Hard to figure out an alternative without judging any pricing for your area, where are you located?
USA
Hard to figure out an alternative without judging any pricing for your area, where are you located?
ended with a WD Blue SN580 2TBI have a mbp mid 2015 a1398 with a dying Adata XPG SX8200 Pro 1tb
I like to replace it with a 2tb nvme. (can a mid 2015 macbook pro handle a 2tb drive?)
I have the option between these drives. which one would you guys reccomend?
Personal I think the SN570 would be a save choice?
- Samsung 970 Evo Plus 2TB ( I read this ssd get delivered with a Phoenix or Elpis controller, so not sure what you get)
- WD Blue SN570 2TB
- WD Black SN770 2TB
- Crucial P3 2TB (CT2000P3SSD8)
Maybe some of these? (100-110 OK for you?)
Sorry I missed this. I wound up not getting it. Instead I played it safe and got a used legit Apple SSD from a 2013 trashcan Mac Pro off eBay, because I wanted to dual boot into macOS El Capitan to use with an old DJ mixer and you can't do that with an adapter. The trashcan SSD has been working really well; all I had to do was remove the heat sink with a hair dryer and a spudger.Hello, how has the intel 670p been in your MacBook Pro ? Any issues? I experienced some slow down running applications. Wondering if you experienced the same.
With the hardware variations that may occur between each drive it is difficult to predict what sort of figures you may get without testing each option.Are any/all of those quite lower power like the P31 do you know?
That was the big draw for the P31 Gold
No issues here with the P31 and short Sintech adapter in my MBA 2013. Can you go back to the last working OS? I'd see if that runs with the P31. Note, though, that it's my understanding that to successfully install an NVMe SSD, the Mac had to have been updated to Catalina or later because of a necessary firmware update. Also take a look at the OCLP Ventura thread.I have just upgraded a 2013 13inch MacBook Air with a P31 Gold and at the same time upgraded to Ventura via OCLP. Both the latest version.
i am now getting random crashes caused by windowserver, where the display freezes but say a zoom call can still be heard and interacted with the only way to recover is to reboot the machine ?
i assume the is Ventura related not related to the SSD upgrade ?
Since you've confirmed that the WD isn't at fault, since it boots from an external enclosure—presumably you'd get the same result with the P31 if you were to install Big Sur on it?—it sounds as if the problem is elsewhere. Had you connected the Timetec to the logic board with the same Sintech adapters or something else? I ask because you were briefly successful with a third-party NVMe SSD, which rules out a need for a firmware update. It's possible you've been unlucky with faulty adapters, but it's also possible you've got some other hardware issue. Can you find a way to run hardware diagnostics on the machine? It would be nice if the Apple Store could do that at least, even if it's beyond Apple's repair horizon.Hi everybody!
My configuration is:
Two months ago my original Apple SSD 256 GB stopped working and I was suggested to make an attempt to change it by myself because it’s out of date and at the Apple Store couldn’t fix it up.
- MacBook Pro Retina 13" late 2013 (MacBookPro11,1)
- 2,4 GHz Intel Core i5 dual-core
- 8 GB 1600 MHz DDR3
- macOS Big Sur 11.7.10
- Firmware 478.0.0.0.0
At first I tried with this Timetec which worked two weeks. In this short period of time, also the original Apple SSD booted occasionally.
After that Timetec SSD caused MacBook not to turn on (black screen with fan working at low speed, can't execute SMC and NVRAM reset or any other key combination).
Therefore I found this forum and I decided to buy Sintech adapters (short and long) and a WD SN570 1 TB.
Unfortunately with this setting Macbook does not boot, I have a grey screen (SMC and NVRAM reset work but do not change anything, safe boot doesn’t work). I succed in installing macOS Big Sur with a USB enclosure from a bootable USB drive. WD SSD boots if in the enclosure but not if assembled on MacBook.
I didn’t give up so I bought a SK Hynix Gold P31 but I obtain the Grey Flashing Folder Question Mark (the same with original Apple SSD).
Nothing change if I install Big Sur with the USB enclosure and then mount the p31 on the logic board (SSD not detectable, folder question mark).
I think it should be a problem of the connector on the logic board, am I wrong?
Don’t know if I should try with a used original Apple SSD on eBay or change the logic board.
Thank you very much for suggestions!
F
Since you've confirmed that the WD isn't at fault, since it boots from an external enclosure—presumably you'd get the same result with the P31 if you were to install Big Sur on it?—it sounds as if the problem is elsewhere. Had you connected the Timetec to the logic board with the same Sintech adapters or something else? I ask because you were briefly successful with a third-party NVMe SSD, which rules out a need for a firmware update. It's possible you've been unlucky with faulty adapters, but it's also possible you've got some other hardware issue. Can you find a way to run hardware diagnostics on the machine? It would be nice if the Apple Store could do that at least, even if it's beyond Apple's repair horizon.
You've probably already looked into VDH002 errors, but here's a link to an iFixit forum thread that mentions it, along with a couple of testing and repair gambits.Yes, I have the same result with p31 with Big Sur and Windows 10 (bootable form external drive, not if assembled). I don't think it's a problem of the adapters (same result with either short and long Sintech and with another one non-Sintech adapter). Timetec SSD has 12-14 pin connector, no adapter need.
Diagnostic tool shows VDH002 error. At the Apple Store the hardware diagnostic showed a storage problem (at that time was original Apple SSD mounted).
Thank you
Hmnn, so you slot in the Timetec nvme without the adapter?Timetec SSD has 12-14 pin connector, no adapter need.
Hmnn, so you slot in the Timetec nvme without the adapter?
I wonder if that is something correct to do. If not, it could have damaged the nvme as well as the logic board socket.
Not sure.
You've probably already looked into VDH002 errors, but here's a link to an iFixit forum thread that mentions it, along with a couple of testing and repair gambits.
20€ isn't much to invest in a test an SSD. That said, my hunch is it's a logic board issue. At that point I'd think about donating or selling the laptop, since it's already 11 years old, and finding a new or used replacement, unless you like fixing stuff just for fun.I think my option are buying an used original Apple SSD (20-30€) to confirm it's not a SSD issue or directly try to change the logic board (150€).
What do you think?
20€ isn't much to invest in a test an SSD. That said, my hunch is it's a logic board issue. At that point I'd think about donating or selling the laptop, since it's already 11 years old, and finding a new or used replacement, unless you like fixing stuff just for fun.
I believe that is all hardware limited (the config is set by Apple and cannot be altered)1) Are the number of lanes for PCIe (x2 or x4) determined by the SSD or the motherboard? Will my 2013 support x4 or will it always be x2? In System Report under SATA, under Apple controller, I'm currently seeing a "link width" of x2.
Something like an SN570/580 would work as a baseline for your needs (decent value of performance/power draw)2) Which 1TB would you recommend to maximize speeds but also have low power consumption? I don't want to pick one that's too fast for what my MBP can support anyway (related to question 1).
I believe they have been mostly fixed, but if issues persist you can try updating the NVME driver (using a file from a later model machine supposedly can fix some issues; some of them may be related to the DXE file used in the previous firmware but you will have to do this with great care)3) As far as I understand, the hibernation issues have been resolved with the bootrom from Big Sur. Are there any other limitations left?
I believe that is all hardware limited (the config is set by Apple and cannot be altered)
Something like an SN570/580 would work as a baseline for your needs (decent value of performance/power draw)
Thanks! My original drive is PCI 2.0 2x, but I believe the motherboard actually supports PCI 2.0 4x? And this is actually where a lot of the improvement in speed will come from? Can anyone confirm this for a late 2013 15"?
I believe there are a few reports of the SN580 working (you can search this thread here), but you will be speed limited with the narrow bus (which is why a lot of people will recommend the now outdated Gen3 devices)I was reading this thread for hours again last night and learned a lot. Sounds like maybe the "best" contender is the SK Hynix P31 as it presents no issues and is the most power efficient.
Has the SN580 been successfully confirmed to work? It's a Gen 4 and I read a dozen pages back to try and stick to Gen 3. It's cheaper than the SN570 on Amazon right now. The Kioxia Exceria also seems to be highly recommended but I can't find a 1TB available on Amazon right now.
Interesting.. Why not use Monterey? Been running fine on my 2015 Air for a long time. Did you try to remake the Catalina installer? I just realized you had SX8100.. Are those compatible? I have the 2TB SX8200 Pro..Hi. Maybe somebody knows. I have inserted 4TB ADATA SX8100 to mbp15 2015 and trying to install macOS. Monterey installer is seeing the SSD, but if I try to install Catalina installer is not seeing the SSD. How can I resolve this kind of problem? I like Catalina and I want to install definitely it.
I can't stand new interface design. And I like the old design a lot. I've also heard that silicon versions of OS can carry out increased wear on the ssd. I will try, thank you. This installer was made in 2020. Compatible. Monterey works fine. I use SX8200 pro 2TB on my mbp13 2015 too.Interesting.. Why not use Monterey? Been running fine on my 2015 Air for a long time. Did you try to remake the Catalina installer? I just realized you had SX8100.. Are those compatible? I have the 2TB SX8200 Pro..