I'll agree that the adjustment slider can be a little finicky--don't lift your finger off perfectly and the setting can wobble a bit. However, when I touch the slider to adjust the brightness, the dimming prompted by opening Control Center goes away and is replaced by the true screen brightness, for as long as my finger is on the slider. Is it not doing this for you?
Ah damn you're right! I didn't realise that's what it was doing, thanks for pointing that out That's why I thought the brightness was changing so dramatically when I released my finger - it was actually going back from the true brightness to the dimmed screen. My bad.
Having tested again knowing this, ofc this works much better but I would prefer if it didn't dim the top portion of the screen in the first case. All that back and forth between brightness values makes it hard to remember the original level and thus harder to calibrate. Will get better as I get more used to it though I'm sure.
Forgive me in case anything has changed as it's been a few months since I've used Android with any regularity but doesn't the notification/quick settings panel fill the entire screen when pulled down? Wouldn't it then obscure whatever you were watching?
It does, but I like that the video continues anyway, it makes for a more seamless experience imo. And when following a live stream sometimes you can't pause anyway, so having the settings operation pause it automatically would simply mean a few seconds missed when you could at least have followed the sound. For vids, I just pause then change the brightness if I don't want to miss any of the visuals.
Determining the right brightness level still works well despite the actual video picture being obscured - since the brightness value doesn't change when I pull down the shade, I can still determine the right relative brightness change by seeing how much the light in the notifications shade changes.
----------
The notification shade hides once you move the brightness bar allowing you to see whatever is on the screen, at least on L.
That's very nice, didn't know this. What I was describing above is how it is on my Note 2.