Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
I had pops and creaks in two copies of the Gen 5. I also noticed that the hard surfaces around the camera and logo insert are raised above the microfiber lining, which seems like a design faux pas that may eventually cause scuffs on the phone. That‘s unfortunate because it’s a superb case otherwise.

Regarding the Sheath, I received one of the new versions with the updated buttons and MagSafe indentation fix. Unfortunately, it seems they didn’t totally fix the indentation issue. After just one night on a Belkin charger the indentation has shown up. It will undoubtedly get worse over time which happened with the other copies I‘ve already returned.

View attachment 2329217
To be fair I don’t remember that the MagSafe indentation was going to be addressed just the buttons with some minor tweaks. That’s what the email said from Caudabe.

They need to get rid of the felt liner, then put whatever sh*t they use where it needs to be to stop the condom ring.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Zensō
To be fair I don’t remember that the MagSafe indentation was going to be addressed just the buttons with some minor tweaks. That’s what the email said from Caudabe.

They need to get rid of the felt liner, then put whatever sh*t they use where it needs to be to stop the condom ring.
One of their social media reps told me straight up that the indentation problem was solved. This was in the comments under one of their social media posts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Djones96
To be fair I don’t remember that the MagSafe indentation was going to be addressed just the buttons with some minor tweaks. That’s what the email said from Caudabe.

They need to get rid of the felt liner, then put whatever sh*t they use where it needs to be to stop the condom ring.

I've got multiple Sheaths for my family including mine. All except one have no visible MagSafe indentation on the back. On my dad's I can kind of see it but it's not an issue that would bug him or me if I had it. The cases are otherwise performing fantastic and we've been using these for months now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
My Synthesis is being shipped today should get it Thursday. I hope mine is the new buttons.
Are you sure the Synthesis has the revised buttons? I emailed them previously and I thought they mentioned that it was coming later? I'll check my emails later, but I'm pretty sure that's what they said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
I've got multiple Sheaths for my family including mine. All except one have no visible MagSafe indentation on the back. On my dad's I can kind of see it but it's not an issue that would bug him or me if I had it. The cases are otherwise performing fantastic and we've been using these for months now.
Your odds are much better than mine have been. Three out of four of mine had the indentation. In each case the indentation worsened with use.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
Are you sure the Synthesis has the revised buttons? I emailed them previously and I thought they mentioned that it was coming later? I'll check my emails later, but I'm pretty sure that's what they said.
Cross-post from the Caudabe thread:


I received the email from Caudabe on Friday afternoon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
I've got multiple Sheaths for my family including mine. All except one have no visible MagSafe indentation on the back. On my dad's I can kind of see it but it's not an issue that would bug him or me if I had it. The cases are otherwise performing fantastic and we've been using these for months now.
What color Sheaths? I’m really starting to think I might like the Sheath over the Synthesis. The all over texture comes in handy more than I thought it would.
 
One of their social media reps told me straight up that the indentation problem was solved. This was in the comments under one of their social media posts.
Just to back this, when I initially emailed Caudabe about a replacement case, I specifically said that the main problems I was having were with the MagSafe indentation, and the buttons, they had me email them a picture, and after I did that, they sent me a replacement case stating that the indentation problem would be fixed. This was the picture I sent them, so yes, they did say the indentation problem would be fixed with revised cases.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1938.jpeg
    IMG_1938.jpeg
    334.9 KB · Views: 68
No more Frosty love?

What is the correct way to install your phone into the Frosty without damaging the interior frost?
I usually install my cases from the volume side to the power button side and my Frosty got damaged.
Maybe better from the top or bottom?
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
Just to back this, when I initially emailed Caudabe about a replacement case, I specifically said that the main problems I was having were with the MagSafe indentation, and the buttons, they had me email them a picture, and after I did that, they sent me a replacement case stating that the indentation problem would be fixed. This was the picture I sent them, so yes, they did say the indentation problem would be fixed with revised cases.

I try and take a pic and mine and you can’t see it in a pic.

However what’s interesting is in the middle of the MagSafe on back feels very slightly spongy than the rest of the case if that makes sense.
 
Ref Caudabe

Seen multiple posts about the revised versions. I don’t use MagSafe so the ring issue isn’t a factor to me, but can I just double check..

Do we know for certain, if I order a Synthesis and Sheath today in celestial blue for my 15 Pro (non-max) am I getting the versions with new buttons?
 
  • Like
Reactions: walds11
Ref Caudabe

Seen multiple posts about the revised versions. I don’t use MagSafe so the ring issue isn’t a factor to me, but can I just double check..

Do we know for certain, if I order a Synthesis and Sheath today in celestial blue for my 15 Pro (non-max) am I getting the versions with new buttons?
For certain I got a Sheath with new buttons and buttons are great.

Not so certain is an email was responded to from @walds11 saying as of Friday 12/22 that the Synthesis would be new version.

I’m getting my Synthesis most likely Thursday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: walds11
Just as I’d been saying I’ve got enough cases, I won a Spigen OG case giveaway! The universe is on my side when it comes to my phone case addiction 😂 I asked for an Enzo Aramid (not an OG case) as my first pick, or frosted Ultra Hybrid if it wasn’t possible. Tracking says it’ll get here tomorrow, so we’ll see what they’ve sent me! Either way I’ll be stoked to receive a free case from them.
 
Bandwerk is sold. Cant really think of any other cases I’m waiting for now besides the turquoise Andar. Maybe it’s time I start buying MagSafe wallets to feed the addiction lol. Still need to buy a sheath tho, I like the synthesis I bought from hooterville I believe but the volume buttons are garbage lol.

Hopefully the next rebel frost has interchangeable MagSafe ring colors
 
I contacted Caudabe on social media and they just got back to me:

Hey there! At this time we are working on making small adjustments to the buttons on Synthesis. These updates aren’t reflected in existing cases but are anticipated around early to mid January.

I specifically asked about the Synthesis. They obviously provided misinformation in their reply to my email on Friday. Anyway, I ordered the Synthesis celestial blue on Friday based on that information (already received shipping email and should receive before EOW). Oh well. I am still excited about the case and will deal with the crap buttons, for now. I am sure they will make it right by sending me the updated Synthesis when it is available.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: Zensō and macher
For certain I got a Sheath with new buttons and buttons are great.

Not so certain is an email was responded to from @walds11 saying as of Friday 12/22 that the Synthesis would be new version.

I’m getting my Synthesis most likely Thursday.

Thanks for that. Look forward to hearing ref your new Synthesis buttons then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macher
Thing I hate about the black Sheath is that the edges turn kind of a lighter/white shade and do not clean up.

I was going to order another Sheath but think I'll hold off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zensō
Caudabe claims 6.6ft drop protection but Apple doesn’t claim anything.

6.6ft is good for me which is about chest height.

After having my popsocket on overnight when I first received the Sheath I’ve gotten a VERY slight indentation. You really have to look to notice. I usually don’t use the pop socket but wanted to test it. I don’t use MagSafe either. I’m ok with it as it is now. I really like the Sheath. For those that are MagSafe heavy it’s definitely an issue.

I think all us who like the Sheath should contact Caudabe and help them out. Seems like past Sheaths haven’t had the problem. It’s their flagship case too.

Here’s an article from Caudabe that I theorize back fired on them implementing a liner. They compromised the back of the case. Their intentions were good but it back fired.

What’s your take?

Chest height?! Are you 8ft tall??
 
Thing I hate about the black Sheath is that the edges turn kind of a lighter/white shade and do not clean up.

I was going to order another Sheath but think I'll hold off.

I requested a return for the new revised Sheath I received. I just cannot enjoy the feeling of this case after a long period of time holding the phone. For me, it's just a weird feeling and just cannot get on board with it.
 
Still loving mine, I install it from the bottom then push in the top. Not sure if it makes much of a difference but I haven't lost any frost yet. I try to make sure the phone is pushed down as far as it will go without rubbing the back first just to be safe.
No more Frosty love?

What is the correct way to install your phone into the Frosty without damaging the interior frost?
I usually install my cases from the volume side to the power button side and my Frosty got damaged.
Maybe better from the top or bottom?
 
Or if you don’t mind open bottom, I just got an email from Bullstrap they’re having a flash sale 25% off (on top of their store wide 15% off). Code: “CHRISTMASCASH” expires tonight
Excellent deal they have. I am tempted for another. Already have 4 from them 🤣
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.