allow playback of MP3s on its first few generations of "Network Walkmans." Instead, it forced users to perform lossy conversions to ATRAC3 format, to facilitate DRM management. Having dealt with that fiasco, and having lived in Japan for more than twenty years, I'd venture a guess that I'm a little more familiar with Japanese corporate governance than you. The chances of Sony or Nintendo allowing ROM downloads and officially-sanctioned emulators on other companies' app stores (like Apple's) is slim to none (although I'd LOVE to be proven wrong!!!) ... Since management positions in the vast majority of Japanese companies (including Sony and Nintendo) are filled based on tenure (rather than merit) and since Japanese society as a whole values consensus and harmony (rather than individuality and outside-the-box thinking), it's just not likely that either company will do the reasonable thing here. Anyway, I'll leave you to it. 👍🏻
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.