So I went to the Apple Store and got my first hands-on experience with the new Music app in iOS 10. I didn't.... hate it... as much as I thought I would.
The Good:
- The Library home screen (with it's obnoxiously large header font and oversized Recently Added tiles at the bottom) is suprisingly customizable. You can add or remove buttons like Playlist, Artists, Genre, Videos, etc. You can even remove Downloaded Music button if it's redundant to your existing Apple Music library. You can even reorder the list in which the buttons appear - by default it reads Playlist, Artist, Albums, Songs - but you can reorder it to read Artist, Songs, Playlist, or even add in Genre, Compilations, etc. It's basically a homescreen version of what the bottom tile bar on the classic iOS 6 Music app used to be. Forgive me for being so impressed with such a small detail, but Apple has taken away user control SO much in recent years that this level of customization caught me off guard.
- That flickering text bug from iOS 9 is finally gone. God I hated that.
- Like most of iOS 10, it doesn't lag *as much* as 9 does. It's not 8.4.1 buttery smooth, but maybe it will be on the iPhone 7. I don't know. I tested an iPhone 6 and 6S at the store, and both dropped frames slightly when scrolling the Artist list (like usual with iOS 9).
The Bad:
- Large font. It's been beaten to death. We know, it sucks.
- The Recently Added tiles on the homescreen are too big. I much preferred the 8.4.1 - 9.3 style with 3 albums across the top, no more no less.
- Reliance on Artist stock photos instead of defaulting to an album cover when no artist image is available is lame.
- My BIGGEST gripe: When you select an artist, instead of a list of albums you get a GRID of album covers in no particular order. Who the hell thought this was an efficient way to sort and search for music? This is one thing that stops me from upgrading. It's that annoying to me. I'm still on 9.0.1, which for all of it's lag or bugs, was the last time we were able to list albums beneath each Artist like we did on iOS 6. It's a little touch that really makes all the difference for someone that uses the Music app as much as I do.
In the end, the iOS 10 Music app wasn't as much of a disaster as I expected. But it's also not worth upgrading if you're a nitpicky Music user like myself. I'll be curious to see if some design changes occur with 10.1 or 10.2 in the future to fix some of these issues.