Been playing these two pretty much since release with the battle of good versus evil still raging on LOL. Both games are now on fresher fields and platforms

due to updated
source ports with many bug fixes & improvements. Better still now
native to Apple silicon & 64-Bit Intel thx to
Mac Source Ports.
Doom 3 (2004)
View attachment 2092245
A survival horror focused FPS that genuinely gets under your skin. Quite literally a very dark experience.
dhewm3 (source port) Keeps the original experience with bug fixes and far better support for newer operating systems and hardware.
Dev:
"Compared to the original version of Doom3, dhewm3 has many bugfixes, supports EAX-like sound effects on all operating systems and hardware (via OpenAL Softs EFX support), has much better support for widescreen resolutions and has 64bit support."
Doom 3 BFG (2012)
View attachment 2092246
Feels and plays more action focused, reduces the tension of the original in trade for some quality-of-life mechanics. I tend to drop the brightness to match as close as possible the original as I like the horror aspect.
RBDOOM-3-BFG (source port) vastly improves immersion due to a complete overhaul of the games lighting systems.
Dev:
"RBDOOM-3-BFG is based on DOOM-3-BFG and the goal of this port is to bring DOOM-3-BFG up to latest technology in 2021 making it closer to Doom 2016 while still remaining a DOOM 3 port regarding the gameplay."
Naturally the battle continues to which is the better game LOL. Personally, I like both and therefore have the best of both worlds
Both source ports are freely distributed; however, you will require the original game data files to play either title. Those that want to install on Apple Silicon or 64-Bit Intel need to download from
Mac Source Ports.
Q-6