Dear Maxthackray, just wanted to add that the Corsair MP510 is also working flawless. Not much heat generation, bottom of MBP 2013 stays handwarm at most scenarios.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Upgrading 2013-2015 Macbook Pro SSD to M.2 NVMe
- Thread starter maxthackray
- WikiPost WikiPost
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
- Status
Dear Maxthackray, just wanted to add that the Corsair MP510 is also working flawless. Not much heat generation, bottom of MBP 2013 stays handwarm at most scenarios.
Oh, sorry, but always reading the last posts I had not seen the first page XD
The power consumption may vary depending on the components you have installed. Hibernate mode 0 is considered classic desktop hibernation where the PC is completely shut off except for the RAM where the contents are stored. Before hibernation there is a mode called sleep or standby however you want to call it, this is not the same as hibernate mode 0 because multiple components are in a low powered state, including the NVME drive. If you don't set standby to mode 0 when you close the lid of your mac it will go to sleep, then after standbydelayhigh/low (depends on battery level) minutes it will go into hibernate mode 0. Disabling standby bypasses sleep when lid is closed and goes directly to hibernate mode 0.
This behavior is independent of SSD/NVME, you wont notice it with the stock SSD because its configured differently by apple to leverage low power usage in sleep state. With NVME MacOS doesn't have the ability to leverage low power states during sleep so when you close the lid of the mac, the NVME drive is still using more power than the regular SSD before it transitions into hibernate mode 0 where the drive is off which is why people experience higher battery drain when they stop using their mac. This is why it is recommended to disable standby.
The point here is that sleep and hibernate mode 0 are not the same. The effect of these settings is more observable if you have a mac with a high powered drive like a samsung 970 rather than a drive that has a power consumption closer to that of the original Apple SSD.
thank you guys for all experience here, the only difficult left is to get working hibernation on 2014 mbp, somehow to update bootrom
successfully replace stock 128 with adata sx8200 pro only missing sleep, coz it is necessary to put all modes to zero
p.s. cpu is getting a lot a lot hotter (checking thru TG Pro), its especially problem with adata ssd or its because of new interface for ssd?
coz i replace thermo grease and clean all dust etc and this difference very noticeably between stock
p.s. can somebody link to the step by step guide how to modify a bootrom, coz without hibernation its looks annoying, so it is good idea to fix it
successfully replace stock 128 with adata sx8200 pro only missing sleep, coz it is necessary to put all modes to zero
p.s. cpu is getting a lot a lot hotter (checking thru TG Pro), its especially problem with adata ssd or its because of new interface for ssd?
coz i replace thermo grease and clean all dust etc and this difference very noticeably between stock
p.s. can somebody link to the step by step guide how to modify a bootrom, coz without hibernation its looks annoying, so it is good idea to fix it
Last edited:
Just got my first order from sintech delivered, external enclosure for mac SSD, and the black adaptater (I've ordered the green one too).
Now I just need to get my nvme SSD (SANDISK extreme pro, same as Black from WD), and test the mojave install.
Now I just need to get my nvme SSD (SANDISK extreme pro, same as Black from WD), and test the mojave install.
Hi Ackerschlepper, thanks for your information. I would like to buy a Corsair MP510 for my MBP 2015 early 13. Just to be sure, could you let me know what the exact model of the M2 converter you are using for the ssd? Did you buy it from Amazon US? A link would be great.
and would you therefore be so kind to let all of us know, what you've exactly done to solve your installation problem plz?!
what do you mean by that?
[doublepost=1553205942][/doublepost]
hmm, and which 1tb one doesn't? what's the no.1 recommendation?
Last edited:
You can set a low standbydelay in seconds and test it yourself
I am convinced that when on battery power the standby hibernates the Mac automatically after reaching sleep for ”standbydelay” (low or high depending on the battery’s current charge) seconds. This is regardless of ”hibernatemode”. On the contrary, when plugged in, ”autopoweroff” is what kicks in for a laptop after sleeping for the default 8h.
Thanks for the info. I see what you mean with standby 0 going straight to the hibernate mode by testing with hibernate 25 (I see the progress bars when I wake as the memory is written back to the RAM from the drive)
One thing I’ve noticed is that with standby enabled (standby 1) the Mac doesn’t go into the hibernate mode after the standbydelay time. For example I can tell it doesn’t go into hibernate 25 because it wakes up quicker and no progress bars.
Apple support articles note that “standby mode” goes into a lower power mode and saves the memory to the ssd but doesn’t power the computer completely off like “safe sleep” when you see the progress bars (hibernate 25).
It seems that Safe Sleep occurs only after the “poweroffdelay” or if the Mac completely loses charge during “standby” (or if you disable standby and use hibernate mode 25 it will occur immediate”
I don’t have a NVME in my MBP installed yet. If I understand correctly the issue isn’t just waking up from “safe sleep” but waking from “standby”?
[doublepost=1553239418][/doublepost]
Classic “hibernation” behavior is actually hibernate 25: computer saves memory from the RAM to the drive and the computer completely powers off. When it resumes it is slower because it has to write the contents of the memory back to the RAM.
Classic “sleep” is going into a lower power state while keeping the contents of memory in RAM and is quick to resume.
“Standby” on a Mac seems to be a form of hibernate on a Mac that writes the memory to the disk and goes into a even lower power state but doesn’t power off like true hibernate and quicker to resume.
>this< , so I think both cos the issue is actually with resuming from the SSD, thus in cases when the RAM is powered off ( 1-> when hibernating, 2-> when standbydelay is reached on battery power, 3-> when autopoweroff delay is reached when plugged in)
Regarding the standby sleep being different than hibernation, it is possible, or there may be a difference between iMac and MacBook. Another possibility is that there may have also been processes running or devices inserted preventing your Mac from writing the hibernation image and deep sleeping. You have to refer to the system logs to be certain. However, from what is posted on Apple Support webpages, I am inclined to think that if there is a standby sleep, it only applies when a MacBook is on battery power.
So to summarize, these are the states in which a Mac enters:
-monitor off (everything else powered on)
-sleep = standing by (ram on, everything else in a low-power state or off)... can maintain this up to 30 days on battery power (one thing to note here is that older MacBooks with a 3rd party SSD drive may not be able to shut the SSD down during normal sleep due to lack of firmware support)
-deep sleep = hibernate (possibly = standby sleep) (everything powered off, bluetooth in a low-power state to be able to wake)
-shut down (everything powered off)
If standby sleep is to differ from hibernate, we have to point out the differences (which may have something to do with the power source, perhaps some parts in the one case remain powered, and are off in the other case). I, however, do not think that we can trust some journalist articles popping out here and there from unreliable sources.
I think I have found a bug when using a samsung 970 pro 1Tb on a Macboook Pro from 15 mid 2015, mac os Mojave 10.14.3, with sintech adapter revision B (big green adapter).
In AmorphousDiskMark, if I run the second benchmark (4kib block QD=32) the system goes slow and laggy up to the point I can barely go to the apple and click reboot. Once rebooted everything works fine again. However, with a Toshiba xg4 this thing does not happen. I'll try later with the original ssd to see what happens.
In AmorphousDiskMark, if I run the second benchmark (4kib block QD=32) the system goes slow and laggy up to the point I can barely go to the apple and click reboot. Once rebooted everything works fine again. However, with a Toshiba xg4 this thing does not happen. I'll try later with the original ssd to see what happens.
Hey guys:
I decided to do a slight mod on my NVMe drive yesterday. I bought a thermal pad to help keep the SSD cool. It isn't necessary, but Apple certainly didn't design the cooling system with NVMe drives in mind. I'm now getting idle temps of 28 degrees vs 33 degrees Celsius. Not a huge mod but definitely could be useful for those running Samsung NVMes.
Stan
I decided to do a slight mod on my NVMe drive yesterday. I bought a thermal pad to help keep the SSD cool. It isn't necessary, but Apple certainly didn't design the cooling system with NVMe drives in mind. I'm now getting idle temps of 28 degrees vs 33 degrees Celsius. Not a huge mod but definitely could be useful for those running Samsung NVMes.
Stan
I'm using a Mid-2014 15" MacBook Pro retina (A1398) with a 512GB Adata XPG SX8200 Pro
Are the options for the 2015 13" models the same as the 2015 15" models?
I may be buying a 2015 13" for someone and putting in an NVMe drive but I only have experience with the 2015 15" NVMe situation.
I may be buying a 2015 13" for someone and putting in an NVMe drive but I only have experience with the 2015 15" NVMe situation.
I put NVMe SSDs into: 2013 15" and 2015 13" using the big black Sintech. No difference at all (except for the known hibernation issue on the 2013), the 2015 model works like a charm for months now w/o any issues (under Mojave).
This one: https://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B01CWWAENG/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o03_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Sintech NGFF M.2 2280 JPU128T SD6PQ4 M aka "Sintech long black"
Sintech NGFF M.2 2280 JPU128T SD6PQ4 M aka "Sintech long black"
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Great thread! Read last 30 pages or so, and I'm planning to do an SSD upgrade for my late 2013 15" Pro 500GB.
Was thinking XPG SX8200 Pro 1TB, and have seen a number of mentions of other 1TB, but ...
Has anyone had similar positive experience, lack of overheating or any issues (other than hibernate) with any 2TB SSDs?
Was thinking XPG SX8200 Pro 1TB, and have seen a number of mentions of other 1TB, but ...
Has anyone had similar positive experience, lack of overheating or any issues (other than hibernate) with any 2TB SSDs?
Hey,
and first of all thanks for this great source of information. My mid-2014 MacBook Pro just got new SSD from OWC and has the same issue with sleeping as described in this forum.
I'm planning on flashing the NVMe drivers since the ability to hibernate is critical for me (also wife NEVER EVER remembers to shut down the Mac, so hard reset has become a part of a daily operation for us:/ ).
I just ordered the programmer and the clamp so I'm set with the hardware part.
After flashing the modified bootrom can I just reboot the Mac? In the instructions it says reinstall MacOs, but is this really necessary? I am already on latest Mojave, and I don't need a backup since I lost my files anyway couple weeks back when the ssd failed. I haven't put anything important to my Mac since finding out about the sleep/wake-issue.
and first of all thanks for this great source of information. My mid-2014 MacBook Pro just got new SSD from OWC and has the same issue with sleeping as described in this forum.
I'm planning on flashing the NVMe drivers since the ability to hibernate is critical for me (also wife NEVER EVER remembers to shut down the Mac, so hard reset has become a part of a daily operation for us:/ ).
I just ordered the programmer and the clamp so I'm set with the hardware part.
After flashing the modified bootrom can I just reboot the Mac? In the instructions it says reinstall MacOs, but is this really necessary? I am already on latest Mojave, and I don't need a backup since I lost my files anyway couple weeks back when the ssd failed. I haven't put anything important to my Mac since finding out about the sleep/wake-issue.
Hi,
Yes you can just reboot the mac. Your "patched" BootRom will turn on your mac as the unpatched original one, with the only modification of supporting hibernation.
In the process of patching the BootRom, we only replace the compressed NVMe DXE driver of the 2013-2014 rMBP with the uncompressed ones from the 2015 rMBP. The rest of the BootRom remains unchanged.
Be sure to have a backup of your BootRom in case things turn wrong.
By the way, be conscious that you will be given alerts from the "eficheck" program on a regular monthly basis.
This is normal and harmfull : this is only a notification that the BootRom has been modified, which is normal and expected in our case
Hi everyone,
First : I've updated the first post of this thread with a sort of mix of important informations. Hope this will help.
Secondly, thanks to the advice of user macgeek01, I've bought, tested and added to my comparison tables a Sabrent Rocket 512 GB SSD.
And this baby is very impressive : cheap, fast, and very low power consumption. I highly recommend it, as much as the SX8200.
It is 4K sectors native so it also runs from Sierra (with an updated BootRom of course) :
First : I've updated the first post of this thread with a sort of mix of important informations. Hope this will help.
Secondly, thanks to the advice of user macgeek01, I've bought, tested and added to my comparison tables a Sabrent Rocket 512 GB SSD.
And this baby is very impressive : cheap, fast, and very low power consumption. I highly recommend it, as much as the SX8200.
It is 4K sectors native so it also runs from Sierra (with an updated BootRom of course) :
Can you elaborate why there is a separate column for "can be formatted in 4K sectors", what are the advantages of 4k LBA, and do those apply significantly also for Windows machines, but not only Macs? How do you check if a drive can be formatted in 4k?
Do you think that the ADATA SX8200 PRO drive differs sufficiently from the tested SX8200 version? To your experience how is the power consumption of same models 512GB drives vs 1TB, are they likely to be identical? Can the SX8200 PRO be formatted in 4k, if the plain SX8200 cannot?
I've been having some issues with the SX8200 PRO, the TBW increase with at least 0.1/day and there is no way that I write 100GB/day to the SSD... hibernate is off, as well as hybrid sleep. Furthermore, ADATA's customer service is disgusting, they seem like some newbie Chinese with little knowledge of English. Here are some of their customer service replies:
"Dear customer
Thanks for supporting ADATA product.
We suggest you download the ssdtoolbox to check the healthy of ssd.
Best Regards,
ADATA Technology "
"Dear Customer,
Thanks for supporting ADATA product.
Per checked, we haven't met this issue and tested ok, please double check with your pc.
Regards,
ADATA Customer Service Center"
Also, that is how their SSD ToolBox software looks like, and after I reported it, they answered that the problem is in my computer
, which is LOL
Do you think that the ADATA SX8200 PRO drive differs sufficiently from the tested SX8200 version? To your experience how is the power consumption of same models 512GB drives vs 1TB, are they likely to be identical? Can the SX8200 PRO be formatted in 4k, if the plain SX8200 cannot?
I've been having some issues with the SX8200 PRO, the TBW increase with at least 0.1/day and there is no way that I write 100GB/day to the SSD... hibernate is off, as well as hybrid sleep. Furthermore, ADATA's customer service is disgusting, they seem like some newbie Chinese with little knowledge of English. Here are some of their customer service replies:
"Dear customer
Thanks for supporting ADATA product.
We suggest you download the ssdtoolbox to check the healthy of ssd.
Best Regards,
ADATA Technology "
"Dear Customer,
Thanks for supporting ADATA product.
Per checked, we haven't met this issue and tested ok, please double check with your pc.
Regards,
ADATA Customer Service Center"
Also, that is how their SSD ToolBox software looks like, and after I reported it, they answered that the problem is in my computer
, which is LOL
Last edited:
Awesome, thanks! Happy to see it performs well up against the competition.
Have you seen any speed benefits with 4K native blocks opposed to 512 emulated? Or is the benefit just in error correction? Thanks again!
If anyone is considering the Sabrent Rocket, if you order on Amazon with these codes, price will drop to listed:
2 TB - code 10GPJSJA - $359.99
1 TB - code 11ARTQT2 - $159.02
512 GB - code 11ARTQT2 - $79.91
2 TB - code 10GPJSJA - $359.99
1 TB - code 11ARTQT2 - $159.02
512 GB - code 11ARTQT2 - $79.91
Last edited: