Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
However, for the general consumer populous it's just an unnecessary gadget.

I don't think anyone is arguing its a necessity. There is nothing wrong with wanting or owning an unnecessary gadget.

Whether it is something that gives people a bit of fun, enjoyment or whatever is completely personal. I really don't think anyone could give two hoots over whether they have your approval to find a device enjoyable to use.
 
I don't think anyone is arguing its a necessity. There is nothing wrong with wanting or owning an unnecessary gadget.

Whether it is something that gives people a bit of fun, enjoyment or whatever is completely personal. I really don't think anyone could give two hoots over whether they have your approval to find a device enjoyable to use.

I don't expect people to look for my approval. I'm just saying people already have several devices that all do the same thing, the iPad is no exception.
 
Some of you guys are weak, I'm sorry ;)

The first thing I noticed about the iPad was "Wow this feels great".. The weight combined with the sturdy built really lets you know that you're dealing with a quality product, as well as it just feels great to actually be able to feel it. My biggest problem with the iPhones is that they're simply too light. I'd really prefer a sturdy built 200g iPhone over the current 135g.
 
Some of you guys are weak, I'm sorry ;)

The first thing I noticed about the iPad was "Wow this feels great".. The weight combined with the sturdy built really lets you know that you're dealing with a quality product, as well as it just feels great to actually be able to feel it. My biggest problem with the iPhones is that they're simply too light. I'd really prefer a sturdy built 200g iPhone over the current 135g.

Agreed completely, in fact I think slightly more weight due to its "bevelled" back so it would not rock on its back if on a bench etc. Once using the beast the iPad is, which has an amazing display you dont even want to go back to using an iphone.
 
OP, sorry to hear that you're not happy with the iPad. You look/speak/post like a reasonable person, so my apologies for unkind posts that have been posted. for what it is worth, I think you have named some good reasons to bring back your iPad. And yes, you could have avoided it by reading/exploring a bit more in advance, but who am I to tell you (when I've spend several iPads worth of gadgets-junk that didn't work and I never got my money back for those things)?

For me, I love reading on it. The empty Spanish catalog is indeed a bit pity, but I've downloaded around 400 books in Dutch that where in epub/pdf format and added them to my iPad. That makes for quite a nice library.

Holding the ipad in front of you is tiresome, no matter how much you work out.But the same goes for a Kindle or anything else. If you need to hold it in front of you with stretched armes, it will get heavy sooner or later. I understand your reason, but even a 300gr pocket book will get heavy if you don't support it.
But the weight on the iPad is not spend useless IMHO: from all the pictures I've seen so far on Kindles, e-readers, slates etc. etc. all of them are so fragile looking, cheap plastic and the one's I've holded easily flexed under normal forces. I haul the iPad around in my bag, every day, inside an Apple case (I really need to find a better case that is just as slim, more handy and much, much more durable). But I'm never concerned it will not survive. Is that worth the extra weight? for me it is, for you it might be different.

I can reach mobile me via the goodreader and it works. Most of the time, sort of, because I just want to look up a doc/pdf. If I want to edit it, I need to email it, which isn't a very nice solution, but I'm counting on Apple to come up with a nice MobileMe.app that works better and more directly.

I was a bit annoyed about the closed iTunes system too. but on the other hand, all the apps that get in are reviewed and have at least a reasonable working. Some of them might get unstable, but if you look at the enormous amount of apps and the relative few cases of bad apps, I think Apple is doing a wonderful job. You just can't let every desinger/software engineer roam free in your ipad. It will be just like the HTC phone of my coworker, who has installed dozens of apps on it, only to become so instable and untrustworthy that he has formated the whole thing and now only has the factory delevered programms on it. So it is a bit annoying, but in the end I'm more happy with a good working closed system than the unstable but open HTC my co-worker has. YMMV, as they say.

But on the other hand, look at the bright side: I read that you've got an ibook? With the money you got back from the iPad, perhaps you could save some more and buy a superb macbook pro 13" and have a very nice 9hour (IRRC) battery life?! Then you don't have the iTunes Cyclops-big-brother-eye-closed-system as one poster named it and still make a considerable leap forwarde in speed, weight, display quality, and battery life when compared to the ibook.
 
Sounds like you don't need the power of a Macbook Pro (so I'm not sure why you would buy one). Seems you didn't research with the Macbook was really all about.

Swing and a miss. I will assume you were trying to be sarcastic. You failed but at least you attempted. The very first time I can load Aperture or MTR, or Adobe Photo Shop on my iPad I may consider dumping the MBP, but for now it performs the duties that the iPad (a non-computer) cannot perform. So it looks like I did do my homework.

I, for one, am not someone who buys a device and deals with its short comings, because I think it's a nifty device. I buy what I need when its needed. I would never buy a phone, MP3 player, television, computer, etc that didn't fit my needs (even at a 85%-90% level) just because it's flashy (pun not originally intended) and from Apple.

So must be that super-duper person that uses 100% of their computers capabilities. When was the last time you used: Stickies, Font Book, or Chess?

I never suggested that no one should buy an iPad, because it doesn't fit my needs. No need to get offended. I'm just saying that I don't see a use for it for me, or most other people who already own a computer. I think it's a great computer for a teenager (sort of a tween leapfrog toy) or someone very old and uncomfortable with technology. However, for the general consumer populous it's just an unnecessary gadget.

Hint: The iPad is not a computer. While it can perform computational duties it does not run a full blown computer OS. Guess you missed the briefing. I guess you also missed the briefing that the iPad is aimed at the consumer market that you just dismissed.

Troll alert.
 
"Unhappy Owner - I'm sorry" - What is this, some kind of help group?
 
Swing and a miss. I will assume you were trying to be sarcastic. You failed but at least you attempted.



So must be that super-duper person that uses 100% of their computers capabilities. When was the last time you used: Stickies, Font Book, or Chess?



Hint: The iPad is not a computer. While it can perform computational duties it does not run a full blown computer OS. Guess you missed the briefing. I guess you also missed the briefing that the iPad is aimed at the consumer market that you just dismissed.

And here we have the long and the short of it. Its not a computer. Stop trying to make it one. If anything its more akin to a PMP with extra functionality. Look at those Archos media tablets, App Store and accelerometer aside, they offer very much the same set of features (granted, they are nowhere near as polished or as intuitive as the iPad, and yes, i'm an Archos owner).
 
And here we have the long and the short of it. Its not a computer. Stop trying to make it one. If anything its more akin to a PMP with extra functionality. Look at those Archos media tablets, App Store and accelerometer aside, they offer very much the same set of features (granted, they are nowhere near as polished or as intuitive as the iPad, and yes, i'm an Archos owner).

Was this directed at me?
 
Yes. I ride the train/subway 40-45 minutes each way for work everyday and usually stand as i believe I am in better shape than most people riding with me. I like to read while I ride. Kindle is simplicity itself to hold one handed and read, changing pages with my thumb. The iPad is pretty much impossible to use the same way. If you really honestly can say that you find it comfortable to hold the iPad in one hand, reading an iBook, and changing pages, with one hand, then you have the strength of Hercules


Slight exaggeration? I bought my 10 year old son a iPad and he manages fairly well with 1 hand.
 
I know this thread is beat to death, and I haven't read it all... but if those are your reasons for not liking the iPad... well, it's pretty lame. Just to take one of these - when is the last time you read a book, standing with the book held at arms length? Nobody does that. Whatever you read is supported on some "base"... your lap, a desk, a pillow. Also the iPad weighs less than some books. When is the last time you heard of someone returning a book because it weighed too much? It's nuts.

The iPad isn't for everyone, obviously. And I've read legitimate reasons for returning one. But these three reasons are totally lame.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.