I’d happily pay more for a Sheath with excellent metal buttons.
The 15PM Sheath is 47 grams vs the Pitaka Pro at 40 grams. The Pitaka is stiffer, with a more precise fit, and also has air pockets around the perimeter, which appears to make it more protective than the Sheath, regardless of the claims made by the manufacturers, which should always be taken with a big dose of salt.
I believe it’s unwise to take these drop tests at face value. How many times were the phones dropped, at what angles, on which surfaces, how many resulted in damage, how did they define damage, and so on. The claimed difference between a 4’ and 6.6’ drop test is meaningless really.
To me, the Sheath’s killer feature is the surface texture, which some love and others hate. I like that it’s essentially fingerprint-free and provides a good amount of grip, but not so much that it causes other problems. My ideal case would be the Pitaka Pro with its near perfect fit, camera surround, buttons, and weight, combined with the surface texture of the Sheath. I’d happily pay top dollar for that case and that would be the last you’d hear from me on this thread. 😊