Just received the Pitaka MagEz 5 and I’m pretty disappointed in the feel and grip in comparison to the Benks ArmorAir, especially considering it’s twice the price. The aramid feel of the Benks is far more pronounced and grippy. I suppose that’s the trade off for it being thinner and lighter. I’d happily take the extra 10g (the Benks is super light at 27g anyway) if it means the feel of the case is better in hand.
I felt the exact same way. I have used Pitaka cases for years and loved them. But the case 4 was bulky, the case 5 is not as grippy, and both of them have sharp edges instead of matching the curved edges of the new phone models.
I've tried a ton of aramid fiber cases for the 15PM (Pitaka, Benks, Latercase, Memumi, Thinborne, and some off-brands as well) and none have been perfect. The thinnest 0.5mm Memumi is the best so far for grip and hand feel, but the Thinborne is second and is a bit thicker so more protective. Latercase also feels good, but not as grippy as the Memumi and MagSafe doesn't work as well through the case (neither has the magnets, but the memumi is at least decent enough). The Pitaka, other Memumi and Benks cases all have sharp edges on the sides of the phone, which imho really defeats the purpose of a minimalistic case to begin with.
So imho, only the Memumi and Thinborne are good options if you care about preserving the hand feel of the phones while just adding some grip. Overall, the design of the Thinborne, with the integrated magnets and lower profile lip on the front is best, but I've now received two defective units and am awaiting support for a fix (the first one had a corner that was deformed and didn't fit over the phone, and the second one was deformed in two corners, making it near impossible to remove). The issue with the ultra thin Memumi is that it's also very difficult to remove and doesn't have MagSafe.
If Thinborne can't send me a non-defective unit then I'll likely just stick with the Memumi. Really disappointed in the aramid options for this latest phone.
EDIT: Thinborne customer service is horrendous and their quality control is poor. Returning the case and likely just sticking with the Memumi one until something better comes along.