I would take consumer reports with a huge pinch of salt. It's hilarious the kind of reliability cars can get marked down for, even if people have issues with the infotainment system etc. In the EV sector we've had some deep dives regarding the Polestar 2 on that as it weirdly scored really bad in the USA compared to the rest of the world, and it was just weird in their methodology how very small samples of what are basically whinges, and general technology limitations can drag a score down badly. In my opinion, they are outdated and should stick to reviewing toasters and the likes.
Yes, for pure continuous off-roading, but realistically, who does that unless you are a farmer. The Land Rover Defender would be a great car, but again it is much more utilitarian, even the current one. Reliability of the Defender vs the Range Rover? Nah, not buying it. It's like anything maintain it and treat it well and it treats you well. Core mechanical systems are absolutely solid and get's you home no problem. Besides they are just a car, just with a lot of comfort features added to it. The off-road systems are some of the best in the world.