Can't believe I'm saying this: I love my CVT.
To set this up -- I'd been driving manuals ever since buying my first car, a Honda Civic, in 1990. My wife and I got two new Hondas last spring, a CR-V and a Civic hatchback. Both have CVTs; the CR-V's forward "gears" are Drive, Sport, and Low, while the Civic, in its Sport Touring trim, has Drive and Sport plus paddle shifters.
For the past two weeks, we've been visiting our parents back home while Mom recovers from knee surgery. I've been driving their Chevy HHR and Subaru Forester, both with traditional slushbox automatics (at least the Forester has a "sport" mode with which you can manually select gears).
I've forgotten how annoying it is to have a transmission hunt for gears when I don't want it to shift at all. Say I'm going downhill and don't need to accelerate -- the Subaru upshifts to make me go faster even though I'm off the throttle. The CVTs in our Hondas can hold a gear, or even "downshift" (easy to do on demand with the Civic's paddles), to use engine braking to regulate speed.
The programming on the Subie's transmission sucks, too. It'll let the revs hang for a full second after lifting off the throttle. If I want to accelerate, sometimes it'll respond, sometimes it won't. At part throttle, it'll upshift with a jerk.
Almost NONE of these annoyances happen with our new CVTs. Although I'm still getting used to accelerating while hearing the engine revs stay the same, it makes technical sense to use the engine's optimal RPM range for power (whether you want more power or less) and adjust the transmission continuously to match road speed. Traditional "stepped gearing" automatics, whether we realized it or not, were always a workaround to accommodate the combustion engine's unequal power curve. With a CVT, when you want max power, the ECU can park the engine right at its power peak, and let the transmission handle the acceleration in road speed. With a traditional automatic, the engine still has to transition into and out of its powerband.
I'd still rather own a manual transmission again. But for now, I really miss my CVT.
[/blaspheme]