Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Should the iPad become a Mac Replacement?

  • Yes - the iPad should become a general Mac replacement

    Votes: 38 12.6%
  • Yes - the iPad should become a Mac laptop replacement

    Votes: 53 17.5%
  • No - the iPad should stick to the original design intent

    Votes: 171 56.6%
  • I don’t have a preference for what the iPad evolves into

    Votes: 40 13.2%

  • Total voters
    302

Unregistered 4U

macrumors G4
Jul 22, 2002
10,617
8,641
In addition, I suspect that Apple is working on some Mac-specific silicon to propel Mac desktops into ultra-high performance workstation / super computer territory. If/when this happens I hope/expect some of it to trickle down to the iPad Pro to unlock some use cases that are currently not feasible.
Understanding that it remains to be seen, I really don’t think they’re putting much more effort into desktops. Everything for desktops now, and in the future, is/will be some permutation of what’s available for mobile (which, by extension, is some modification of iPhone/iPad designed cores). Creating something unique for less than 100,000 units a year… they’d have to charge more than most folks that WANT desktops would likely be willing to pay (especially considering that many folks that WANT desktops don’t even want to pay today’s prices!)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dgdosen

AppZ.Zero

macrumors member
Nov 29, 2021
99
244
An iPad Pro with Mac OS would be favourite device. Since Apple doesnt produce anything like that and is artificaly choking the iPad, they wont get money for Macbooks or ipads from me.
 

MallardDuck

macrumors 68000
Jul 21, 2014
1,680
3,225
So, given that background, do you think the iPad should become a Mac replacement or stay true to its original design intent?

Hardware-wise they'd have to add full accessory and peripheral support including multi-monitor capability. Then they'd have to port MacOS to it so we have a real file system and full application support, as well as the ability to run non-app store apps.

At that point, it's a Mac, so why bother? It'd actually be easier to add touchscreen capabilities to the Mac, than turn a tablet into a computer.
 

monstermash

macrumors 6502a
Apr 21, 2020
974
1,062
Any way to make my lawnchair a replacement for my livingroom
recliner sofa?

Oh, wait...you mean they're different things for different purposes? Ooooooooh, I get it. Thanks!!
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: thmsnt and heretiq

RinkDinkus

macrumors member
Mar 30, 2022
75
88
Instagram: maxzeuner
To be honest, I would have been in the camp of “The iPad needs to not replace the Mac” but to be honest I really don’t know (or care) anymore.

Most general day to day computing can be done on our phones even. I was originally going to sell my MacBook and just have my 2020 iPad and my XS. Then I decided to meet in the middle and get a 14 Plus and sell my iPad. Big enough screen that it could do everything my iPad could do plus the basics of my MacBook.

“BUT WHAT ABOUT (specific workflow app)” idk then use it on what you’re used to. Use the right tool for the right job. I honestly think I’m just going to keep my MacBook for audio related tools since all the iOS/iPadOS audio production software is still iffy.
 
  • Love
Reactions: singleshard

currocj

macrumors 6502a
Jul 8, 2008
655
915
Earth
I continue to be puzzled by this idea that there is a single all-encompassing universal use-case for Macs.

The iPad is already a Mac replacement for some/many people. That has been true since the first day of the first gen. For others, the iPhone is a Mac replacement.

The added functionality and features to the iPad since that first gen have done nothing to impede the use of the iPad for those first gen use cases.
The day my mom got her ipad 1st gen, she never needed a computer. She is still barely able to comprehend and master it.
 

iPadified

macrumors 68020
Apr 25, 2017
2,014
2,257
Wasn't the tag line "Perhaps you next computer is not a computer" or similar. I think that very precisely describes the iPad and the distinction to a traditional computer. "Maybe iPadOS can replace MacOS for you" or "Maybe a modular computing device can replace the clamshell computer for you" are more correct statements but hardly have the same ring to it.
 

gpat

macrumors 68000
Mar 1, 2011
1,936
5,346
Italy
Wasn't the tag line "Perhaps you next computer is not a computer" or similar. I think that very precisely describes the iPad and the distinction to a traditional computer. "Maybe iPadOS can replace MacOS for you" or "Maybe a modular computing device can replace the clamshell computer for you" are more correct statements but hardly have the same ring to it.

That tagline was obviously meant to mess with people's minds while Apple had no clear idea about what to do with the product line itself.
As a long-time Mac user, I see the only utility of the iPad in its Pencil apps (note-taking, artistic, whatever).
I think it's pretty obvious that the iPad would've been dead as a platform if Cook didn't decide to implement the Pencil on it, also the best implementation on the market by far.
Jobs was raving about the "post-PC era" and PCs (and Macs) didn't go anywhere 12 years later.
Sure, there are people that can't be bothered to learn about the ins and outs of a traditional computer, but you could never sustain iPad sales with them alone.
They're good with the $300 base model anyway and most of the time they just rely on their smartphone only and see a second device as an hassle.
 

singleshard

macrumors newbie
Nov 29, 2018
11
9
South Korea
I love my M1 iPad Pro. I use it everyday for work.

Today, I thought iPad OS was about to crash after I doodled a forest with hundreds of leaves in Notability during a long meeting. The iPad got really, really hot. Then I wanted to move my doodle down a little to make room for a sunset ... the lag on this was horrendous. It reminded me of moving an application window in Windows 95 where the dragged window would disappear; it was hard to see how far you moved it, then the window would draw itself back onto the screen in fat, janky lines while you unwrapped a piece of gum and put it in your mouth.

The M1 should not have choked like this. Notability is most likely the problem, but iPad OS also shares blame. 8GB should be more than enough to display the screen, have Notability and Chat open, and draw a few hundred vector shapes with a 4 color palette ... alas, this was too much for such a "powerful" device. That is sad and this is why Macs still exist.

Later, I repositioned the forest on an M1 Mac (Studio) in the same version of Notability (universal app). There was a lag rendering the freehand lasso line around the forest just like on the iPad, but moving the forest was buttery-smooth. So not really a Notability problem.

This is what the limitations of an OS looks like. iPad OS is just sh*t.

Apple can make the hardware powerful, but if iPad OS is not able to leverage that hardware in a meaningful way, then this is as far as the iPad will go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eicca

Unregistered 4U

macrumors G4
Jul 22, 2002
10,617
8,641
Later, I repositioned the forest on an M1 Mac (Studio) in the same version of Notability (universal app). There was a lag rendering the freehand lasso line around the forest just like on the iPad, but moving the forest was buttery-smooth. So not really a Notability problem.

This is what the limitations of an OS looks like. iPad OS is just sh*t.
No, it’s what an app not being used for its intended purpose looks like. :) If the devs thought that was a use case that ranked high among their users, it’d be designed to cover that on the iPad. Do the same thing in, say, Vectornator, and you can have thousands of vector shapes + layers and effects, no problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heretiq

teh_hunterer

macrumors 65816
Jul 1, 2021
1,231
1,673
I love my M1 iPad Pro. I use it everyday for work.

Today, I thought iPad OS was about to crash after I doodled a forest with hundreds of leaves in Notability during a long meeting. The iPad got really, really hot. Then I wanted to move my doodle down a little to make room for a sunset ... the lag on this was horrendous. It reminded me of moving an application window in Windows 95 where the dragged window would disappear; it was hard to see how far you moved it, then the window would draw itself back onto the screen in fat, janky lines while you unwrapped a piece of gum and put it in your mouth.

The M1 should not have choked like this. Notability is most likely the problem, but iPad OS also shares blame. 8GB should be more than enough to display the screen, have Notability and Chat open, and draw a few hundred vector shapes with a 4 color palette ... alas, this was too much for such a "powerful" device. That is sad and this is why Macs still exist.

Later, I repositioned the forest on an M1 Mac (Studio) in the same version of Notability (universal app). There was a lag rendering the freehand lasso line around the forest just like on the iPad, but moving the forest was buttery-smooth. So not really a Notability problem.

This is what the limitations of an OS looks like. iPad OS is just sh*t.

Apple can make the hardware powerful, but if iPad OS is not able to leverage that hardware in a meaningful way, then this is as far as the iPad will go.

I'm not an iPad evangelist, but claiming this is the iPad's fault is a bit of a stretch. It could be purely that Notability haven't put as much effort into their iPad app.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heretiq

JamesMay82

macrumors 65816
Oct 12, 2009
1,479
1,207
Just watched Lewis capaldi doc on Netflix and was surprised he uses a iPad for all his initial song writing and records himself on the iPad voice app.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heretiq

heretiq

Contributor
Original poster
Jan 31, 2014
1,036
1,710
Denver, CO
Just watched Lewis capaldi doc on Netflix and was surprised he uses a iPad for all his initial song writing and records himself on the iPad voice app.
That’s so cool to know @entropyfl ; but I’m not surprised that an iPad could be used that way. I’m watching the documentary now. What an extraordinary human being. Thanks for posting this!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesMay82

heretiq

Contributor
Original poster
Jan 31, 2014
1,036
1,710
Denver, CO
Enjoy! It’s refreshing to see someone with his fame stay so down to earth!
Yes it is. He is the real deal. Talented. Smart. Humble.
IMG_3188.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JamesMay82

chrono1081

macrumors G3
Jan 26, 2008
8,744
5,246
Isla Nublar
Some can use it as their sole device and others can’t. Why do so many here focus so much trying to force a device in a one size fits all compartment?

This.

I have many friends who can use an iPad as their computer just fine, great for them but I can't. I do too much that would just be cumbersome on an iPad.

But I also have an iPad and I love it for what I need to use it for, it's just not the same as what I use my laptop for.
 

Choco Taco

Suspended
Nov 23, 2022
615
1,065
Until it can run macOS, or they drastically improve the way iPadOS functions, it will never be a replacement for me.
 

eicca

Suspended
Oct 23, 2014
1,773
3,605
Here’s another point. What are they thinking, selling a $300 keyboard+trackpad setup? By the time you buy that and the iPad itself, you’re in the hole WAAAAAY past a MacBook.

And yet they won’t put a touchscreen on the MacBook.

Why? Other than the money. There’s no reason for this other than the money.
 

sparksd

macrumors G4
Jun 7, 2015
10,023
34,492
Seattle WA
Here’s another point. What are they thinking, selling a $300 keyboard+trackpad setup? By the time you buy that and the iPad itself, you’re in the hole WAAAAAY past a MacBook.

And yet they won’t put a touchscreen on the MacBook.

Why? Other than the money. There’s no reason for this other than the money.

Of course they'd do it for the money - they're a for-profit business.
 
  • Like
Reactions: monstermash
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.