I'm using the Grip Candy (black/ice - non-transperant back) right now, and I think it is the closest to the perfect case that I will ever find. Even though I think that, something has me always on the lookout for a better case. I was looking at the Tones before, and since you have both, I wanted to get your opinion on the two.
Also, I'm looking for the Grip Candy Sheer that has the transparent black back and the black sides. I don't know the name of the color combo, but I think they sell it at Verizon. Since it's the one you pictured, do you have this one? And do you have the black iPhone? I was wondering if you could see anything through the back.